Are Conscientious Student-Loan Defaulters a Threat?

Some think defaulting on student loans might be the new draft-card burning, and could force the government to address rising tuition and $1.2 trillion in student debt.

National Journal
J. Weston Phippen
Add to Briefcase
J. Weston Phippen
June 23, 2015, 11:58 a.m.

A group of stu­dents called the Cor­inthi­an 100 pur­pose­fully de­faul­ted on their stu­dent loans. It was a play to protest Cor­inthi­an Col­leges, a private, for-profit school chain that has been called pred­at­ory and has been ac­cused of mis­lead­ing low-in­come stu­dents in­to con­sid­er­able debt for de­grees that some have called worth­less. The protest worked. On June 8, the gov­ern­ment an­nounced that it would for­give the stu­dents’ loans.

Each year, tu­ition rises at private and pub­lic col­leges, as does the amount of debt stu­dents carry with them after gradu­ation. So while the Cor­inthi­an stu­dents had some­what unique cir­cum­stances (for-profit de­grees have re­cently come un­der at­tack), their de­fi­ance raises the ques­tion: What if hun­dreds of thou­sands or even mil­lions of stu­dents de­faul­ted on their loans as a form of protest—a massive move­ment to “burn” the promis­sory note?

An­drew Ross, a pro­fess­or at New York Uni­versity, wants people to do just this.

“It’s a wide­spread con­sensus that this is a huge crisis for fu­ture gen­er­a­tions,” Ross says.

Ross was an early mem­ber of the Oc­cupy Wall Street move­ment. He is the au­thor of a book called Cred­ito­cracy: And the Case for Debt Re­fus­al. He also con­trib­uted to the Debt Res­isters’ Op­er­a­tions Manu­al, pub­lished by Strike Debt, an off­shoot of the Oc­cupy move­ment.

The Oc­cupy move­ment has fo­cused a lot on debt, hav­ing cre­ated or­gan­iz­a­tions like Rolling Ju­bilee, which buys health care and stu­dent debt (about $32 mil­lion so far, ac­cord­ing to its web­site), and the Debt Col­lect­ive, which helped or­gan­ize the Cor­inthi­an stu­dent-loan protests.

The reas­on for the debt fo­cus, Ross says, is be­cause an edu­ca­tion is the best way to im­prove a per­son’s stand­ing in life, yet the U.S. edu­ca­tion­al sys­tem is widen­ing gaps of in­equal­ity. “It’s been turned in­to the cruelest of debt trap,” Ross says, “where stu­dents from only the most well-heeled fam­il­ies can es­cape.”

Stu­dent Debt Crisis is an­oth­er or­gan­iz­a­tion that fo­cuses on stu­dent debt. And while it sup­por­ted the Cor­inthi­an 100, Ex­ec­ut­ive Dir­ect­or Nat­alia Ab­rams doesn’t ask people to de­fault. What the group has done is pro­pose two fed­er­al bills in 2012 and 2013 that would have re­pur­posed money from cor­por­ate wel­fare to help pay off stu­dent debt, a move the group be­lieves would have stim­u­lated the eco­nomy from the bot­tom up.

More than 1.2 mil­lion people signed a pe­ti­tion in sup­port, but both bills fell short in Con­gress. Ab­rams ad­vises against vol­un­tary de­fault be­cause “it’s just so det­ri­ment­al, I can’t in good faith ask people to do that.”

Stu­dent loans are dif­fer­ent than al­most any oth­er type of debt. Adam Min­sky, a law­yer who spe­cial­izes in stu­dent loans, says the gov­ern­ment doesn’t even have to take a debt­or to court. Without a court or­der, the gov­ern­ment can gar­nish wages (typ­ic­ally around 15 per­cent of in­come), and with­hold any fed­er­al stream of money, like tax re­funds and So­cial Se­cur­ity.

“They can lit­er­ally pur­sue you un­til you die,” Min­sky says.

In nearly two dozen states, de­fault­ers can have their pro­fes­sion­al li­censes re­voked. In a few, they can even lose their driver’s li­censes. With all this, plus back in­terest, stu­dents who de­fault will likely end up pay­ing much more than they ori­gin­ally bor­rowed. In ad­di­tion, de­fault­ing can ru­in someone’s cred­it.

“Cred­it com­pan­ies don’t care if you didn’t pay the loan be­cause you were dead­beat or mak­ing a protest,” says Dav­id Wessel, dir­ect­or of the Hutchins Cen­ter on Fisc­al and Mon­et­ary Policy at the Brook­ings In­sti­tute.

What hasn’t been talked about much, however, is the po­ten­tial im­pact on the eco­nomy if such a move­ment were to ac­tu­ally gain pop­ular­ity.

The av­er­age col­lege seni­or who gradu­ated from a pub­lic or private non­profit col­lege in 2013 owed $28,400, ac­cord­ing to a re­port by The In­sti­tute for Col­lege Ac­cess & Suc­cess.

Some simple math would lead one to con­clude that if 1 mil­lion people were to de­fault, this would mean a $28 bil­lion bar­gain­ing chip for “con­scien­tious stu­dent-loan de­fault­ers.”

“You really have to break that up in two dif­fer­ent parts,” says Douglas Webber, an as­so­ci­ate pro­fess­or of eco­nom­ics at Temple Uni­versity. “There are gov­ern­ment-backed stu­dent loans and private stu­dent loans, and it’s very easy to pre­dict what will hap­pen in the private mar­ket.”

In the private mar­ket, Webber says, that massive de­fault would in­crease ex­ist­ing stu­dent-loan in­terest rates. Lenders would re­duce the amount of money they loaned to stu­dents, and pos­sibly, stop lend­ing al­to­geth­er.

“It’s a little more dif­fi­cult to talk about what will hap­pen on the gov­ern­ment end,” Webber says. The gov­ern­ment would re­coup it some­where, either from taxes or cuts to ser­vices, or it could just lump it in­to the na­tion­al debt ($18.2 tril­lion and count­ing), he says.

The fed­er­al gov­ern­ment can sue uni­versit­ies for that money. But this is un­likely to hap­pen un­less, as in the Cor­inthi­an case, there are leg­al grounds to be­lieve the school preyed upon its stu­dents. Most likely the gov­ern­ment will re­claim it from the debt­or.

The idea of a wide-scale con­scien­tious stu­dent-loan de­fault­er move­ment has even less of an im­pact giv­en that about 650,000 people de­faul­ted on their loans last year, and there was no ir­re­vers­ible ef­fect set in mo­tion on the part of banks or the gov­ern­ment.

Ul­ti­mately, both Webber and Wessel say, any im­pact to the eco­nomy would be min­im­al.

What a col­lect­ive de­fault could do, though, they say, is fo­cus polit­ic­al aware­ness around rising costs of tu­ition, and an edu­ca­tion­al sys­tem that is in­creas­ingly strat­i­fied and un­equal.

What Ross and the Debt Col­lect­ive hope to ac­com­plish is to em­phas­ize that an edu­ca­tion is a so­cial right, and that the U.S. should join the grow­ing list of coun­tries that provide a free col­lege edu­ca­tion. With a col­lect­ive de­fault, Ross says, someone’s bound to pay at­ten­tion.

“It’s not just about money, it’s about demo­cracy,” Ross says. “If you look back at the civil-rights move­ment, one of the most right­eous de­mands was to open the col­legi­al doors to a pop­u­la­tion who had been denied the right to an edu­ca­tion. And now the right to edu­ca­tion has been re­placed by the right to ac­cess edu­ca­tion­al loans.”

What We're Following See More »
Allegations Against Jackson Include Drinking, Hostile Environment
39 minutes ago
Sanders To Announce Plan For Federal Jobs Guarantee
1 hours ago

"Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT.) will announce a plan for the federal government to guarantee a job paying $15 an hour and health-care benefits to every American worker 'who wants or needs one,' embracing the kind of large-scale government works project that Democrats have shied away from in recent decades. Sanders's jobs guarantee would fund hundreds of projects throughout the United States aimed at addressing priorities such as infrastructure, care giving, the environment, education and other goals." The idea would be dead on arrival in the Republican controlled Congress, but could signal the economic policies Sanders might embrace in his rumored 2020 presidential run.

Senate Delays VA Secretary Nomination
1 hours ago

The Senate has opted to delay Ronny Jackson's confirmation hearing, President Trump's nominee to lead the Department of Veteran's Affairs, amidst unspecified concerns about his background. "The development came just two days before Jackson, the White House physician, was scheduled to testify before the Senate Committee on Veterans’ Affairs and threw what was looking to be a difficult confirmation process into further jeopardy... 'I can tell you we’re vetting out Jackson,'" said Sen. Jon Tester (D-MT), the committee’s ranking Democrat. "'I can’t get into specifics, but we’re doing our job to make sure he’s fit for the job.'"

Nadler: Goodlatte Could Subpoena Rosenstein
5 days ago

"The top Democrat on the House Judiciary Committee says Chairman Bob Goodlatte, R-Va., is poised to subpoena the Justice Department for former FBI Director James Comey’s memos, which the agency so far has failed to produce. Rep. Jerrold Nadler, D-N.Y., warned such a move puts Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein in jeopardy of being placed in contempt of Congress and the special counsel investigation of being shut down prematurely."

House Ag Committee Passes Farm Bill
5 days ago
"On a party-line vote, the House Agriculture Committee approved a five-year farm bill on Wednesday that tweaks the supports now in place—a promise of certainty, leaders said, during a period of low commodity prices and threats of a trade war with agriculture on the front line." The bill includes no new funding over the last farm bill.

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.