‘Grit’ in Kids is Good, But Here’s What Else They Need

Researchers describe key factors in what constitutes success and how to foster it.

July 10, 2015, noon

As fed­er­al and state edu­ca­tion­al policies have shif­ted to re­ly­ing on stand­ard­ized test­ing and oth­er meas­ure­ments to as­sess young people’s suc­cess, many par­ents, edu­cat­ors, and poli­cy­makers are push­ing back, find­ing that what’s be­ing meas­ured can­not fully ac­count for what young people need to suc­ceed.

For some re­search­ers, this has trans­lated in­to look­ing at the in­flu­ence of non­aca­dem­ic skills—vari­ously de­scribed as emo­tion­al in­tel­li­gence, self-con­trol, or the catchy “grit.” But one big chal­lenge has been agree­ing on what is be­ing de­scribed, as well as what in­ter­ven­tions can best help make a child well-roun­ded, re­si­li­ent, and cap­able in­to adult­hood.

A study by re­search­ers from the Uni­versity of Chica­go tries to set the found­a­tion for al­tern­at­ive ways to meas­ure and foster the skills and aptitudes kids need as they grow.

“It is so com­mon, es­pe­cially in the edu­ca­tion sphere, to define suc­cess in terms of edu­ca­tion­al out­comes like col­lege and ca­reer read­i­ness or col­lege com­ple­tion,” said Stacy Ehr­lich, one of the prin­cip­al in­vest­ig­at­ors. “But the an­swer is much broad­er than just at­tain­ing a col­lege de­gree. We hope for our youth to be happy, en­gaged cit­izens, be healthy, have pos­it­ive re­la­tion­ships with oth­ers, feel like they can make their own de­cisions about how to dir­ect their lives, and have the know-how to do it.”

Re­view­ing re­search from the past two dec­ades on child, ad­oles­cent, and young adult de­vel­op­ment, the re­search­ers con­cluded that in ad­di­tion to de­vel­op­ing cog­nit­ive skills such as crit­ic­al think­ing and the abil­ity to work with oth­ers, young adults need to de­vel­op a sense of agency—the abil­ity to make act­ive choices about their lives, rather than just al­low­ing cir­cum­stances to act on them—and an “in­teg­rated iden­tity”—a stable sense of self from which to make de­cisions.

And much of the re­search the study looks at in­dic­ates that build­ing these parts of char­ac­ter be­gins in the earli­est stages of life, but can be af­fected throughout a young per­son’s de­vel­op­ment.

Preschool chil­dren, for ex­ample, are already de­vel­op­ing the be­gin­nings of agency, want­ing to set goals and make choices about what to do. And per­haps just as im­port­ant for long-term de­vel­op­ment, they are just learn­ing how to con­trol their own im­pulses.

For Bar­bara Abel, a cur­riculum man­ager for a Chica­go early-edu­ca­tion pro­gram in­ter­viewed for the study, this is key. “I’ve been work­ing on chil­dren’s ca­pa­cit­ies to self-reg­u­late in terms of emo­tion­al reg­u­la­tion, be­ha­vi­or­al reg­u­la­tion, and at­ten­tion reg­u­la­tion,” she said.

Once kids reach school age, self-con­trol de­vel­ops in­to an abil­ity to re­flect on their be­ha­vi­ors more crit­ic­ally, which in middle school and high school in­flu­ence their abil­ity to de­vel­op a sense of their own cap­ab­il­ity and their re­la­tion­ships to their peers, and to de­vel­op the mind­set and val­ues that will guide their de­cisions go­ing for­ward.

For Hil­lary Rhodes of the Wal­lace Found­a­tion, the primary fun­der for the study, put­ting names to the prin­ciples be­hind needed in­ter­ven­tions was an im­port­ant step.

“It wasn’t just think­ing about what to do, but the em­phas­is on re­flec­tion,” Rhodes said. “Even if a child has a neg­at­ive ex­per­i­ence, adults, and peers can help re­flect on that ex­per­i­ence, and we have op­por­tun­it­ies all the time to make a dif­fer­ence in a child’s life.”

Child de­vel­op­ment spe­cial­ists such as An­gela Duck­worth, who pop­ular­ized the im­port­ance of “grit,” and Dav­id Yeager, who has stud­ied how young people can learn from fail­ure, warned in a re­cent es­say that fig­ur­ing out how to meas­ure these less-tan­gible as­pects of a young per­son’s abil­it­ies risks fall­ing in­to the trap of mis­quan­ti­fic­a­tion.

But they agree that de­vel­op­ing ways to ac­count for these qual­it­ies is key to de­vel­op­ing more-pro­duct­ive ways to help young people reach their fullest po­ten­tial.

What We're Following See More »
Nadler Subpoenas Unredacted Report
3 days ago
Mueller Made 14 Criminal Referrals
4 days ago
The Report Is Here
4 days ago
Nadler Asks Mueller to Testify By May 23
4 days ago
Barr OK With Mueller Testifying
4 days ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.