Ted Cruz Is Right: NSA Reform Bill Allows More Spying

With terrorism fears running high, Cruz and Rubio traded shots over government surveillance.

Ted Cruz makes a point during the CNN Republican presidential debate on Tuesday in Las Vegas.
AP Photo/John Locher
Brendan Sasso
Add to Briefcase
Brendan Sasso
Dec. 15, 2015, 10:43 p.m.

Sens. Marco Ru­bio and Ted Cruz clashed over their op­pos­ing votes on a key sur­veil­lance bill dur­ing Tues­day night’s GOP de­bate, with each sen­at­or try­ing to es­tab­lish him­self as the strongest on na­tion­al se­cur­ity.

Ru­bio ac­cused Cruz of ham­per­ing in­tel­li­gence agen­cies by sup­port­ing the USA Free­dom Act, which ended the Na­tion­al Se­cur­ity Agency’s vast col­lec­tion of mil­lions of U.S. phone re­cords. That in­form­a­tion could have been crit­ic­al in in­vest­ig­at­ing the shoot­ing in San Bern­ardino, Cali­for­nia, Ru­bio ar­gued. “We are now at a time where we need more tools, not less tools,” the Flor­ida Re­pub­lic­an said. “And that tool we lost, the metadata pro­gram, was a valu­able tool that we no longer have at our dis­pos­al.”

Cruz shot back that Ru­bio “knows what he’s say­ing isn’t true.” The old NSA drag­net, Cruz ar­gued, covered only 20-30 per­cent of call re­cords, where­as the Free­dom Act will ac­tu­ally al­low the agency to col­lect “nearly 100 per­cent” of re­cords. Ru­bio stayed firm, claim­ing that “there is noth­ing that we are al­lowed to do un­der this bill that we could not do be­fore.”

So who is right? Did the Free­dom Act ac­tu­ally give the NSA ac­cess to more re­cords, as Cruz is claim­ing?

Yes, ac­cord­ing to top in­tel­li­gence of­fi­cials. “The over­all volume of call de­tail re­cords sub­ject to query pur­su­ant to court or­der is great­er un­der USA FREE­DOM Act,” the Of­fice of the Dir­ect­or of Na­tion­al In­tel­li­gence wrote in a fact sheet on its im­ple­ment­a­tion of the law last month.

Un­der the old law, the Pat­ri­ot Act, the NSA claimed it had the right to col­lect re­cords on every U.S. phone call. But due to tech­nic­al obstacles, the agency re­portedly struggled to in­teg­rate cell-phone re­cords in­to its data­base. With people in­creas­ingly re­ly­ing on cell phones in­stead of land­lines, the tech­nic­al prob­lems had caused a ma­jor gap in the NSA’s data­base.

Un­der the Free­dom Act, the NSA was re­quired to give up con­trol of the data­base. In­stead, the phone com­pan­ies keep the re­cords them­selves, and the NSA can get court ap­prov­al to search for par­tic­u­lar re­cords. But crit­ic­ally, the law in­cludes a pro­vi­sion that re­quires phone com­pan­ies to provide “tech­nic­al as­sist­ance” to help the NSA ac­cess the data in a read­able format. That pro­vi­sion en­sures the NSA can ac­cess mil­lions of cell-phone re­cords that had pre­vi­ously been bey­ond its reach.

So while the NSA now has few­er re­cords in its dir­ect pos­ses­sion, the uni­verse of phone-call logs it can ac­cess is ac­tu­ally lar­ger.

New Jer­sey Gov. Chris Christie tried to put him­self above the fray by say­ing the de­bate over sur­veil­lance powers shows why the pub­lic hates the Sen­ate—“end­less de­bate about how many an­gels can dance on the head of a pin.”

What We're Following See More »
Lieberman Withdraws from Consideration for FBI Job
2 days ago
Trump Tells NATO Countries To Pay Up
2 days ago
Russians Discussed Influencing Trump Through Aides
2 days ago

"American spies collected information last summer revealing that senior Russian intelligence and political officials were discussing how to exert influence over Donald J. Trump through his advisers." The conversations centered around Paul Manafort, who was campaign chairman at the time, and Michael Flynn, former national security adviser and then a close campaign surrogate. Both men have been tied heavily with Russia and Flynn is currently at the center of the FBI investigation into possible collusion between the Trump campaign and Russia.

Ethics Cops Clear Mueller to Work on Trump Case
4 days ago

"Former FBI Director Robert Mueller has been cleared by U.S. Department of Justice ethics experts to oversee an investigation into possible collusion between then-candidate Donald Trump's 2016 election campaign and Russia." Some had speculated that the White House would use "an ethics rule limiting government attorneys from investigating people their former law firm represented" to trip up Mueller's appointment. Jared Kushner is a client of Mueller's firm, WilmerHale. "Although Mueller has now been cleared by the Justice Department, the White House may still use his former law firm's connection to Manafort and Kushner to undermine the findings of his investigation, according to two sources close to the White House."

Senate Intel to Subpoena Two of Flynn’s Businesses
4 days ago

Senate Intelligence Committee chairman Richard Burr (R-NC) and ranking member Mark Warner (D-VA) will subpoena two businesses owned by former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn. Burr said, "We would like to hear from General Flynn. We'd like to see his documents. We'd like him to tell his story because he publicly said he had a story to tell."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.