Opinion: A Comprehensive Strategy for Immigration Policy

National Journal
Sayu Bhojwan
Add to Briefcase
Sayu Bhojwan
Sept. 10, 2012, 6:35 a.m.

On Wed­nes­day night at the Demo­crat­ic Na­tion­al Con­ven­tion, Ben­ita Vel­iz rep­res­en­ted the most in­spir­ing act­iv­ism in re­cent his­tory, the Dream­ers. A col­lege gradu­ate from Texas, Ben­ita is one of the mil­lion-plus young people be­ne­fit­ing from the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion’s de­ferred-ac­tion policy to stop de­port­a­tion of young people.

The new policy would grant eli­gible im­mig­rants tem­por­ary visas and al­low them to ap­ply for em­ploy­ment au­thor­iz­a­tion so they have a chance at the Amer­ic­an dream. Ben­ita’s voice was one of many in the course of three days to up­lift the cause of Dream­ers and her­ald the pres­id­ent’s ad­min­is­trat­ive ac­tion. Most speak­ers high­light­ing Pres­id­ent Obama’s ac­com­plish­ments men­tioned this policy de­cision, and it is in­deed one worthy of cel­eb­ra­tion.

Still, it’s hard to ig­nore this real­ity: The pres­id­ent’s de­ferred-ac­tion policy helps only an es­tim­ated 1.4 mil­lion im­mig­rants and is only tem­por­ary. Even as the Demo­crat­ic con­ven­tion’s main stage main­streamed the cause of these young im­mig­rants, mil­lions of oth­er im­mig­rants are strug­gling in the shad­ows.

Those in­di­vidu­als and their stor­ies formed a back­drop to both pres­id­en­tial con­ven­tions, via the “Un­doc­uBus.” At one gath­er­ing in Char­lotte, I heard a young wo­man say that Obama would be known as the first Afric­an-Amer­ic­an pres­id­ent but also as one who over­saw a re­cord num­ber of de­port­a­tions.

For some, it may seem easy to de­lin­eate between Dream­ers, who are un­doc­u­mented through no fault of their own, and oth­er un­doc­u­mented im­mig­rants. But, the line is in fact blurry, and fur­ther, there is no clear di­vid­ing line between all un­doc­u­mented im­mig­rants and oth­er Amer­ic­ans.

Some are just on the oth­er side of the line. Con­sider Jose Ant­o­nio Var­gas, one of the bravest cham­pi­ons of com­pre­hens­ive im­mig­ra­tion re­form. Var­gas is in­eligible for de­ferred ac­tion be­cause he is four months older than the cutoff age of 30. Oth­ers’ lives are in­ex­tric­ably in­ter­twined with Dream­ers, in­clud­ing their par­ents or grand­par­ents, whose sac­ri­fices brought these young people to the U.S. in the first place.

When un­doc­u­mented par­ents fear tak­ing their Amer­ic­an-born chil­dren to school, and worse, when these par­ents are sep­ar­ated from their chil­dren and de­por­ted, we bring en­tire fam­il­ies of chil­dren in­to foster homes and the child-wel­fare sys­tem. That comes at a deep psy­cho­lo­gic­al, and fin­an­cial, cost to our so­ci­ety. 

A fam­ily in which the adults are work­ing and caring for their chil­dren, who are at­tend­ing school and nur­tur­ing am­bi­tions for col­lege and ca­reer, feeds the Amer­ic­an dream. A fam­ily torn asun­der by the ar­bit­rary use of power is not able to achieve that dream. 

At the Un­doc­uBus gath­er­ing in Char­lotte, I heard the kinds of stor­ies I have been hear­ing for nearly two dec­ades. But this time, thanks to the pro­lif­er­a­tion of 287 (g) agree­ments, in which loc­al law en­force­ment col­lab­or­ates with the Im­mig­ra­tion and Cus­toms En­force­ment agency, the fear is more pre­val­ent among par­ents, among work­ers, and even among Dream­ers, for whom de­ferred ac­tion is only a tem­por­ary fix. (ICE cur­rently has 287(g) agree­ments with 64 law en­force­ment agen­cies in 24 states.)

The Demo­crat­ic Party plat­form does call for com­pre­hens­ive im­mig­ra­tion re­form, but Rep. Lu­is Gu­ti­er­rez of Illinois was a rare voice on that is­sue at the con­ven­tion.

“Forced de­port­a­tion,” he said, “is not right.  Our broken im­mig­ra­tion sys­tem cre­ates stor­ies like this every day.  Good people, torn apart, kept from work­ing, pay­ing taxes, serving in the armed forces.” And, at the Re­pub­lic­an Na­tion­al Con­ven­tion, Con­doleezza Rice called in her speech for a law “to pro­tect our bor­ders; meet our eco­nom­ic needs; and yet show that we are a com­pas­sion­ate people.”  

The pres­id­ent who takes of­fice in 2013 has to be com­mit­ted to a com­pre­hens­ive policy, not one that is piece­meal or tem­por­ary. Mem­bers of Con­gress, whose con­stitu­en­cies are af­fected by poorly im­ple­men­ted im­mig­ra­tion policy as well as by voters from im­mig­rant com­munit­ies, also need to step up.

Fi­nally, im­mig­rant com­munit­ies must work on the com­pre­hens­ive ad­vocacy ap­proach ar­tic­u­lated by ad­voc­ates at the Un­doc­ubus gath­er­ing — con­duct­ing ro­bust grass­roots act­iv­ism, lever­aging power­ful and high-pro­file voices and donors, and en­ga­ging in the elect­or­al pro­cess as voters and as can­did­ates.

Sayu Bho­jwani is the found­ing dir­ect­or of The New Amer­ic­an Lead­ers Pro­ject. She has worked on im­mig­rant in­teg­ra­tion in vari­ous ca­pa­cit­ies for more than 15 years.

Opin­ions and oth­er state­ments ex­pressed by Per­spect­ives con­trib­ut­ors are theirs alone, not Na­tion­al Journ­al‘s. Con­tent cre­ated by third-party con­trib­ut­ors is their sole re­spons­ib­il­ity, and its ac­cur­acy is not en­dorsed or guar­an­teed.

What We're Following See More »
Military Parade Delayed Until 2019
7 hours ago
Manafort Case Moves to Closing Arguments
1 days ago
Manafort Defense Rests
2 days ago
Judge Holds Witness in Contempt in Manafort Case
6 days ago

"A federal judge has found a witness in contempt for refusing to testify before the grand jury hearing evidence in special counsel Robert S. Mueller III’s investigation of Russian interference in the 2016 presidential election. U.S. District Chief Judge Beryl Howell made the ruling Friday after a sealed hearing to discuss Andrew Miller’s refusal to appear before the grand jury. Miller is a former aide to longtime Trump confidant Roger Stone."

Gates Says He Committed Crimes with Manafort
1 weeks ago

Paul Manafort's former business partner Rick Gates said in court today that "he conspired with Manafort to falsify Manafort’s tax returns. Gates said he and Manafort knowingly failed to report foreign bank accounts and had failed to register Manafort as a foreign agent."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.