How Republicans Learned to Stop Worrying and Love PolitiFact

The GOP used to hate the fact-checker. Now they’re making trophies in its honor.

Republican National Committee staffers deliver a "Lie of the Year" trophy to the office of Sen. Jeff Merkely, D-Ore.
National Journal
Alex Seitz-Wald
Dec. 19, 2013, midnight

How quickly they for­get.

Re­pub­lic­ans have a new weapon in their ar­sen­al against Obama­care after Poli­ti­Fact awar­ded Barack Obama its ig­noble “Lie of the Year” for his bogus claim that “if you like your health care plan, you can keep it.”

Armed with the im­prim­at­ur of the Pulitzer Prize-win­ning out­fit, Re­pub­lic­ans have taken to the Sen­ate floor bran­dish­ing gi­ant Poli­ti­Fact posters. Fox News has touted the award as proof of Obama’s in­her­ent men­dacity. And the Re­pub­lic­an Na­tion­al Com­mit­tee is even de­liv­er­ing tiny trophies (made in China) to a dozen Demo­crat­ic law­makers’ Cap­it­ol Hill of­fices to con­grat­u­late them on the un-pres­ti­gi­ous win. It’s “no small fib,” the RNC said, and it’s “doubt­ful Obama­care would have passed without that lie.”

You’d ex­pect noth­ing less, of course. In polit­ics, if your op­pon­ent gets called out for blatantly ly­ing by a re­spec­ted fact-check­er, you want the world to know about it.

But it’s more than a bit iron­ic to see con­ser­vat­ives tout­ing Poli­ti­Fact as a trus­ted ar­bit­er of truth con­sid­er­ing they’ve spent the past four years try­ing to dis­cred­it the site as un­trust­worthy and biased, in­vest­ig­ated its re­port­ers and ed­it­ors, and more of­ten than not found their own “pants on fire.”

In 2009 and 2010, it was the GOP who earned the “Lie of the Year” prize for claims re­lated to Obama­care — “Death pan­els” and “a gov­ern­ment takeover of health care” — and last year, Mitt Rom­ney earned the dis­hon­or for an ad about the auto in­dustry.

For that and oth­er crimes — a study based on Poli­ti­Fact data sug­ges­ted that Re­pub­lic­ans lie three times more of­ten than Demo­crats — con­ser­vat­ives de­clared war on the site.

The Vir­gin­ia Re­pub­lic­an Party com­piled an 86-page op­pos­i­tion re­search file last year on the Rich­mond-based state af­fil­i­ate, call­ing the Vir­gin­ia Poli­ti­Fact “biased” and “lack­ing in ob­jectiv­ity.” Fol­low­ing their lead, na­tion­al Re­pub­lic­ans began “dis­patch­ing truth squads na­tion­wide to ques­tion ‘rul­ings’ from oth­er state Poli­ti­Facts units and dig in­to the polit­ic­al lean­ings of re­port­ers,” as The Wash­ing­ton Ex­am­iner re­por­ted. This ef­fort in­clud­ing dig­ging up “the party re­gis­tra­tion of re­port­ers or ed­it­ors” and “look­ing over the Face­book and Twit­ter ac­counts of the re­port­ers and ed­it­ors for hint of bi­as.”

“We’re not go­ing to let our cam­paign be dic­tated by fact-check­ers,” Mitt Rom­ney’s poll­ster said after the cam­paign got caught bend­ing the truth on sev­er­al oc­ca­sions.

When Poli­ti­Fact rated a par­tic­u­lar Rom­ney claim as false, his policy dir­ect­or emailed the site’s ed­it­ors to say they had an “em­bar­rass­ing bi­as and lack of journ­al­ist­ic stand­ards,” and that “your ana­lys­is in this in­stance was so in­ad­equate that the piece ended up be­ing little more than Obama for Amer­ica spin.” Breit­bart.com’s cov­er­age of the ex­change car­ried the tri­umphant head­line: “Rom­ney Puts Poli­ti­Fact on the Ropes,” with a pic­ture of Rom­ney pos­ing as a strong man with his fists above his head.

It’s part of a lar­ger, deeply in­grained con­ser­vat­ive nar­rat­ive that dis­trusts the main­stream me­dia as a hope­lessly biased or­gan of the Left. The right-lean­ing Me­dia Re­search Cen­ter puts up bill­boards, hands out bump­er stick­ers, and even flies planes trail­ing gi­ant ban­ners that read “Don’t be­lieve the lib­er­al me­dia.” By “lib­er­al me­dia,” they don’t mean The Na­tion and MS­N­BC, they mean ABC, CNN, The New York Times, etc.

Poli­ti­Fact is not that hon­est fact-check­er,” Jon Cas­sidy ex­plained in a lengthy take­down of Poli­ti­Fact in the con­ser­vat­ive web­site Town­Hall, writ­ten dur­ing the height of the 2012 cam­paign.

But Mark Hem­ing­way in 2011 pub­lished the defin­it­ive con­ser­vat­ive take on fact check­ers in the Weekly Stand­ard. His 3,500 word es­say, “Lies, Damned Lies and Fact Check­ing,” promp­ted praise on the right and in­tro­spect­ive de­bate in the main­stream press. A sample:

If the stated goal seems simple enough”‹ — “‹provid­ing an im­par­tial ref­er­ee to help read­ers sort out ac­ri­mo­ni­ous and hy­per­bol­ic polit­ic­al dis­putes”‹ — “‹in prac­tice Poli­ti­Fact does noth­ing of the sort.

Today, however, Re­pub­lic­ans sud­denly find Poli­ti­Fact‘s rat­ings cred­ible and worthy of us­ing as a cudgel against Demo­crats. Is Poli­ti­Fact still in the tank for Obama if it calls him the year’s biggest li­ar? And if it’s so dis­hon­est, can we trust them when they say the pres­id­ent bent the truth?

This kind of badger­ing of the refs is hardly unique to right. Lib­er­als have ex­ploded at Poli­ti­Fact when its rul­ings don’t go their way plenty of times. Rachel Mad­dow once dir­ec­ted a mono­logue at the site, a fre­quent foil of the MS­N­BC host’s, where she de­clared: “You are truly ter­rible … [you] just make this stuff up.”

For Angie Holan, ed­it­or of the na­tion­al site, which is based at the Tampa Bay Times, the bi­par­tis­an cri­ti­cism is evid­ence that they’re do­ing something right. “Most of us are base­ball fans at Poli­ti­Fact, and we’ve no­ticed that factcheck­ers are kind of like um­pires. Every­body loves — and hates — the umps at one point or an­oth­er,” she said in an email.

But while the Left has pro­tested cer­tain rul­ings, it hasn’t en­gaged in the same kind of whole­sale cam­paign to dis­cred­it fact check­ers like the Right has. It doesn’t have the same in­her­ent dis­trust of the me­dia.

Will con­ser­vat­ives change their view of Poli­ti­Fact now that its sided with them? If past is pre­ced­ent, the good will only last un­til the next neg­at­ive rul­ing against your side.

Cor­rec­tion: An earli­er ver­sion of this story misatrib­uted a quote from Mitt Rom­ney’s poll­ster to the former pres­id­en­tial can­did­ate him­self. It has been up­dated.

What We're Following See More »
FIRST WOMAN NOMINATED BY MAJOR PARTY
Hillary Clinton Accepts the Democratic Nomination for President
5 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"It is with humility, determination, and boundless confidence in America’s promise that I accept your nomination for president," said Hillary Clinton in becoming the first woman to accept a nomination for president from a major party. Clinton gave a wide-ranging address, both criticizing Donald Trump and speaking of what she has done in the past and hopes to do in the future. "He's taken the Republican party a long way, from morning in America to midnight in America," Clinton said of Trump. However, most of her speech focused instead on the work she has done and the work she hopes to do as president. "I will be a president of Democrats, Republicans, and Independents. For the struggling, the striving, the successful," she said. "For those who vote for me and for those who don't. For all Americans together."

COUNTER-CHANTS AT THE READY
Protesters Make Good on Threat to Disrupt Speech
5 hours ago
THE LATEST

Supporters of Bernie Sanders promised to walk out, turn their backs, or disrupt Hillary Clinton's speech tonight, and they made good immediately, with an outburst almost as soon as Clinton began her speech. But her supporters, armed with a handy counter-chant cheat sheet distributed by the campaign, immediately began drowning them out with chants of "Hillary, Hillary!"

SUFFOLK POLL
New Survey Shows Clinton Up 9 in Pennsylvania
14 hours ago
THE LATEST

If a new poll is to be believed, Hillary Clinton has a big lead in the all-important swing state of Pennsylvania. A new Suffolk University survey shows her ahead of Donald Trump, 50%-41%. In a four-way race, she maintains her nine-point lead, 46%-37%. "Pennsylvania has voted Democratic in the past six presidential elections, going back to Bill Clinton’s first win in 1992. Yet it is a rust belt state that could be in play, as indicated by recent general-election polling showing a close race."

Source:
THREE NIGHTS RUNNING
Democrats Beat Republicans in Convention Ratings So Far
14 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Wednesday was the third night in a row that the Democratic convention enjoyed a ratings win over the Republican convention last week. Which might have prompted a fundraising email from Donald Trump exhorting supporters not to watch. "Unless you want to be lied to, belittled, and attacked for your beliefs, don't watch Hillary's DNC speech tonight," the email read. "Instead, help Donald Trump hold her accountable, call out her lies and fight back against her nasty attacks."

Source:
SHIFT FROM ROMNEY’S NUMBERS
Catholics, Highly Educated Moving Toward Dems
18 hours ago
THE LATEST

Catholics who attend mass at least weekly have increased their support of the Democratic nominee by 22 points, relative to 2012, when devout Catholics backed Mitt Romney. Meanwhile, a Morning Consult poll shows that those voters with advanced degrees prefer Hillary Clinton, 51%-34%. Which, we suppose, makes the ideal Clinton voter a Catholic with a PhD in divinity.

×