It Takes a City

The story of Detroit in its heyday shows how the success of Motown Records was a community effort.

A skyline of Detriot in the 1960s is pictured. 
Fred Wilkinson/Flickr Creative Commons
Ronald Brownstein
Add to Briefcase
Ronald Brownstein
Oct. 2, 2015, 5 a.m.

A mes­mer­iz­ing cast struts through the pages of Dav­id Maran­iss’s evoc­at­ive new book about De­troit in the early 1960s, Once in a Great City.

In Maran­iss’s cap­able hands, mob­sters rub shoulders with ath­letes; the city’s may­or, Jerome Cavanagh, bal­ances na­tion­al am­bi­tions with sim­mer­ing loc­al ten­sions; Henry Ford II and Lee Ia­c­occa feud their way in­to auto­mot­ive his­tory by de­vel­op­ing the icon­ic Mus­tang; and late-night scene-seekers squeeze be­side gam­blers and hust­lers to hear Bil­lie Hol­i­day, Etta James, and Jack­ie Wilson at the “exot­ic, hyp­not­iz­ing, en­thralling” Flame Show Bar. Riv­et­ing fig­ures such as John F. Kennedy and Mar­tin Luth­er King make ex­ten­ded ap­pear­ances. The over­all ef­fect is like sit­ting on a bar stool next to one of the great old-time city news­pa­per colum­nists (think Mike Royko or Jimmy Breslin) who seemed to know, and drink with, every­one in town.

Maran­iss, a former Wash­ing­ton Post re­port­er who has be­come a premi­er con­tem­por­ary his­tor­i­an and bio­graph­er, braids to­geth­er these stor­ies for a pan­or­amic por­trait of a city un­know­ingly near­ing the end of its golden run as the world’s auto­maker. The 1967 race ri­ot and the tsunami of for­eign car im­ports that would bat­ter De­troit’s found­a­tions from with­in and without loom just off­stage.

But of all the stor­ies Maran­iss tells, the most com­pel­ling may be the rise of Berry Gordy Jr. and Mo­town Re­cords. It is also the story most rel­ev­ant to the chal­lenges fa­cing cit­ies today.

In many re­spects, Amer­ica’s cit­ies are re­viv­ing. The Brook­ings In­sti­tu­tion re­ports that 63 of the 100 largest met­ro­pol­it­an areas have more jobs today than be­fore the fin­an­cial crash in 2007. Between them, those cit­ies have ad­ded 8.4 mil­lion jobs, more than three-fourths of all U.S. em­ploy­ment cre­ated since then. Young col­lege gradu­ates drawn to urb­an life are re­in­vig­or­at­ing neigh­bor­hoods from Wash­ing­ton, D.C.’s 14th Street cor­ridor to SoMa in San Fran­cisco as en­tre­pren­eur­i­al hubs and des­tin­a­tions for bust­ling shop­ping and night­life. In a telling re­versal, after dec­ades of flight, the white pop­u­la­tion has in­creased since 2000 in about half of our largest cit­ies, Brook­ings re­ports.

Yet cit­ies every­where are strug­gling to ex­tend these ex­pand­ing op­por­tun­it­ies to all of their res­id­ents. In vis­its this year to places as dif­fer­ent as Den­ver, At­lanta, Chica­go, and Aus­tin, the most com­mon con­cern I have heard is that the kids grow­ing up there—most of them Afric­an-Amer­ic­an or His­pan­ic—are not be­ing equipped with the skills to com­pete for the jobs the cit­ies are again gen­er­at­ing. That sense of dis­con­nec­tion deepened the urb­an un­rest that flared in places from Fer­guson, Mis­souri, to Bal­timore and fueled the “tale of two cit­ies” con­cerns that dom­in­ated the most re­cent may­or­al elec­tions in New York City and Chica­go. Alicia Phil­ipp, pres­id­ent of the Com­munity Found­a­tion for Great­er At­lanta, crys­tal­lized the frus­tra­tion I heard across those cit­ies when she told me re­cently, “What we need is an op­por­tun­ity in­fra­struc­ture.”

Maran­iss is a bril­liant storyteller, not a policy ana­lyst. But his ac­count of Gordy’s rise of­fers keen in­sights in­to what such an in­fra­struc­ture might look like. The key is that it in­volves pub­lic, private, and civic in­sti­tu­tions each play­ing com­ple­ment­ary roles.

How did Mo­town give the world such tran­scend­ent tal­ents as Wil­li­am “Smokey” Robin­son, Di­ana Ross, Stevie Won­der, and Martha and the Van­del­las? Cer­tainly the an­swer starts with the mu­sic­al and en­tre­pren­eur­i­al geni­us of Gordy, who was equal parts song­writer, im­pres­ario, and em­pire-build­er. But, as Maran­iss shows, Gordy’s in­spired mu­sic­al in­nov­a­tion res­ted on a sturdy found­a­tion built by com­mun­al in­sti­tu­tions.

That list starts with De­troit’s pub­lic schools. Many of Gordy’s stars (and the ses­sion mu­si­cians who sup­por­ted them) were products of the city’s schools, which val­ued mu­sic and lov­ingly nur­tured tal­ent. “Talk to mu­si­cians in De­troit,” Maran­iss writes, “and odds are they will re­call—vividly and fondly—the teach­ers who pushed them along.” The schools were sup­por­ted in that mis­sion by the city’s vi­brant black churches, which provided both a rich mu­sic­al tra­di­tion and an­oth­er nurs­ery for in­cub­at­ing young tal­ent. Aretha Frank­lin, for one, was the daugh­ter of the for­mid­able C. L. Frank­lin, the city’s lead­ing Afric­an-Amer­ic­an min­is­ter.

Less ob­vi­ous, but equally es­sen­tial, was the role of the Grin­nell Broth­ers Mu­sic House, a down­town mu­sic shop whose classes and af­ford­able fin­an­cing for fam­il­ies of all in­comes and races meant, as one loc­al ob­serv­er told Maran­iss, “all these work­ing-class fam­il­ies in De­troit … had their own pi­ano.” If Grin­nell had nar­rowed its busi­ness strategy to serving only the af­flu­ent, few­er young people (such as Smokey Robin­son, who grew up play­ing a Grin­nell pi­ano) would have dis­covered the gifts Gordy later har­ves­ted.

Even in those years, De­troit suffered from se­greg­a­tion, dis­crim­in­a­tion, and in­equal­ity. But Gordy and Mo­town showed what’s pos­sible when the spark of private-sec­tor in­nov­a­tion is ap­plied to tal­ent that was sys­tem­at­ic­ally de­veloped by pub­lic and civic in­sti­tu­tions. That’s still the most prom­ising for­mula for re­con­nect­ing all of our com­munit­ies to op­por­tun­ity—even if it’s un­likely to again pro­duce the con­stel­la­tion of mu­sic­al bril­liance that Maran­iss so vividly re­cre­ates.

What We're Following See More »
North Korea Threatens H-Bomb Test Over Pacific
2 days ago

"North Korea said on Friday it might test a hydrogen bomb over the Pacific Ocean after President Donald Trump vowed to destroy the reclusive country, with leader Kim Jong Un promising to make Trump pay dearly for his threats. Kim did not specify what action he would take against the United States or Trump, whom he called a 'mentally deranged U.S. dotard' in the latest bout of insults the two leaders have traded in recent weeks."

Trump Makes Good on Promise of New North Korea Sanctions
3 days ago

President Trump this afternoon announced another round of sanctions on North Korea, calling the regime "a continuing threat." The executive order, which Trump relayed to Congress, bans any ship or plane that has visited North Korea from visiting the United States within 180 days. The order also authorizes sanctions on any financial institution doing business with North Korea, and permits the secretaries of State and the Treasury to sanction any person involved in trading with North Korea, operating a port there, or involved in a variety of industries there.

Trump Promises More Sanctions on North Korea
3 days ago

In response to a reporter's question, President Trump said "he’ll be looking to impose further financial penalties on North Korea over its nuclear and ballistic tests. ... The U.N. has passed two resolutions recently aimed at squeezing the North Korean economy by cutting off oil, labor and exports to the nation." Meanwhile, the Guardian reports that South Korea's unification ministry is sending an $8m aid package aimed at infants and pregnant women in North Korea. The "humanitarian gesture [is] at odds with calls by Japan and the US for unwavering economic and diplomatic pressure on Pyongyang."

FLOTUS to Speak at UN Luncheon
4 days ago
Trump Meets with UN Leaders
4 days ago

President Trump on Tuesday night met with UN Secretary Guterres and President of the General Assembly Miroslav Lajcak. In both cases, as per releases from the White House, Trump pressed them on the need to reform the UN bureaucracy.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.