Equality Often Missing as Early as Preschool

Bigotry in basketball draws attention, but there’s evidence discrimination also distorts young lives.

Attorney General Eric Holder (L) and Education Secretary Arne Duncan talk to preschoolers Dylan Hunt (2ndR) and Khalil Robinson (R) while they pretend to play doctors in their class at J.O. Wilson Elementry School. On March 21, 2014 in Washington, DC. President Obama has proposed expanding government-funded early childhood education.
National Journal
MaryLee Allen and Daniel Hains
May 13, 2014, 1 a.m.

In April, the U.S. Edu­ca­tion De­part­ment’s Of­fice for Civil Rights re­leased data for the first time ex­amin­ing the num­ber of young chil­dren sus­pen­ded from preschool pro­grams in pub­lic schools.

The data re­vealed a ser­i­ously troub­ling pat­tern in school dis­cip­line for young chil­dren dur­ing the 2011-12 school year.

Black chil­dren rep­res­en­ted only 18 per­cent of the na­tion’s preschool stu­dents in pub­lic schools in the 2011-12 school year but 42 per­cent of stu­dents sus­pen­ded once — and an even more shock­ing 48 per­cent of stu­dents sus­pen­ded more than once from preschool. In con­trast, white chil­dren rep­res­en­ted 43 per­cent of the preschool pop­u­la­tion and 26 per­cent of those sus­pen­ded one or more times.

These facts be­come more dis­turb­ing when viewed along­side the re­search of Wal­ter Gil­li­am, a Yale pro­fess­or of psy­cho­logy and the dir­ect­or of the Ed­ward Zi­gler Cen­ter in Child De­vel­op­ment and So­cial Policy. Gil­li­am’s 2005 study on preschool ex­pul­sions found that young black chil­dren were far more likely to be ex­pelled than oth­er ra­cial and eth­nic groups.

Gil­li­am’s study ex­amined a di­verse sample of preschool set­tings. He found that the pub­lic-school-based preschools and Head Start pro­grams it ex­amined had lower ex­pul­sion rates than those op­er­ated in­side faith-af­fil­i­ated cen­ters and for-profit child-care pro­grams, set­tings not in­cluded in the Edu­ca­tion De­part­ment’s Civil Rights Data Col­lec­tion re­port.

Both the Gil­li­am study and the Edu­ca­tion De­part­ment’s new data point to a ser­i­ous prob­lem: Young chil­dren, es­pe­cially young chil­dren of col­or, are be­ing re­moved from preschool set­tings and robbed of early op­por­tun­it­ies to learn.

Even worse, ra­cial dis­par­it­ies in preschool sus­pen­sions and ex­pul­sions seem to mim­ic a lar­ger trend throughout pub­lic schools. Dur­ing the 2011-12 school year, black chil­dren in grades K-12 were sus­pen­ded and ex­pelled from schools around the coun­try at a rate three times that of white chil­dren, ac­cord­ing to fed­er­al data.

The story here is not the num­bers them­selves but the mes­sage they con­vey about our lack of com­mit­ment to en­sur­ing a head start and a fair start for our young­est chil­dren. A small group of preschool pro­grams — only 6 per­cent of the na­tion’s school dis­tricts of­fer­ing preschool — re­por­ted sus­pend­ing any chil­dren. But any sus­pen­sion or ex­pul­sion of our young­est and most vul­ner­able chil­dren is un­ac­cept­able. When we sus­pend or ex­pel a child, we adults are say­ing to that child, “We can­not meet your needs. We give up on you.”

How can we give up on a young child be­fore he or she reaches kinder­garten?

Gil­li­am’s re­search shows that high teach­er-child ra­tios and teach­er stress — in­dic­at­ors of a low-qual­ity preschool pro­gram — are closely as­so­ci­ated with an el­ev­ated rate of stu­dent ex­pul­sions. Black chil­dren “ex­per­i­ence a ser­i­ous op­por­tun­ity gap in the form of lim­ited ac­cess to high-qual­ity early care and edu­ca­tion,” and are more likely to be placed in low-qual­ity care, ac­cord­ing to re­search re­leased in Novem­ber by the Na­tion­al In­sti­tute for Early Edu­ca­tion Re­search.

What re­search and data col­lec­tion on preschool sus­pen­sions and ex­pul­sions really re­veal is our fail­ure as adults to provide high qual­ity care for all of our chil­dren dur­ing their most cru­cial years of rap­id brain de­vel­op­ment. If our so­ci­ety has reached the point where it is deemed ac­cept­able to give up on 3- and 4-year-old chil­dren, we have in­deed fallen far from our na­tion­al creed of be­ing the “land of op­por­tun­ity.”

Mari­an Wright Edel­man, pres­id­ent of the Chil­dren’s De­fense Fund, of­ten quotes the great Ger­man theo­lo­gian Di­et­rich Bon­hoef­fer, who once said that the test of the mor­al­ity of a so­ci­ety is what it does for its chil­dren. CDF be­lieves that we are miser­ably fail­ing Bon­hoef­fer’s test.

We fail Bon­hoef­fer’s test every time we de­cide it is easi­er to pun­ish a 4-year-old rather than sup­port her.

We fail Bon­hoef­fer’s test when we place a lower value on the life of a black child than the life of a white child, al­low­ing black chil­dren to dis­pro­por­tion­ately at­tend low-qual­ity preschool pro­grams and face ex­clu­sion­ary dis­cip­line.

We fail Bon­hoef­fer’s test when we over­bur­den edu­cat­ors with too many preschool­ers in each class and when we fail to train and sup­port those who de­vote their lives to the care of our young­est chil­dren.

We fail Bon­hoef­fer’s test when we give up on a child’s fu­ture be­fore he can even tie his shoelaces.

However, it’s not too late for our preschool-age chil­dren, and it is not too late for us to build a found­a­tion for fu­ture suc­cess. We must fol­low the lead of the bi­par­tis­an group of gov­ernors and may­ors in states and cit­ies across the coun­try who are work­ing hard to make ac­cess to high qual­ity early-child­hood de­vel­op­ment and learn­ing a real­ity for all of their chil­dren. All chil­dren through age 5 need a high-qual­ity early-child­hood sys­tem with com­pre­hens­ive ser­vices and sup­ports so those most in need do not slip through the cracks.

As the wealth­i­est na­tion in the world, we must em­brace our mor­al re­spons­ib­il­ity to care for all of our chil­dren. It is the right thing to do and the smart thing to do. The fu­ture of the na­tion de­pends on it.

MaryLee Al­len is act­ing policy dir­ect­or and Daniel Hains is an early-child­hood policy as­sist­ant at the Chil­dren’s De­fense Fund. 

HAVE AN OPIN­ION ON POLICY AND CHAN­GING DEMO­GRAPH­ICS? The Next Amer­ica wel­comes op-ed pieces that ex­plore the polit­ic­al, eco­nom­ic, and so­cial ef­fects of the pro­found ra­cial and cul­tur­al changes fa­cing our na­tion, par­tic­u­larly rel­ev­ant to edu­ca­tion, eco­nomy, the work­force, and health. Email Jan­ell Ross at jross@na­tion­al­journ­al.com. Please fol­low us on Twit­ter and Face­book.

What We're Following See More »
Sanders and Clinton Spar Over … President Obama
5 hours ago

President Obama became a surprise topic of contention toward the end of the Democratic debate, as Hillary Clinton reminded viewers that Sanders had challenged the progressive bona fides of President Obama in 2011 and suggested that someone might challenge him from the left. “The kind of criticism that we’ve heard from Senator Sanders about our president I expect from Republicans, I do not expect from someone running for the Democratic nomination to succeed President Obama,” she said. “Madame Secretary, that is a low blow,” replied Sanders, before getting in another dig during his closing statement: “One of us ran against Barack Obama. I was not that candidate.”

THE 1%
Sanders’s Appeals to Minorities Still Filtered Through Wall Street Talk
6 hours ago

It’s all about the 1% and Wall Street versus everyone else for Bernie Sanders—even when he’s talking about race relations. Like Hillary Clinton, he needs to appeal to African-American and Hispanic voters in coming states, but he insists on doing so through his lens of class warfare. When he got a question from the moderators about the plight of black America, he noted that during the great recession, African Americans “lost half their wealth,” and “instead of tax breaks for billionaires,” a Sanders presidency would deliver jobs for kids. On the very next question, he downplayed the role of race in inequality, saying, “It’s a racial issue, but it’s also a general economic issue.”

Clinton Already Pivoting Her Messaging
7 hours ago

It’s been said in just about every news story since New Hampshire: the primaries are headed to states where Hillary Clinton will do well among minority voters. Leaving nothing to chance, she underscored that point in her opening statement in the Milwaukee debate tonight, saying more needs to be done to help “African Americans who face discrimination in the job market” and immigrant families. She also made an explicit reference to “equal pay for women’s work.” Those boxes she’s checking are no coincidence: if she wins women, blacks and Hispanics, she wins the nomination.

How Many Jobs Would Be Lost Under Bernie Sanders’s Single-Payer System?
15 hours ago

More than 11 million, according to Manhattan Institute fellow Yevgeniy Feyman, writing in RealClearPolicy.

State to Release 550 More Clinton Emails on Saturday
15 hours ago

Under pressure from a judge, the State Department will release about 550 of Hillary Clinton’s emails—“roughly 14 percent of the 3,700 remaining Clinton emails—on Saturday, in the middle of the Presidents Day holiday weekend.” All of the emails were supposed to have been released last month. Related: State subpoenaed the Clinton Foundation last year, which brings the total number of current Clinton investigations to four, says the Daily Caller.