Is Marco Rubio Becoming the Anti-Rand?

Republicans have a chance to recast their foreign policy brand in 2016. Isolationists have their leading man. Who will go up against him?

Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) addresses the 40th annual Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) March 14, 2013 in National Harbor, Maryland.
National Journal
Tim Alberta
See more stories about...
Tim Alberta
March 6, 2014, 7:44 a.m.

Marco Ru­bio had heard enough from his Sen­ate col­league, and when the time came, the sen­at­or from Flor­ida de­livered a harsh rep­rim­and. “If this na­tion is not firmly on the side of hu­man rights and free­dom and the dig­nity of all people, what na­tion on the Earth will? And if we’re pre­pared to walk away from that, then I sub­mit to you that this cen­tury is go­ing to be a dan­ger­ous and dark one.”

In that mo­ment, Ru­bio was on the Sen­ate floor, re­buk­ing Demo­crat Tom Har­kin of Iowa for his ac­claim of Cuba. But it’s not dif­fi­cult to ima­gine Ru­bio, some­time in the not-so-dis­tant fu­ture, aim­ing such an ad­mon­i­tion at an­oth­er sen­at­or: Rand Paul.

As the 2016 Re­pub­lic­an pres­id­en­tial race sim­mers be­neath the sur­face, con­tenders are be­gin­ning to carve out policy iden­tit­ies that can be sold to voters and cam­paign donors. Nowhere will this po­s­i­tion­ing be more un­pre­dict­able than on the sub­ject of for­eign policy. After eight years out of power — fol­low­ing sev­en years of Re­pub­lic­an ad­ven­tur­ism abroad — the GOP in 2016 will have something of a blank slate on which to craft a mod­ern ap­proach to in­ter­na­tion­al re­la­tions. Paul, whose isol­a­tion­ist streak ap­peals to a war-weary slice of the GOP elect­or­ate, stands in one corner of the party’s for­eign policy fight head­ing in­to the pres­id­en­tial elec­tion. The oth­er corner, one that ap­peals to tra­di­tion­al de­fense hawks and in­ter­ven­tion­ists, is presently un­oc­cu­pied.

Enter Ru­bio. The Flor­idi­an claims to re­ject the “ob­sol­ete” la­bels of hawk and dove, in­ter­ven­tion­ist and non­in­ter­ven­tion­ist. But the com­mon theme of Ru­bio’s months-long, transcon­tin­ent­al for­eign policy pros­elyt­iz­a­tion tour is ar­tic­u­lat­ing a strong Amer­ica that is act­ive and en­gaged in every part of the world. His take­down of Har­kin was just the latest ex­ample, and the re­sponse — the speech re­gistered a quarter-mil­lion You­Tube hits with­in 72 hours and was raved about in GOP circles — showed the hun­ger in the party for someone to re­but the nas­cent liber­tari­an wing. Wheth­er in­ten­ded or not, Ru­bio’s speech may have signaled the be­gin­ning of the anti-Rand au­di­tions for 2016.

“This wasn’t some hazy, eph­em­er­al speech about Amer­ic­an do-good­ing,” said Rick Wilson, a Flor­ida GOP strategist close to Ru­bio’s camp. “This was about the con­sist­ent themes of Amer­ic­an mor­al lead­er­ship and our re­spons­ib­il­ity to point out and call out the ac­tions of those in the world that show an op­press­ive streak and the ne­ces­sity to stamp it out.”

In­deed, these “themes” were not ex­clus­ive to Ru­bio’s floor speech. The sen­at­or has been an in­ter­na­tion­al act­or of late, be­gin­ning with a ma­jor for­eign policy ad­dress at the Amer­ic­an En­ter­prise In­sti­tute in Novem­ber. The fol­low­ing month, he gave a high-pro­file talk in Lon­don on the en­dur­ing im­port­ance of the Transat­lantic al­li­ance. In Janu­ary, Ru­bio vis­ited Asia, meet­ing with gov­ern­ment lead­ers in Ja­pan and South Korea and tour­ing the de­mil­it­ar­ized zone. He began Feb­ru­ary by call­ing for the U.S. to “overtly provide leth­al sup­port” to rebels in Syr­ia, rais­ing eye­brows in Re­pub­lic­an circles. And he ended the month with that fiery floor speech, de­noun­cing the vi­ol­ence in Venezuela and cri­ti­ciz­ing U.S. poli­cy­makers for not act­ively op­pos­ing com­mun­ism in our hemi­sphere.

“When you look at 2016 in terms of pro­spect­ive can­did­ates, Marco Ru­bio def­in­itely seems to be do­ing the most to de­vel­op a for­eign policy pro­file,” said GOP strategist Kev­in Mad­den, a vet­er­an of Mitt Rom­ney’s pres­id­en­tial cam­paigns. “And it’s hap­pen­ing at a time when many Re­pub­lic­ans are look­ing for a strong coun­ter­point to the ad­min­is­tra­tion — and also a new voice. John Mc­Cain and Lind­sey Gra­ham are well es­tab­lished. They want to hear from someone new.”

Just when Ru­bio ap­peared ready for a rest, Rus­si­an troops entered Ukraine. As Pres­id­ent Obama sought to de­fuse the situ­ation and oth­er Re­pub­lic­ans is­sued guarded state­ments, Ru­bio went on the of­fens­ive. He wrote an op-ed for Politico sug­gest­ing ways to “pun­ish Rus­sia.” On Meet the Press, Ru­bio called Rus­sia “an en­emy of the United States” and labeled Vladi­mir Putin’s re­gime “a gov­ern­ment of li­ars.”

That’s aw­fully hawk­ish for someone who doesn’t like la­bels.

Paul was con­sid­er­ably less an­im­ated in re­spond­ing to Rus­si­an ag­gres­sion. He is­sued a pla­cid state­ment sug­gest­ing that Rus­si­an lead­ers “should think long and hard” about their ac­tions. At least Paul, a con­sid­er­ably more adroit politi­cian than his fath­er, had the pres­ence of mind to be­gin his state­ment with an ob­lig­at­ory line: “We live in an in­ter­con­nec­ted world, and the United States has a vi­tal role in the sta­bil­ity of that world.” Such nu­ance may be un­fa­mil­i­ar to the fam­ily brand — Ron Paul fam­ously said he wouldn’t have ordered the raid that killed Osama bin Laden, out of “re­spect for the rule of law” — but it’s ab­so­lutely ne­ces­sary if Paul is to ex­pand his ap­peal bey­ond the grass­roots army that buoyed his fath­er’s cam­paigns.

“The group that would sup­port Paul and his isol­a­tion­ism is more lim­ited than the group that would sup­port someone who wants a more ro­bust role for Amer­ica in the world as a peace­maker,” said Fred Malek, a long­time GOP con­sult­ant who chaired Mc­Cain’s fin­ance op­er­a­tion dur­ing his 2008 pres­id­en­tial cam­paign.

One thing is cer­tain: Ru­bio won’t win those Re­pub­lic­ans without a fight. Sev­er­al oth­er po­ten­tial can­did­ates, in­clud­ing New Jer­sey Gov. Chris Christie and former Sen. Rick San­tor­um of Pennsylvania, are ex­pec­ted to com­pete for the same hawk­ish votes.

But un­like his pro­spect­ive com­pet­i­tion, Ru­bio, by nature of work­ing in Wash­ing­ton and serving on the Sen­ate For­eign Re­la­tions Com­mit­tee, can uniquely po­s­i­tion him­self on the na­tion­al stage as Paul’s ideo­lo­gic­al coun­ter­weight in the run-up to 2016. In­deed, while there are many dis­ad­vant­ages to be­ing a pres­id­en­tial can­did­ate serving in Con­gress, Ru­bio is ex­ploit­ing one gi­ant up­side.

{{ BIZOBJ (video: 4791) }}

What We're Following See More »
Eleven States Sue Administration Over Transgender Bathroom Access
1 hours ago

The great restroom war of 2016 continues apace, as eleven states have sued the Obama administration in federal court, claiming its federal guidance on how schools should accommodate transgender students "has no basis in law." "The lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Texas on behalf of Alabama, Arizona, Georgia, Louisiana, Maine, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, West Virginia and Wisconsin. The lawsuit argues that the federal government has worked to turn workplaces and schools 'into laboratories for a massive social experiment.'"

Puerto Rico Debt Bill Passes House Committee
2 hours ago

By a 29-10 vote, the House Natural Resources Committee today passed the bill to allow Puerto Rico to restructure its $70 billion in debt. The legislation "would establish an oversight board to help the commonwealth restructure its un-payable debt and craft an economic recovery plan."

Wyden Bill Would Make Nominees’ Tax Disclosures Mandatory
2 hours ago

"Though every major party nominee since 1976 has released his tax returns while running for president, the practice has never been required by law. Sen. Ron Wyden (D-OR) wants to change that. The senior Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, which handles tax issues, introduced a bill on Wednesday that would force presidential candidates to release their most recent tax returns. The Presidential Tax Transparency Act, as the bill is called, would require candidates to make their latest three years of tax returns public no later than 15 days after becoming the nominee."

Ryan Not Endorsing Trump Just Yet
4 hours ago
U.S. Capitol Doesn’t Meet Standards for New Moms
5 hours ago

"The U.S. Capitol does not meet the federal government’s own standards for accommodations for new mothers," according to an investigation by NBC Channel 4. "Though the U.S. General Services Administration, a government agency which oversees the management of federal government buildings, requires a minimum number of lactation stations and changing tables, Congress is exempt from the rules and fails to meet those standards." The Capitol grounds have 12 lactations stations, far short of the 42 that would be required given the number of female workers there.