How Republicans Built a Better Obamacare Ad

Democrats are worried that personal tales of misfortune will be tough to defend against in the 2014 midterms.

Sen. Kay Hagan (D-NC) comes out from the weekly policy luncheon October 4, 2011 on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC.
National Journal
Scott Bland
See more stories about...
Scott Bland
Feb. 3, 2014, midnight

{{ BIZOBJ (video: 4702) }}

Wear­ing a blue blouse and clutch­ing a cof­fee mug, Chapel Hill busi­ness­wo­man Sheila Salt­er sits at the counter of a well-ap­poin­ted North Car­o­lina kit­chen in a re­cent TV ad. What she says is the stuff of Demo­crat­ic night­mares.

“I was shocked,” she says of her can­celled health in­sur­ance policy. She blames em­battled Demo­crat­ic Sen. Kay Hagan for her woes. Hagan “told us if you liked your in­sur­ance plan and your doc­tors, you could keep them,” Salt­er con­tin­ues.

Salt­er’s kit­chen-counter story, broad­cast in­to North Car­o­lina liv­ing rooms by the con­ser­vat­ive out­side group Amer­ic­ans for Prosper­ity, is part of the latest bar­rage of anti-Obama­care ads. It’s evid­ence that, after four years of look­ing, Re­pub­lic­ans think they’ve fi­nally found the per­fect way to hit Demo­crats for sup­port­ing the law. And Demo­crat­ic strategists worry that Re­pub­lic­ans can rep­lic­ate it across the coun­try.

“For the last two elec­tions voters have had to take our word for it that Obama­care would be a dis­aster,” said GOP con­sult­ant Brad Todd. “They don’t have to take our word for it any­more. They can listen to people like their neigh­bors tell their own stor­ies.”

Pess­im­ist­ic pre­dic­tions and sin­is­ter stat­ist­ics have been staples of at­tack ads since Pres­id­ent Obama signed the health care law in early 2010. But Re­pub­lic­ans haven’t had stor­ies like Salt­er’s to go with them.

Un­til now. And they come just in time for the 2014 elec­tions.

Re­pub­lic­ans should find someone like Salt­er in every 2014 con­gres­sion­al race and put her on TV, ac­cord­ing to one GOP ad-maker. “It would be crim­in­al stu­pid­ity not to find these folks and re­cruit them to this every­where,” said Re­pub­lic­an me­dia strategist Rick Wilson. He con­tin­ued: “I would think you’ll see Dav­id Jolly,” the GOP’s nom­in­ee for a spe­cial House elec­tion in a swing Flor­ida dis­trict, “roll something like this out soon.”

Many of those whose policies were can­celled will be able to get new health in­sur­ance cov­er­age. But between the per­son­al as­pect of the stor­ies and Demo­crats’ in­sist­ent prom­ises over the past few years that every­one would be able to keep their health care plans, the ad­vert­ise­ments have the po­ten­tial to strike a nerve in ways that Re­pub­lic­an cam­paigns have not be­fore.

The Re­pub­lic­an stand-by on Obama­care in 2010 and 2012 was to at­tack it, and Demo­crats who sup­port it, be­cause it “cuts Medi­care by $700 bil­lion.” (Demo­crats ap­plied a sim­il­ar at­tack to Re­pub­lic­ans and their budgets.) But per­son­al an­ec­dotes are much more power­ful polit­ic­al mes­saging tools than cita­tions of data. The Demo­crat­ic con­sult­ing firm Glob­al Strategy Group re­cently asked poll re­spond­ents to rate the be­lievab­il­ity of sev­er­al sets of state­ments, pit­ting one fea­tur­ing an­ec­dotes against one fea­tur­ing stat­ist­ics on the same sub­ject. More people chose the an­ec­dot­al state­ment in all three tests.

That might be be­cause the stor­ies are less am­bigu­ous. Obama­care has gen­er­ated nu­mer­ous re­ports about its im­pact, and both parties cherry-pick the most friendly stat­ist­ics for their pur­poses. Not­ably, the Hagan cam­paign’s fact-check of AFP’s re­cent ad couldn’t dis­prove any­thing that Salt­er said. Per­son­al­iz­ing Obama­care can back­fire — GOP Rep. Cathy Mc­Mor­ris Rodgers’s State of the Uni­on re­but­tal fea­tured a con­stitu­ent story that’s now get­ting picked apart by the me­dia — but the tech­nique has high po­ten­tial.

Just ask Demo­crats. A per­son­al­ized tech­nique was a huge part of their anti-Mitt Rom­ney play­book in 2012.

“It’s just like when Pri­or­it­ies USA used that steel­work­er” and oth­er per­son­al stor­ies in their ads, Wilson said.

That’s a ref­er­ence to the pro-Obama su­per PAC that aired a series of tele­vi­sion spots savaging Rom­ney’s re­cord dur­ing the last elec­tion. Many of them, in­clud­ing what might be the most mem­or­able TV ad of an elec­tion that had more than ever, fea­tured men and wo­men speak­ing to the cam­era about how Rom­ney’s firm, Bain Cap­it­al, took over their busi­nesses, shut them down, and laid off work­ers like them.

The Re­pub­lic­an ar­gu­ment that Rom­ney’s busi­ness ca­reer ul­ti­mately cre­ated more wealth and jobs for oth­ers didn’t stick nearly as well as Demo­crats’ mes­saging about the GOP nom­in­ee. It’s part of the reas­on exit poll re­spond­ents said that Obama was “more in touch with people like you” than Rom­ney and that Rom­ney’s policies were more likely to fa­vor the rich over the middle class.

Hav­ing watched those ads work in their fa­vor in 2012, the po­ten­tial on­slaught of per­son­al­ized GOP health care ads in 2014 has some Demo­crats wor­ried.

“That’s a really hard ar­gu­ment to try and beat back,” said one Demo­crat­ic strategist in­volved in con­gres­sion­al races. “Now we’re ar­guing with real people who have a power­ful voice. There’s no ques­tion that the real stor­ies of people who’ve lost health in­sur­ance are a prob­lem for us.”

What We're Following See More »
STAFF PICKS
When It Comes to Mining Asteroids, Technology Is Only the First Problem
2 days ago
WHY WE CARE

Foreign Policy takes a look at the future of mining the estimated "100,000 near-Earth objects—including asteroids and comets—in the neighborhood of our planet. Some of these NEOs, as they’re called, are small. Others are substantial and potentially packed full of water and various important minerals, such as nickel, cobalt, and iron. One day, advocates believe, those objects will be tapped by variations on the equipment used in the coal mines of Kentucky or in the diamond mines of Africa. And for immense gain: According to industry experts, the contents of a single asteroid could be worth trillions of dollars." But the technology to get us there is only the first step. Experts say "a multinational body might emerge" to manage rights to NEOs, as well as a body of law, including an international court.

Source:
STAFF PICKS
Obama Reflects on His Economic Record
2 days ago
WHY WE CARE

Not to be outdone by Jeffrey Goldberg's recent piece in The Atlantic about President Obama's foreign policy, the New York Times Magazine checks in with a longread on the president's economic legacy. In it, Obama is cognizant that the economic reality--73 straight months of growth--isn't matched by public perceptions. Some of that, he says, is due to a constant drumbeat from the right that "that denies any progress." But he also accepts some blame himself. “I mean, the truth of the matter is that if we had been able to more effectively communicate all the steps we had taken to the swing voter,” he said, “then we might have maintained a majority in the House or the Senate.”

Source:
STAFF PICKS
Reagan Families, Allies Lash Out at Will Ferrell
2 days ago
WHY WE CARE

Ronald Reagan's children and political allies took to the media and Twitter this week to chide funnyman Will Ferrell for his plans to play a dementia-addled Reagan in his second term in a new comedy entitled Reagan. In an open letter, Reagan's daughter Patti Davis tells Ferrell, who's also a producer on the movie, “Perhaps for your comedy you would like to visit some dementia facilities. I have—I didn’t find anything comedic there, and my hope would be that if you’re a decent human being, you wouldn’t either.” Michael Reagan, the president's son, tweeted, "What an Outrag....Alzheimers is not joke...It kills..You should be ashamed all of you." And former Rep. Joe Walsh called it an example of "Hollywood taking a shot at conservatives again."

Source:
PEAK CONFIDENCE
Clinton No Longer Running Primary Ads
2 days ago
WHY WE CARE

In a sign that she’s ready to put a longer-than-ex­pec­ted primary battle be­hind her, former Sec­ret­ary of State Hil­lary Clin­ton (D) is no longer go­ing on the air in up­com­ing primary states. “Team Clin­ton hasn’t spent a single cent in … Cali­for­nia, In­di­ana, Ken­tucky, Ore­gon and West Vir­gin­ia, while” Sen. Bernie Sanders’ (I-VT) “cam­paign has spent a little more than $1 mil­lion in those same states.” Meanwhile, Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-OR), Sanders’ "lone back­er in the Sen­ate, said the can­did­ate should end his pres­id­en­tial cam­paign if he’s los­ing to Hil­lary Clin­ton after the primary sea­son con­cludes in June, break­ing sharply with the can­did­ate who is vow­ing to take his in­sur­gent bid to the party con­ven­tion in Phil­adelphia.”

Source:
CITIZENS UNITED PT. 2?
Movie Based on ‘Clinton Cash’ to Debut at Cannes
2 days ago
WHY WE CARE

The team behind the bestselling "Clinton Cash"—author Peter Schweizer and Breitbart's Stephen Bannon—is turning the book into a movie that will have its U.S. premiere just before the Democratic National Convention this summer. The film will get its global debut "next month in Cannes, France, during the Cannes Film Festival. (The movie is not a part of the festival, but will be shown at a screening arranged for distributors)." Bloomberg has a trailer up, pointing out that it's "less Ken Burns than Jerry Bruckheimer, featuring blood-drenched money, radical madrassas, and ominous footage of the Clintons."

Source:
×