The Recession, Not Obamacare, Is Slowing Health Spending

Federal report finds health spending continued its slow climb in 2012.

National Journal
Clara Ritger
See more stories about...
Clara Ritger
Jan. 6, 2014, 11:09 a.m.

Growth in na­tion­al health spend­ing re­mained low for the fourth con­sec­ut­ive year, an an­nu­al fed­er­al re­port says.

Health care spend­ing in­creased 3.7 per­cent in 2012 to $2.8 tril­lion, ac­cord­ing to an ana­lys­is re­leased Monday by the Of­fice of the Ac­tu­ary at the Cen­ters for Medi­care and Medi­caid Ser­vices, mark­ing the fourth con­sec­ut­ive year of the slow­est rates re­cor­ded in the 53-year his­tory of the Na­tion­al Health Ex­pendit­ure Ac­counts.

Growth has slowed since 2009. In 2007, health care spend­ing rose 6.3 per­cent. But since 2009 that growth rate has held between 3.6 and 3.8 per­cent.

While some re­search­ers and eco­nom­ists have poin­ted to the Af­ford­able Care Act, which was signed in­to law in March of 2010, as a reas­on for the slow in health care spend­ing, the eco­nom­ists at CMS were not quick to cred­it the pres­id­ent’s leg­acy health ini­ti­at­ive.

“We spent as much as 0.1 per­cent more on health care between 2010 and 2012 due to the Af­ford­able Care Act,” said CMS eco­nom­ist Anne Mar­tin, the primary au­thor of the study that was re­leased in the Janu­ary is­sue of Health Af­fairs.

The Af­ford­able Care Act ad­ded roughly $5 bil­lion to health care spend­ing between 2010 and 2012, CMS said. With na­tion­al health care spend­ing top­ping $8 tril­lion, that total rep­res­ents just a frac­tion of over­all costs.

While the key com­pon­ents of the health law won’t have a sig­ni­fic­ant role in spend­ing totals un­til the 2014 data are re­leased, some pro­vi­sions im­ple­men­ted soon after the law’s pas­sage did af­fect the 2012 num­bers, in­clud­ing in­creased Medi­caid re­bates for pre­scrip­tion drugs, drug dis­counts for Medi­care be­ne­fi­ciar­ies, cov­er­age for de­pend­ents un­til age 26, and the pro­vi­sion which re­quires in­sur­ance com­pan­ies to spend at least 80 per­cent of premi­ums on med­ic­al care.

CMS poin­ted to the re­ces­sion as the reas­on for mod­est growth in health care spend­ing. Both the 1990 and 2001 re­ces­sions were fol­lowed by “peri­ods of sta­bil­ity,” the eco­nom­ists said.

“We have no evid­ence that cycle has been broken,” Mar­tin said.

Des­pite the num­bers fol­low­ing the his­tor­ic­al trend line, there were a num­ber of one-time factors that con­trib­uted to the low spend­ing growth in 2012. Skilled nurs­ing fa­cil­it­ies saw a Medi­care pay cut to make up for high­er pay in pre­vi­ous years and pat­ents ex­pired for a large num­ber of pre­scrip­tion drugs, al­low­ing ac­cess to and use of less-ex­pens­ive gen­er­ics. Those areas saw 1.6 per­cent and 0.4 per­cent growth, re­spect­ively, com­pared with 4.3 per­cent and 2.5 per­cent growth in 2011.

High­er use and cost of ser­vices res­ul­ted in high­er per­son­al health care spend­ing in 2012. Per­son­al health care spend­ing in­creased to 3.9 per­cent in 2012 and ac­counts for 85 per­cent of na­tion­al spend­ing totals. 2012 saw an up­tick in the num­ber of of­fice vis­its and over­all use of phys­i­cian and clin­ic­al ser­vices, which amoun­ted to a 4.6 per­cent spend­ing in­crease, com­pared with years im­me­di­ately fol­low­ing the re­ces­sion. In­creased cost and use of hos­pit­al care res­ul­ted in a 1.5 per­cent jump from 2011 to 2012, a growth of 4.9 per­cent.

Be­cause some states op­ted to ex­pand ac­cess to Medi­caid ser­vices be­fore the wide­spread Af­ford­able Care Act ex­pan­sion, Medi­caid spend­ing ac­cel­er­ated to 3.3 per­cent in 2012 from 2.4 per­cent growth in 2011. Medi­care growth, however, slowed to 4.8 per­cent from 5 per­cent the pre­vi­ous year, due to the skilled nurs­ing fa­cil­ity pay cut.

Low growth in spend­ing on private health in­sur­ance premi­ums in 2012 — a 3.2 per­cent in­crease — was due to con­tin­ued shifts to high-de­duct­ible health plans (which carry low premi­ums and high cost shar­ing) as well as de­creased en­roll­ment in private health in­sur­ance plans due to the re­ces­sion.

The gross do­mest­ic product sur­passed health care spend­ing at a rate of 4.6 per­cent, mak­ing health care a smal­ler share of the eco­nomy in 2012 than in pre­vi­ous years, fall­ing to 17.2 per­cent from 17.3 per­cent in 2011. The last time health spend­ing de­clined with re­spect to the GDP was 1997, al­though eco­nom­ists at the Cen­ters for Medi­care and Medi­caid Ser­vices said 2011 and 2012 both marked minor de­clines. In 1997, health care spend­ing fell to 13.3 per­cent from 13.4 per­cent in 1996, due primar­ily to the Bal­anced Budget Act, which man­dated large re­duc­tions in fed­er­al Medi­care and Medi­caid spend­ing, CMS of­fi­cials said.

What We're Following See More »
STEPHANIE RAWLINGS-BLAKE TO FILL IN
Wasserman Schultz Won’t Gavel Open the Convention
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

Debbie Wasserman Schultz has given up her last remaining duty at this week's convention. Now, she's told her hometown newspaper, the South Florida Sun-Sentinel, that she will not gavel in the convention today. Baltimore Mayor Stephanie Rawlings-Blake will do the honors instead. "I have decided that in the interest of making sure that we can start the Democratic convention on a high note that I am not going to gavel in the convention," Wasserman Schultz said.

Source:
SUPPORTERS’ RALLY
Sanders Supporters Boo When He Mentions Clinton-Kaine
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

Perhaps this talk of unity has been overstated. Addressing a room full of his supporters today, Bernie Sanders heard "sustained boos" when he said he said it was essential that we elect Hillary Clinton and Tim Kaine.

Source:
ALL EYES ON RUSSIANS
FBI Investigating DNC Hack
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

The FBI this morning issued a statement saying it is "investigating a cyber intrusion involving the DNC," adding that "a compromise of this nature is something we take very seriously." Meanwhile, Hillary Clinton's campaign is suggesting that the hack "was committed by Russia to benefit Donald Trump."

Source:
NEED 300 DELEGATE SIGNATURES
Sanders Delegates Threaten to Challenge Kaine Pick
3 hours ago
THE LATEST

A group of delegates loyal to Bernie Sanders is actively exploring how to challenge Tim Kaine's nomination for the vice presidency. A lead of the group "said he hoped the Democratic National Committee releases information within hours on how to submit a challenger to Kaine, which he said would require the signatures of 300 delegates. He said they have until Wednesday morning to file a challenge to Kaine and stressed that while his group would take any requests from the Sanders campaign under consideration, the delegate group is an independent organization."

Source:
JOHNSON PULLING 26%
A Three-Way Race in Utah?
3 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Here are some more numbers out of Utah that should frighten Donald Trump—and give hope to Gary Johnson. "An internal poll conducted for Rep. Mia Love two weeks ago found Trump at 29 percent, Clinton at 27 percent" and Libertarian candidate Johnson at 26 percent. "That was, however, before Trump picked Indiana Gov. Mike Pence." Utah party chairman James Evans said that move ought to clinch the state for Trump. "Utahns are going to come through because the level of distaste for Hillary is so deep," he said.

Source:
×