Do Taliban Detainees Need to Be Released at End of Afghanistan Conflict?

The legal definition of the end of armed conflict in Afghanistan could determine whether detainees like those released in the Bergdahl swap can remain in custody.

The "Camp Six" detention facility of the Joint Detention Group at the US Naval Station in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba.
National Journal
Kaveh Waddell
June 11, 2014, 10:05 a.m.

In the wake of Pres­id­ent Obama’s an­nounce­ment that the U.S. will pull out the ma­jor­ity of its com­bat troops from Afgh­anistan by the end of 2014, ques­tions have aris­en in Con­gress about the status of Taliban de­tain­ees taken dur­ing the 13-year armed con­flict.

“We’re cur­rently in armed con­flict with the Taliban and al-Qaida,” said Steph­en Pre­ston, gen­er­al coun­sel to the De­part­ment of De­fense, speak­ing in front of the House Armed Ser­vices Com­mit­tee on Tues­day. “At some point, the armed con­flict with the Taliban ends.” At that point, Pre­ston said, the U.S. will no longer have a basis in in­ter­na­tion­al law to hold bel­li­ger­ents.

But most agree that the armed con­flict with Taliban will not end when U.S. forces pull out of Afgh­anistan. The battle with the Taliban is gen­er­ally bundled in­to the lar­ger fight against al-Qaida, and so the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion could use the Au­thor­iz­a­tion for Use of Mil­it­ary Force (AUMF) to hold de­tain­ees like those it re­leased in ex­change for Sgt. Bowe Ber­g­dahl long past the end of troop pres­ence in Afgh­anistan.

Some in Con­gress are try­ing to lim­it the AUMF, which the Bush and Obama ad­min­is­tra­tions have used to jus­ti­fy in­def­in­ite de­ten­tion at Guantanamo Bay and mil­it­ary ac­tion against forces “as­so­ci­ated with” al-Qaida world­wide. A meas­ure in­tro­duced by Rep. Adam Schiff, D-Cal­if., would al­low the AUMF to ex­pire in 2015.

But in Wed­nes­day’s hear­ing, Rep. Adam Smith, D-Wash., re­af­firmed that the U.S. would not be com­pelled to re­lease Taliban de­tain­ees “as long as we’re fight­ing al-Qaida and as long as we’re fight­ing their as­so­ci­ated forces.”

Pre­ston was called to testi­fy along­side De­fense Sec­ret­ary Chuck Hagel to an­swer ques­tions about the pris­on­er swap that traded Ber­g­dahl for five high-level Taliban de­tain­ees from Guantanamo Bay.

What We're Following See More »
GDP Grew at 1.2% in Q2
39 minutes ago

The U.S. economy grew at an anemic 1.2% in the second quarter, "well below the 2.6% growth economists surveyed by The Wall Street Journal had forecast." Consumer spending was "robust," but it was offset by "cautious" business investment. "Since the recession ended seven years ago, the expansion has failed to achieve the breakout growth seen in past recoveries. "The average annual growth rate during the current business cycle, 2.1%, remains the weakest of any expansion since at least 1949."

Schumer: We’ll Take the Senate
1 hours ago

Sen. Chuck Schumer, the majority leader in waiting, not only thinks his party will take the Senate this fall, but that it's on the cusp of an era of "electoral dominance." He told Politico: “We’re going to have a Democratic generation. [President Barack Obama] helped create it. But it’s just where America’s moving demographically, ideologically and in every way. We’ll have a mandate to get something done.”

Biden to Guest on ‘Law and Order: SVU’
2 hours ago

"Vice President Joe Biden will appear in an episode of Law & Order: Special Victims Unit that will mention the backlog of untested rape kits in many cities, as well as efforts to end violence against women—an issue close to Biden, who authored the Violence Against Women Act in 1994." He'll be in New York to tape the episode today.

Clinton Heading to the Rust Belt
2 hours ago

"Clinton's first order of business after the Democratic convention is a bus trip through the electoral battlegrounds of Pennsylvania and Ohio, the opening move in a strategy to defend her party's grip on states President Barack Obama won and to brand her opponent as unfit to be president. It shows a campaign eager to close off a likely effort by Donald Trump, her Republican opponent, to build an Electoral College majority by winning working-class, white voters in the Rust Belt and other slowly diversifying states."

FBI Probing Hack at DCCC
2 hours ago

"The FBI is investigating a cyber intrusion at the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee (DCCC) that may be related to an earlier hack at the Democratic National Committee." The intrusion "may have been intended to gather information about donors, rather than to steal money."