What’s More Powerful Than Politics? Profit — at Least for Health Insurers

While partisans can afford to dig in on Obamacare, many insurance companies just want the law to work.

This December 2, 2013 photo shows a woman reading the HealthCare.gov insurance marketplace internet site in Washington, D.C.
National Journal
Michael Catalini
See more stories about...
Michael Catalini
Dec. 3, 2013, 4 p.m.

Con­gres­sion­al Re­pub­lic­ans have re­lent­lessly at­tacked Obama­care. The White House has been equally staunch in its de­fense. Yet des­pite the polit­ic­al en­trench­ment char­ac­ter­iz­ing the health care de­bate, one group is quietly tack­ing to­ward a more prac­tic­al solu­tion.

In­sur­ance com­pan­ies are try­ing to en­sure that the law works.

While few will spec­u­late on how they’d re­act if the Af­ford­able Care Act’s troubles were to con­tin­ue, in­surers — some of whom op­posed pas­sage of the law — say they’re work­ing closely with the White House and ex­ec­ut­ive-branch agen­cies to make sure the prob­lems that plagued the law’s first few months don’t fur­ther hamper en­roll­ment.

Robert Zirkel­bach, a spokes­man for the trade group Amer­ica’s Health In­sur­ance Plans, said the group’s mem­bers are reg­u­larly provid­ing tech­nic­al feed­back to the ad­min­is­tra­tion.

While the in­sur­ance in­dustry is not mono­lith­ic — sev­er­al com­pan­ies, for ex­ample, have op­ted out of state ex­changes — most in­surers have a stake in mak­ing sure the le­gis­la­tion works.

From their point of view, the gov­ern­ment is a busi­ness part­ner, which ex­plains both their softly worded cri­ti­cisms and their be­hind-the-scenes ef­forts to get the ex­changes func­tion­ing.

“The in­sur­ance in­dustry is in a bit of an ab­us­ive, code­pend­ent re­la­tion­ship,” said Tom Miller, a res­id­ent fel­low and health in­sur­ance ex­pert at the Amer­ic­an En­ter­prise In­sti­tute. “They can’t step out too far.”

In­surers could cri­ti­cize Obama­care more force­fully, out­side ob­serv­ers say, but that could risk ali­en­at­ing the ad­min­is­tra­tion. To re­main on the side­lines would mean ced­ing a say in how the law op­er­ates.

“I kind of wish there was a deep­er con­spir­acy,” Miller said. “But the bot­tom line is that they want to stay in busi­ness.”

Polit­ic­ally, the law has be­come a lead weight for Demo­crats, with Re­pub­lic­ans re­lent­lessly ham­mer­ing the woe­ful rol­lout. The Af­ford­able Care Act is par­tic­u­larly troub­ling for vul­ner­able Sen­ate Demo­crats, who are stress­ing their at­tempts to fix it le­gis­lat­ively. A pack of Demo­crat­ic law­makers, in­clud­ing Sen. Mary Landrieu of Louisi­ana, have pro­posed le­gis­la­tion aimed at al­low­ing Amer­ic­ans whose plans were can­celed to keep them.

But in­surers by and large op­pose those fixes be­cause rates for 2014 have already been set and restor­ing can­celed plans is easi­er said than done. Zirkel­bach, for in­stance, said those kinds of pro­pos­als amount to “chan­ging the rules in the middle of the game,” and AHIP would not sup­port Landrieu’s pro­pos­al.

Therein lies the in­surers’ lever­age, say health policy ex­perts. The White House can­not af­ford to “throw them over­board,” Miller said, be­cause it needs their help with the web­site. In­surers have been for­ward about this point in par­tic­u­lar.

“In ad­di­tion to fix­ing the tech­nic­al prob­lems with Health­Care.gov, the sig­ni­fic­ant “˜back-end’ is­sues must also be re­solved to en­sure that cov­er­age can be­gin on Jan. 1, 2014,” AHIP Pres­id­ent and CEO Kar­en Ig­nagni said re­cently in a state­ment.

The ad­min­is­tra­tion has three months to demon­strate to in­surers that the Af­ford­able Care Act is suc­ceed­ing, ac­cord­ing to Ed Haislmaier, a seni­or re­search fel­low at the Her­it­age Found­a­tion’s Cen­ter for Health Policy Stud­ies. He also ar­gues that there are bell­weth­er in­surers to watch.

Well­mark, a Blue Cross Blue Shield sub­si­di­ary in Iowa and South Dakota, is not par­ti­cip­at­ing in the Obama­care ex­changes in 2014, but plans to of­fer cov­er­age in 2015. An im­port­ant in­dic­at­or of how well the law is do­ing, Haislmaier said, would be if Well­mark re­vises its 2015 plans.

Mean­while, ob­serv­ers ex­pect in­surers to co­oper­ate with the White House on set­ting up the ex­changes.

What We're Following See More »
WILL ANNOUNCE PICK BEFORE CONVENTION
Trump to Name VP Search Committee
32 minutes ago
THE LATEST

"Donald J. Trump said on Wednesday that he expected to reveal his vice presidential pick sometime in July—before the Republican National Convention in Cleveland—but added that he would soon announce a committee to handle the selection process, which would include Dr. Ben Carson." He said he's inclined to name a traditional political figure, unlike himself.

Source:
AFFECTS WORKERS EARNING MORE THAN $50K
Business, Nonprofits Panicking Over Labor’s New Overtime Rules
35 minutes ago
THE LATEST

"Groups have flocked to the White House Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs to ask for last-minute changes" to the Department of Labor's new overtime rules, which would require that businesses pay overtime to any salaried employee making more than $50,440 per year, up from the current $23,660. Business interests, as well as some nonprofits, say the move could lead to mass change in workers' statuses, from salaried to hourly. "The White House office held 22 meetings on the proposal in April, according to its calendar, and groups say more meetings are planned this week." Last month, National Journal's Alex Brown reported on how the change might affect Washington.

Source:
KAUFMAN, HUNTSMAN ALSO MAY JUMP ON BOARD
Ed Rollins Joins Pro-Trump Super PAC
40 minutes ago
THE LATEST

Republican gun-for-hire Ed Rollins is hopping on the bandwagon, er, the Great America PAC, "an outside group that’s supporting Trump. ... Rollins isn’t the only GOP mainstay coming around to Trump. In recent days, Republican veterans including Republican National Committeeman Ron Kaufman and former Utah Gov. Jon Huntsman have expressed an openness to him."

Source:
PRESSER IN OHIO THIS AFTERNOON
Report: Kasich Is Bowing Out
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

John Kasich is apparently the last domino to fall on the GOP side. NBC is reporting he's suspending his presidential campaign. His path to the Republican nomination seemed all but impossible—even at a contested convention—but he may have finally given up. The Washington Examiner reports Kasich has canceled a press conference at Dulles Airport, "and will instead hold one in Columbus, Ohio, at 5 p.m."

Source:
CNN/ORC
Clinton Ahead by 13 in Early Going
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

"As Donald Trump captures the mantle of presumptive Republican nominee, a new poll finds he begins his general election campaign well behind Democratic front-runner Hillary Clinton. The new CNN/ORC Poll, completed ahead of Trump's victory last night, found Clinton leads 54% to 41%, a 13-point edge over the New York businessman, her largest lead since last July. Clinton is also more trusted than Trump on many issues voters rank as critically important, with one big exception. By a 50% to 45% margin, voters say Trump would do a better job handling the economy than Clinton would."

Source:
×