‘I See Those Women and I Smell Death’

Survivors of another misogyny-fueled mass shooting tell their stories.

Jose Cardoso, 50, grieves at a makeshift memorial in front of the IV Deli Mart, in Isla Vista, California, May 25, 2014. A mass shooting on May 23 in the town near the University of California at Santa Barbara left seven people dead and 13 injured.
National Journal
Marin Cogan
See more stories about...
Marin Cogan
May 30, 2014, 1 a.m.

It’s the smell of smoke that takes Beth Karns back. Not just gun smoke, but wood smoke — the smell kicked up by the spray of bul­lets that struck the gym floor when the shoot­er opened fire. De­pend­ing on how she’s feel­ing that day, the trail she walks be­hind her Pennsylvania home, near a shoot­ing range, is either great de­sens­it­iz­a­tion ther­apy or an emo­tion­al mine­field.

There are oth­er trig­gers, which might come un­ex­pec­tedly and then stay with her for days, linger­ing like smoke. Like news stor­ies about an­oth­er mass shoot­ing some­where in Amer­ica.

It happened last week in Isla Vista, Cal­if. El­li­ot Rodger, the men­tally ill son of a Hol­ly­wood dir­ect­or, killed three room­mates be­fore open­ing fire and killing three more, in­jur­ing 13, and then tak­ing his own life. Five years ago this Au­gust, a sys­tems ana­lyst just out­side of Pitt­s­burgh named George Sodini opened fire in a fit­ness club, killing three and wound­ing nine be­fore tak­ing his own life. Both killers left be­hind ex­tens­ive on­line doc­u­ments de­tail­ing their rage over per­ceived re­jec­tions from wo­men. Both left be­hind vic­tims and sur­viv­ors who had no choice but to carry on with their lives after watch­ing oth­ers lose theirs.

Karns is one of them. The 44-year-old Ve­r­i­zon Wire­less em­ploy­ee hadn’t even tech­nic­ally star­ted her second job at the LA Fit­ness club that Thursday night; her first day was sup­posed to be Sat­urday. But after she re­turned home from a workout there, her fu­ture man­ager called and asked her to come back to help with the cleanup for an in­spec­tion the next morn­ing. That’s how she found her­self stand­ing next to the door of the aer­obics classroom, wip­ing down a piece of gym equip­ment, when Sodini walked in­to the crowded room, turned off the lights and opened fire.

It was around 7 p.m. The gym was packed; mu­sic was blar­ing. It was hard to tell what was hap­pen­ing at first. The fact that the lights were out in the aer­obics room didn’t strike her as odd — in­struct­ors turned them off dur­ing workouts all the time. Then she saw the flash of gun­fire.

Lisa Flee­her was one of the wo­men in the room. She wasn’t alarmed when the man in all black walked in shortly after their aer­obic dance class began. She figured he was the hus­band of one of the wo­men. When he star­ted shoot­ing, she was near the middle of the room. She spied the closest exit, but then watched as a wo­man who tried to es­cape was shot in the back. Flee­her lay down on the ground, amid oth­er bod­ies, hop­ing that the shoot­er would think she’d already been hit. “That was my best op­tion,” she said. “I ended up get­ting shot any­way.”

Karns’s first in­stinct was to count the flashes. In her former ca­reer train­ing as a private in­vest­ig­at­or, she’d learned to count the rounds of gun­fire to de­term­ine what kind of gun the shoot­er might be car­ry­ing and how many rounds might be left. One … two … three.”¦ Around her, people screamed and ran for the exits. They left trails of blood. She coun­ted to 13 be­fore someone grabbed her and star­ted mov­ing her to­ward the en­trance.

Her hands trembled as she tried to dial 911 from the front desk. When a gym pat­ron wear­ing a T-shirt that iden­ti­fied him as a first re­spon­der picked up a stool and star­ted head­ing to­ward the aer­obics room, she went with him, not know­ing the plan but know­ing that she needed to help.

When the room fi­nally went quiet, Flee­her and oth­ers got up and fled. Karns entered and turned on the lights. The first per­son she saw was the in­struct­or — a preg­nant wo­man named Mary Primis — ly­ing on the ground, wounded. An­oth­er wo­man had lain on top of her to shield her from the bul­lets. Primis was shot twice, but she was alive. Karns ap­proached one of the vic­tims and tried to stop her bleed­ing. She re­mem­bers the way the vic­tim’s skin felt, like wet tis­sues. She re­mem­bers the mo­ment when she real­ized the wo­man had stopped breath­ing. She moved on to an­oth­er vic­tim, and held her un­til po­lice burst through the door.

Both Sodini and the Isla Vista shoot­er ac­ted on their hatred of wo­men; vi­ol­ent miso­gyny is a thread that con­nects them to oth­er mass shoot­ers, such as George Hennard, who killed 24 people in Killeen, Texas, in 1991; the Vir­gin­ia Tech shoot­er; and the Columbine killers.

But neither Karns nor Flee­her has much in­terest in the polit­ic­al de­bate that in­ev­it­ably fol­lows a shoot­ing. “The whole situ­ation with me doesn’t make me hate guns or any­thing like that,” Flee­her, who re­covered and had two chil­dren, says. “I just think they need to be used for the right thing in the right way by people who are trained to use them.” Karns is sus­pi­cious about how politi­cians could help. “I don’t know that there’s any­thing that can be done,” she says.

The wo­men have more press­ing, and per­son­al, con­cerns. Flee­her spent months in re­cov­ery after the shoot­ing. Both spent months in coun­sel­ing for post-trau­mat­ic stress. Karns is haunted by all the times she saw Sodini in the gym. Some­times she won­ders if reach­ing out to him could have saved lives.

If there’s one thing she wished people could un­der­stand about what it’s like to go through a mass shoot­ing, it’s that they can nev­er un­der­stand. “It’s nev­er over. People don’t want to hear about it. Or I have friends who will listen, but there’s noth­ing left to say any­more. If some­body comes up to me at work and they scare me in a jok­ing man­ner or I jump at a loud noise, they don’t un­der­stand,” she says. “It’s not one of the ones that gets lis­ted when they dis­cuss mass shoot­ings; no one men­tions the LA Fit­ness shoot­ing in Pitt­s­burgh. I get it. But are they go­ing to re­mem­ber or am I go­ing to be the only one? I don’t want it to be for­got­ten. I don’t want it to be everything, but I don’t want it to be for­got­ten.”

Some­times, on the toughest days, she opens the note­pad app on her smart­phone and writes di­ary entries for her­self:

“I see those wo­men and I smell death. Every day. I have got­ten used to it. But noth­ing takes away what he did. Those wo­men died at the wrong place and wrong time. He killed me on pur­pose.”

What We're Following See More »
Jerry Brown Backs Clinton
20 minutes ago

California Gov. Jerry Brown endorsed Hillary Clinton today, calling her "the only path forward to win the presidency and stop the dangerous candidacy of Donald Trump." While praising Sen. Bernie Sanders' campaign, Brown said "Clinton’s lead is insurmountable and Democrats have shown – by millions of votes – that they want her as their nominee. ... This is no time for Democrats to keep fighting each other. The general election has already begun."

Clinton Says Voters Still Hung Up on Gender
3 hours ago

In a New York Magazine profile, Hillary Clinton said she still encounters misogyny at her own events: “‘I really admire you, I really like you, I just don’t know if I can vote for a woman to be president.’ I mean, they come to my events and then they say that to me.”

Trump Vows Not to Change
3 hours ago
McConnell Urging Rubio to Run for Reelection
6 hours ago

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell: "One of the things that I’m hoping, I and my colleagues have been trying to convince Senator Marco Rubio to run again in Florida. He had indicated he was not going to, but we’re all hoping that he’ll reconsider, because poll data indicates that he is the one who can win for us. He would not only save a terrific senator for the Senate, but help save the majority. ... Well, I hope so. We’re all lobbying hard for him to run again."

Holder: Snowden Performed a Public Service
8 hours ago

Former Attorney General Eric Holder said that NSA leaker Edward Snowden "actually performed a public service by raising the debate that we engaged in and by the changes that we made" by releasing information about government surveillance. Holder, a guest on David Axelrod's "Axe Files" podcast, also said Snowden endangered American interests and should face consequences for his actions.