If Net Neutrality Dies, Is This What the Future of the Internet Will Look Like?

Opponents of “fast lanes” turn to video-game avatars to get their doomsday message out.

NoSlowLane.com / YouTube
National Journal
Kaveh Waddell
See more stories about...
Kaveh Waddell
May 27, 2014, 1 a.m.

The fu­ture of the In­ter­net is a dysto­pia run by the world’s biggest, richest com­pan­ies.

That’s the way the Pro­gress­ive Change Cam­paign Com­mit­tee sees it, call­ing a scen­ario where net neut­ral­ity fails “like liv­ing in the lag­gi­est game you’ve ever played.”

In a video aimed at gamers, a spunky avatar sends a warn­ing from the year 2084 to ex­plain that the de­cision to forgo net neut­ral­ity “killed star­tups and com­pet­i­tion.”

“All we have left,” she la­ments, “is the junk that big cor­por­a­tions want us to see.”

{{third­PartyEmbed type:you­tube id:PEI9Rtw­cvhE}}

The ar­gu­ment isn’t new. But for all the dooms­day rhet­or­ic sur­round­ing net neut­ral­ity — Sen. Al Franken, D-Minn., a lead­er in the fight for net neut­ral­ity, calls the is­sue “the most im­port­ant First Amend­ment is­sue of our time” — such a fiery hell­s­cape is un­likely.

That’s be­cause the ma­ligned Fed­er­al Com­mu­nic­a­tions Com­mis­sion has op­ted to lay out a vague frame­work on net neut­ral­ity that would leave it with a great deal of lat­it­ude to en­force neut­ral­ity rules — or not. FCC Chair­man Tom Wheel­er would have rules en­forced on a “case-by-case basis” rather than cre­at­ing a ri­gid struc­ture that could stifle the In­ter­net’s nat­ur­al evol­u­tion and growth.

Be­sides, the In­ter­net is hardly a level play­ing field today. Al­though the FCC’s pro­posed “fast lanes” — which would al­low In­ter­net ser­vice pro­viders to slow traffic to web­sites that don’t pay for spe­cial ser­vice — don’t yet ex­ist, many bar­ri­ers already stand in the way of star­tups’ entry in­to the high-band­width on­line world. Large con­tent pro­viders like Google and Face­book pay for con­tent-de­liv­ery net­works that ease the bur­den caused by high traffic. This al­lows them to host more pho­tos and videos, and de­liv­er them more quickly to large num­bers of users.

Al­though an FCC de­cision that strikes down net neut­ral­ity could ex­acer­bate this in­equal­ity, it is un­likely to plunge the In­ter­net in­to the cor­por­ate-owned abyss. Even 70 years from now.

{{ BIZOBJ (video: 4950) }}

What We're Following See More »
Paul Ryan Can’t Get Behind Trump
12 hours ago

Paul Ryan told CNN today he's "not ready" to back Donald Trump at this time. "I'm not there right now," he said. Ryan said Trump needs to unify "all wings of the Republican Party and the conservative movement" and then run a campaign that will allow Americans to "have something that they're proud to support and proud to be a part of. And we've got a ways to go from here to there."

Trump Roadmapped His Candidacy in 2000
14 hours ago

The Daily Beast has unearthed a piece that Donald Trump wrote for Gear magazine in 2000, which anticipates his 2016 sales pitch quite well. "Perhaps it's time for a dealmaker who can get the leaders of Congress to the table, forge consensus, and strike compromise," he writes. Oddly, he opens by defending his reputation as a womanizer: "The hypocrites argue that a man who loves and appreciates beautiful women (and does so legally and openly) shouldn't become a national leader? Is there something wrong with appreciating beautiful women? Don't we want people in public office who show signs of life?"

Sen. Murphy: Trump Shouldn’t Get Classified Briefigs
14 hours ago
Romney to Skip Convention
15 hours ago

An aide to Mitt Romney confirmed to the Washington Post that the 2102 GOP nominee will not attend the Republican convention this year. He joins the two living Republican presidents, George W. Bush and George H.W. Bush, as well as 2008 nominee John McCain in skipping the event. Even among living Republican nominees, that leaves only Bob Dole who could conceivably show up. Dole did say in January that he'd prefer Trump to Ted Cruz, but his age (92) could keep him from attending.

Sen. Sasse Calls for a Third Candidate
18 hours ago

Sen. Ben Sasse, the most prominent elected official to declare that he's #NeverTrump, wrote an open letter on Facebook to the "majority of Americans who wonder why the nation that put a man on the moon can’t find a healthy leader who can take us forward together." Calling to mind recent conversations at a Fremont, Neb., Walmart, the senator pitted the presumptive general election battle between Donald Trump and Hillary Clinton as such a "terrible choice" that there would be an appetite for another candidate to emerge. In a parenthetical aside to reporters, Sasse ruled himself out. "Such a leader should be able to campaign 24/7 for the next six months," he wrote. "Therefore he/she likely can’t be an engaged parent with little kids." Meanwhile, his colleague Sen. John McCain (R-AZ) admitted in a private recording obtained by Politico that Trump hurts his reelection chances.