Undocumented Immigrants Are Lawyering Up

The majority of immigration court cases now involve legal representation.

An undocumented Guatemalan immigrant, chained for being charged as a criminal, prepares to board a deportation flight to Guatemala City, Guatemala at Phoenix-Mesa Gateway Airport.
National Journal
Elahe Izadi
See more stories about...
Elahe Izadi
April 21, 2014, 1 a.m.

The ma­jor­ity of im­mig­ra­tion court cases in 2013 in­volved im­mig­rants who had leg­al rep­res­ent­a­tion, a re­versal from five years ago, ac­cord­ing to new data from the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment.

In 2013, 59 per­cent of those in im­mig­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings had leg­al rep­res­ent­a­tion — that’s a big jump from 2009, when just 39 per­cent had law­yers. In 2012, a very slim ma­jor­ity of cases had cli­ents with no leg­al rep­res­ent­a­tion. Those fig­ures come from the 2013 stat­ist­ic­al year­book from the Ex­ec­ut­ive Of­fice for Im­mig­ra­tion Re­view, or EOIR, which is part of the Justice De­part­ment.

Nearly all new cases that came to im­mig­ra­tion courts last year were de­port­a­tion cases. Click through this graph­ic to see how leg­al rep­res­ent­a­tion in new im­mig­ra­tion cases changed over the past five years:

{{third­PartyEmbed type:in­fogram source:ht­tp://e.in­fogr.am/rep­res­ent­a­tion-in-im­mig­ra­tion-court-cases}}

So, what happened? A num­ber of factors are at play.

For one, the gov­ern­ment has done more to help con­nect the un­doc­u­mented with pro bono re­sources, par­tic­u­larly the EOIR work­ing with third-party groups. For in­stance, Health and Hu­man Ser­vices has fun­ded the co­ordin­a­tion of pro bono rep­res­ent­a­tion of ju­ven­iles in im­mig­ra­tion pro­ceed­ings. New pro­grams, such as the cre­ation of the Leg­al Ori­ent­a­tion Pro­gram for Cus­todi­ans in 2012, help edu­cate adult cus­todi­ans of un­doc­u­mented chil­dren and con­nect them to rep­res­ent­a­tion. And EOIR has a re­cog­ni­tion and ac­cred­it­a­tion pro­gram to give low-in­come un­doc­u­mented im­mig­rants ac­cess to reput­able and le­git­im­ate leg­al rep­res­ent­a­tion.

But, also, the nature of im­mig­ra­tion cases has shif­ted over the past few years. Ex­ec­ut­ive ac­tions and ad­min­is­trat­ive dir­ect­ives have changed and high­lighted the ways some un­doc­u­mented im­mig­rants can seek re­lief from de­port­a­tion pro­ceed­ings. In 2011, then-Dir­ect­or of U.S. Im­mig­ra­tion and Cus­toms En­force­ment John Mor­ton form­al­ized pro­sec­utori­al dis­cre­tion, which dir­ec­ted im­mig­ra­tion of­fi­cials to take mit­ig­at­ing factors in­to con­sid­er­a­tion, such as how long a per­son has been in the U.S. In 2012, the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion is­sued De­ferred Ac­tion for Child­hood Ar­rivals, which lets dream­ers delay de­port­a­tion pro­ceed­ings. The share of such cases in courts has in­creased through the years.

Things like that “have really brought the im­mig­rant com­munity in­to kind of a sav­vi­er un­der­stand­ing of what their rights might be,” says Crys­tal Wil­li­ams, ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of the Amer­ic­an Im­mig­ra­tion Law­yers As­so­ci­ation. Ad­di­tion­ally, in­creased anti-de­port­a­tion act­iv­ism may have also heightened aware­ness that leg­al re­sources are avail­able. 

That also means that many of the people go­ing through the court sys­tem may hap­pen to have more com­plex cases, par­tic­u­larly giv­en the ad­min­is­tra­tion’s em­phas­is on people with crim­in­al charges — even though a New York Times ana­lys­is found that many of those de­por­ted dur­ing the Obama ad­min­is­tra­tion had minor vi­ol­a­tions.

Of course, it’s worth not­ing that the over­all num­ber of de­cided im­mig­ra­tion cases has de­clined, from 224,577 in 2009 to 173,018 in 2013. If a great­er pro­por­tion of those cases in­volved com­plex factors, or people with crim­in­al charges, those in­di­vidu­als may have already been ex­posed to leg­al re­sources, Wil­li­ams reas­ons. She also notes that AILA mem­ber­ship has in­creased in re­cent years. “There may be more at­tor­neys avail­able for people to re­tain, and it may just be as simple as that.”

More im­mig­rants hav­ing law­yers means that these im­mig­ra­tion cases have be­come more com­plex and can take longer to re­solve. That’s con­trib­uted to a slow­down in the num­ber of new de­port­a­tion cases, re­ports The New York Times, even as budget cuts have in­creased the back­log of cases. Court-ordered de­port­a­tions ac­tu­ally dropped by 43 per­cent from 2009 to 2013. And roughly half of im­mig­rants are now win­ning their cases be­fore judges, ac­cord­ing to ana­lys­is by Syra­cuse Uni­versity.

At the same time, a large share of un­doc­u­mented im­mig­rants re­moved from the U.S. ac­tu­ally don’t go be­fore a judge, ac­cord­ing to Home­land Se­cur­ity data. So just be­cause im­mig­rants may have more leg­al rep­res­ent­a­tion in court doesn’t mean that most of those who get de­por­ted have had law­yers.

What We're Following See More »
THE 1%
Sanders’s Appeals to Minorities Still Filtered Through Wall Street Talk
1 hours ago

It’s all about the 1% and Wall Street versus everyone else for Bernie Sanders—even when he’s talking about race relations. Like Hillary Clinton, he needs to appeal to African-American and Hispanic voters in coming states, but he insists on doing so through his lens of class warfare. When he got a question from the moderators about the plight of black America, he noted that during the great recession, African Americans “lost half their wealth,” and “instead of tax breaks for billionaires,” a Sanders presidency would deliver jobs for kids. On the very next question, he downplayed the role of race in inequality, saying, “It’s a racial issue, but it’s also a general economic issue.”

Clinton Already Pivoting Her Messaging
1 hours ago

It’s been said in just about every news story since New Hampshire: the primaries are headed to states where Hillary Clinton will do well among minority voters. Leaving nothing to chance, she underscored that point in her opening statement in the Milwaukee debate tonight, saying more needs to be done to help “African Americans who face discrimination in the job market” and immigrant families. She also made an explicit reference to “equal pay for women’s work.” Those boxes she’s checking are no coincidence: if she wins women, blacks and Hispanics, she wins the nomination.

How Many Jobs Would Be Lost Under Bernie Sanders’s Single-Payer System?
9 hours ago

More than 11 million, according to Manhattan Institute fellow Yevgeniy Feyman, writing in RealClearPolicy.

State to Release 550 More Clinton Emails on Saturday
9 hours ago

Under pressure from a judge, the State Department will release about 550 of Hillary Clinton’s emails—“roughly 14 percent of the 3,700 remaining Clinton emails—on Saturday, in the middle of the Presidents Day holiday weekend.” All of the emails were supposed to have been released last month. Related: State subpoenaed the Clinton Foundation last year, which brings the total number of current Clinton investigations to four, says the Daily Caller.

Jim Webb Rules Out Independent Bid
9 hours ago

UPDATED: Sen. Jim Webb (D-VA) will not be playing the role of Ralph Nader in this year’s election. Speaking in Dallas today, Webb said, “We looked at the possibility of an independent candidacy. Theoretically, it could be done, but it is enormously costly and time sensitive, and I don’t see the fundraising trajectory where we could make a realistic run.”