How Democrats Play the Obstruction Game

Harry Reid keeps filling up the “amendment tree,” leaving Republicans with few options.

Senate Majority Leader Senator Harry Reid (D-NV) listens during an event on Capitol Hill on April 3, 2014 in Washington, DC.
National Journal
Sarah Mimms
See more stories about...
Sarah Mimms
April 7, 2014, 1 a.m.

If you’ve been pay­ing at­ten­tion to the Sen­ate floor re­cently, you’ve likely heard a Re­pub­lic­an sen­at­or com­plain­ing about the “amend­ment tree,” an­oth­er tool used by the Demo­crat­ic ma­jor­ity to pre­vent Re­pub­lic­ans from present­ing their own pro­pos­als for a vote.

Lately, the tree seems to be bear­ing more than its share of Demo­crat­ic fruit, Re­pub­lic­ans com­plain.

“When the Sen­ate Demo­crat­ic lead­er­ship de­cides to bring a bill to the floor, far more of­ten than not we are blocked from of­fer­ing any amend­ments,” Sen. Or­rin Hatch, R-Utah, said on the floor last week.

Es­sen­tially, the “tree” rep­res­ents all the amend­ments that are in­cluded in a par­tic­u­lar bill; up to 11 are ac­cep­ted. Of late, the Demo­crat­ic ma­jor­ity has taken to “filling the tree” on ma­jor pieces of le­gis­la­tion, leav­ing no room for Re­pub­lic­an pro­pos­als.

Many of these Demo­crat­ic pro­pos­als are filler, mak­ing in­fin­ites­im­al changes to bills that of­ten don’t end up be­com­ing law any­way. The bulk of them are second-de­gree amend­ments, which is to say, amend­ments of amend­ments. When one falls, the oth­ers topple like dom­in­oes. But that’s typ­ic­ally re­served for the last minute, leav­ing Re­pub­lic­ans no time to re­place them with their own.

These amend­ments typ­ic­ally make very small, and some­times even con­flict­ing, changes to the un­der­ly­ing bill. One of Re­id’s amend­ments filed on the un­em­ploy­ment-in­sur­ance ex­ten­sion bill, which is ex­pec­ted to pass the Sen­ate on Monday, for ex­ample, changes the en­act­ment date of the le­gis­la­tion to one day after the pres­id­ent signs the bill. An­oth­er changes it to two days after the bill is en­acted, a third to three days, and on and on over the course of 11 dif­fer­ent amend­ments, up to a six-day delay.

None of those amend­ments made it in­to the fi­nal le­gis­la­tion; some were dropped Wed­nes­day, while oth­ers were with­drawn Thursday on a ma­jor­ity vote just be­fore the Sen­ate filed clo­ture on the bill, which means no new amend­ments will be con­sidered.

Re­id re­buffed sev­er­al Re­pub­lic­ans’ calls for great­er par­ti­cip­a­tion in the amend­ment pro­cess last week, ar­guing that their amend­ments are aimed not at in­flu­en­cing the un­der­ly­ing le­gis­la­tion, but at pre­vent­ing it from passing.

“There are more than two-dozen amend­ments on this bill alone deal­ing with Obama­care, re­peal­ing it in dif­fer­ent ways,” Re­id ar­gued. “Sev­er­al oth­er amend­ments have been singled out that we have be­fore the body to at­tack the ad­min­is­tra­tion’s ef­forts to pro­tect the en­vir­on­ment. The protests of Re­pub­lic­an sen­at­ors to the con­trary not­with­stand­ing, these amend­ments show that the oth­er side of the aisle is not ser­i­ous about un­em­ploy­ment in­sur­ance be­ne­fits…. What are they try­ing to do? Kill ex­ten­ded un­em­ploy­ment be­ne­fits.”

Sen­ate Re­pub­lic­ans tried Thursday to table (or, kill) one of Re­id’s amend­ments to make room for one of their own. But with Demo­crats in the ma­jor­ity, that move failed on a 46-50 vote. Speak­ing on the floor, Sen. Dav­id Vit­ter, R-La., called the re­peated dis­missal of Re­pub­lic­an amend­ments “in­con­sist­ent with all of the his­tory and tra­di­tions of the Sen­ate.”

This has be­come a pat­tern, much to Re­pub­lic­ans’ chag­rin. “Over the past num­ber of years, the ma­jor­ity has called up a bill and then im­me­di­ately filed clo­ture as if we were fili­bus­ter­ing, when we don’t have any in­ten­tion to fili­buster. All we want is to be able to call up amend­ments,” Hatch said last week. “But, in ad­di­tion to fil­ing clo­ture, the ma­jor­ity will fill the tree, mak­ing [it] im­possible for any­one to call up an amend­ment. Frankly, this is not the way to run the Sen­ate.”

But Re­pub­lic­ans re­cog­nize that they won’t al­ways be in the minor­ity and the way Re­id has con­trolled the Sen­ate over the last six years could come back to haunt him. “I think it is a bad thing to do. However, the prin­ciple has been star­ted and the pre­ced­ent has been set,” Hatch warned.

Cor­rec­tion: An earli­er ver­sion of this story misid­en­ti­fied Or­rin Hatch. He is a Re­pub­lic­an sen­at­or from Utah.

{{ BIZOBJ (video: 4872) }}

What We're Following See More »
Airbag Recalls Target 12 Million Automobiles
20 minutes ago

"The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration identified on Friday the makes and models of 12 million cars and motorcycles that have been recalled because of defective air bag inflators made by Japanese supplier Takata. The action includes 4.3 million Chryslers; 4.5 million Hondas; 1.6 million Toyotas; 731,000 Mazdas; 402,000 Nissans; 383,000 Subarus; 38,000 Mitsubishis; and 2,800 Ferraris. ... Analysts have said it could take years for all of the air bags to be replaced. Some have questioned whether Takata can survive the latest blow."

Secret Service Disciplines 41 Agents Over Chaffetz Leak
51 minutes ago

Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson says 41 Secret Service agents have been disciplined in the fallout of an investigation over the agency's leak of personnel files. The leaker, who has resigned, released records showing that Oversight and Government Reform Chair Jason Chaffetz—who was leading an investigation of Secret Service security lapses—had applied for a job at the agency years before. The punishments include reprimands and suspension without pay. "Like many others I was appalled by the episode reflected in the Inspector General’s report, which brought real discredit to the Secret Service," said Johnson.

Romney Talks Cost of His Futile Anti-Trump Fight
2 hours ago

Mitt Romney spoke in an interview with the Wall Street Journal about his decision to challenge Donald Trump. “Friends warned me, ‘Don’t speak out, stay out of the fray,’ because criticizing Mr. Trump will only help him by giving him someone else to attack. They were right. I became his next target, and the incoming attacks have been constant and brutal.” Still, "I wanted my grandkids to see that I simply couldn’t ignore what Mr. Trump was saying and doing, which revealed a character and temperament unfit for the leader of the free world.”

Puerto Rico Relief Stalled on the Hill
3 hours ago

"A bill to help Puerto Rico handle its $70 billion debt crisis is facing an uncertain future in the Senate. No Senate Democrats have endorsed a bill backed by House Speaker Paul Ryan and Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, while some are actively fighting it. ... On the Republican side, senators say they’re hopeful to pass a bill but don’t know if they can support the current legislation — which is expected to win House approval given its backing from leaders in that chamber."

Congress Slow-walking Zika Legislation
3 hours ago

"Congress abandoned the Capitol Thursday for an almost two-week break without addressing how to combat Zika, even as public health officials issue dire warnings about the spread of the mosquito-driven virus with summer approaching. ... Instead of racing to fund efforts to thwart a potential health crisis, lawmakers are treating the Zika debate like regular legislation, approving Thursday the establishment of a House-Senate committee to hammer out differences in their competing bills."