Eric Holder’s War on Drug Sentences — a Bright Spot in Obama’s Second-Term Legacy?

The attorney general is on a mission to reform decades-old drug policies that majorities agree need changing.

National Journal
Brian Resnick
See more stories about...
Brian Resnick
March 13, 2014, 6:44 a.m.

Eric Hold­er’s last years as at­tor­ney gen­er­al will be marked by drugs.

Just this week, Hold­er has taken sig­ni­fic­ant ac­tion on both sides of the drug war, call­ing for a fight to curb heroin-re­lated over­doses and to also lim­it the sen­tences im­posed on drug of­fend­ers.

We knew this activ­ity was com­ing. Hold­er is mak­ing good on his “Smart on Crime” ini­ti­at­ive, which launched last spring with the un­der­ly­ing philo­sophy that “we can­not pro­sec­ute our way to be­com­ing a safer na­tion.” To Hold­er, and to many Re­pub­lic­ans as well, the stat­ist­ics on crime in Amer­ica are clear and scream­ing for an­swers. The United States has one of the highest per cap­ita pris­on pop­u­la­tions in the world, and a dis­pro­por­tion­ate num­ber of in­mates are Afric­an-Amer­ic­an.

In Au­gust, Hold­er an­nounced that low-level drug of­fend­ers (not con­nec­ted to or­gan­ized crime) would no longer be charged with crimes that im­pose man­dat­ory min­im­ums. Today, he sought to take that a step fur­ther, ad­voc­at­ing to the U.S. Sen­ten­cing Com­mis­sion a de­crease in min­im­um sen­tences for a wide range of drug of­fenses.

The pro­pos­al would re­duce drug-re­lated pris­on sen­tences by an av­er­age of 11 months (from 62 months to 51 months), de­creas­ing the fed­er­al in­mate pop­u­la­tion by 6,550 over five years. Half of Amer­ic­an in­mates are serving drug sen­tences, and those in­mates are dis­pro­por­tion­ately Afric­an-Amer­ic­an.

Re­du­cing the pris­on pop­u­la­tion by 6,550 would mean, on av­er­age, a sav­ings of $169,238,900 a year, per data from the Urb­an In­sti­tute. Money aside, the hu­man-in­terest case for sen­ten­cing re­form is easy to make. 

“This over­re­li­ance on in­car­cer­a­tion is not just fin­an­cially un­sus­tain­able; it comes with hu­man and mor­al costs that are im­possible to cal­cu­late,” Hold­er said in pre­pared re­marks to the com­mis­sion.

The Sen­ten­cing Com­mis­sion pub­lishes the guidelines that fed­er­al judges fol­low in sen­ten­cing cases. It will vote on new guidelines in April. Hold­er’s ad­vocacy rep­res­ents a grow­ing push on both the left and right for pris­on re­form. Last week, at the Con­ser­vat­ive Polit­ic­al Ac­tion Con­fer­ence, a pan­el fea­tur­ing Texas Gov. Rick Perry was un­an­im­ous in its en­thu­si­asm for pris­on re­form.

“The idea that we lock people up, throw them away, and nev­er give them a chance of re­demp­tion is not what Amer­ica is about,” Perry said. “Be­ing able to give someone a second chance is very im­port­ant.”

The changes Hold­er can make are ones par­tis­ans can agree on. In 2012, Pew found that 84 per­cent of Amer­ic­ans agreed with the state­ment, “Some of the money that we are spend­ing on lock­ing up low-risk, non­vi­ol­ent in­mates should be shif­ted to strength­en­ing com­munity cor­rec­tions pro­grams like pro­ba­tion and pa­role,” in­clud­ing 77 per­cent of Re­pub­lic­ans.

Sixty-nine per­cent of Amer­ic­ans agreed with the state­ment, “One out of every 100 Amer­ic­an adults is in pris­on. That’s too many, and it costs too much.”

As policy turns to leg­acy, this Justice De­part­ment’s ac­tions on drug crimes may just be­come a bright leg­acy in a fraught second term for this ad­min­is­tra­tion.

What We're Following See More »
Priebus Asks Party to Unite Behind Trump
5 hours ago
Sanders Upsets Clinton in Indiana
6 hours ago

Despite trailing Hillary Clinton by a significant margin, Bernie Sanders wasn't going the way of Ted Cruz tonight. The Vermont senator upset Clinton in Indiana, with MSNBC calling the race at 9pm. Sanders appears poised to win by a five- or six-point spread.

Ted Cruz Bows Out, Effectively Ceding the Contest to Trump
7 hours ago

And just like that, it's over. Ted Cruz will suspend his presidential campaign after losing badly to Donald Trump in Indiana tonight. "While Cruz had always hedged when asked whether he would quit if he lost Indiana; his campaign had laid a huge bet on the state." John Kasich's campaign has pledged to carry on. “From the beginning, I’ve said that I would continue on as long as there was a viable path to victory,” said Cruz. “Tonight, I’m sorry to say it appears that path has been foreclosed."

Trump Wins Indiana, All but Seals the Nomination
7 hours ago

The Republican establishment's last remaining hope—a contested convention this summer—may have just ended in Indiana, as Donald Trump won a decisive victory over Ted Cruz. Nothing Cruz seemed to have in his corner seemed to help—not a presumptive VP pick in Carly Fiorina, not a midwestern state where he's done well in the past, and not the state's legions of conservatives. Though Trump "won't secure the 1,237 delegates he needs to formally claim the nomination until June, his Indiana triumph makes it almost impossible to stop him. Following his decisive wins in New York and other East Coast states, the Indiana victory could put Trump within 200 delegates of the magic number he needs to clinch the nomination." Cruz, meanwhile, "now faces the agonizing choice of whether to remain in the race, with his attempt to force the party into a contested convention in tatters, or to bow out and cede the party nomination to his political nemesis." The Associated Press, which called the race at 7pm, predicts Trump will win at least 45 delegates.

What’s the Average Household Income of a Trump Voter?
12 hours ago

Seventy-two thousand dollars, according to FiveThirtyEight. That's higher than the national average, as well as the average Clinton or Sanders voter, but lower than the average Kasich voter.