Meet Samuel Alito, the Most Important Conservative in America Today

Easy to forget but hard to ignore, the 64-year-old justice is leaving an indelible mark on the Supreme Court. And giving liberals a lot to complain about.

National Journal
Emma Roller and Dustin Volz
Add to Briefcase
Emma Roller and Dustin Volz
June 30, 2014, 9:31 a.m.

Su­preme Court Justice Samuel Alito en­raged lib­er­als twice on Monday, hand­ing down two po­ten­tially wide-reach­ing opin­ions that weakened Obama­care’s con­tra­cep­tion man­date and severely un­der­mined pub­lic uni­ons.

Alito is a re­li­able mem­ber of the Court’s con­ser­vat­ive flank, though he of­ten earns less at­ten­tion than his iras­cible coun­ter­part Ant­on­in Scalia, whose opin­ions are reg­u­larly dot­ted with sen­sa­tion­al rhet­or­ic­al flour­ishes that eas­ily seize me­dia at­ten­tion. Alito is less waffly than either Chief Justice John Roberts or the streaky, liber­tari­an-at-times An­thony Kennedy, and he doesn’t pos­sess any car­toon­ish idio­syn­crasies akin to the “dis­grace­ful si­lence” of Clar­ence Thomas, who for eight years and count­ing hasn’t asked a single ques­tion dur­ing an or­al ar­gu­ment.

Alito, an Itali­an-Amer­ic­an from New Jer­sey, can be easy to for­get. But as Monday again showed, his sig­ni­fic­ance on the Su­preme Court is real, and worth re­mem­ber­ing.

George W. Bush’s nom­in­a­tion of Alito in 2005 to re­place Sandra Day O’Con­nor (by then a swing vote) on the Su­preme Court may end up be­ing one of 43’s most long-last­ing and im­pact­ful de­cisions. Con­sider that in the last year alone, Alito has weighed in on is­sues as di­verse as same-sex mar­riage, vot­ing rights, uni­ons, and, of course, Obama­care. And in many of those cases, his was the de­cis­ive vote — though the vote did not al­ways work in his fa­vor.

Con­firmed on a 58-42 vote by the Sen­ate, Alito’s Re­pub­lic­an sup­port was near un­an­im­ous — and his op­pos­i­tion by Demo­crats al­most equally par­tis­an. His con­ser­vat­ive bona fides have promp­ted some to nick­name him “Scalito” (a play off of “Scalia” and “Alito”), and he’s done little on or off the bench to dis­pel such no­tions. Dur­ing the 2010 State of the Uni­on Ad­dress, Alito fam­ously mouthed “not true” when Pres­id­ent Obama con­demned the Court’s Cit­izens United rul­ing on cam­paign fin­ance. He’s been a scarce site at the an­nu­al speeches since.

Alito is also quickly be­com­ing a dirty name among pro­gress­ives, who view his ideo­logy as anti-wo­men. Last year he wrote the opin­ion for Vance v. Ball State Uni­versity, which made it more chal­len­ging for wo­men to sue em­ploy­ers for work­place har­ass­ment.

At 64, Alito, like his Bush-ap­poin­ted broth­er-in-arms Roberts, is a re­l­at­ively young mem­ber of the Court, and will likely serve for an­oth­er 20 years, bar­ring any health com­plic­a­tions. Lib­er­als, be­ware: Monday may just be a pre­view of what’s to come from Alito in the years ahead.

What We're Following See More »
Trump Pocketed Insurance Money Following 2005 Hurricane
29 minutes ago

Donald Trump has said he received a $17 million insurance payment in 2005 following Hurricane Wilma, which he claimed did severe damage to his private club in Florida. However, an Associated Press investigation could not find any evidence of the large-scale damage that Trump has mentioned. Additionally, Trump claimed that he transferred some of the $17 million to his personal account thanks to a "very good insurance policy."

Trump Admits He’s Behind
39 minutes ago
GSA Delays Decision on New FBI HQ Until 2017
43 minutes ago

The General Services Administration "will not choose a location for a FBI headquarters until after the new year, a potential setback for Prince George's County and its aim to land the agency and its 11,000 employees. ... It had hoped to make a decision by the end of 2016, timing which would have favored Maryland in terms of political clout on Capitol Hill. Prince George's County Executive Rushern Baker had been pressing for a decision before 2017," while veteran Maryland Sen. Barbara Mikulski, who's retiring, can still influence the outcome.

McCarthy, Pelosi Team Up on National Guard Bonuses
57 minutes ago

The majority and minority leader of the House are both saying "California's veterans are not to blame for being mistakenly overpaid, after a Los Angeles Times story revealed that officials are trying to claw back millions in bonuses from California National Guardsmen. House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy called the efforts to recoup the money 'disgraceful,' and asked for the Department of Defense to waive the repayments soldiers would be forced to make if they inappropriately received re-enlistment bonuses for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan." Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi said she's looking for a "legislative fix" in the lame-duck session.

IBD/TIPP Poll Shows a Dead Heat
3 hours ago

A new Investor’s Business Daily/TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence poll shows Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump each earning 41% support. On the one hand, the poll has been skewing in Trump's favor this year, relative to other polls. But on the other, data guru Nate Silver called the IBD/TIPP poll the most accurate in 2012.


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.