Forget the FCC — Should the FTC Enforce Net Neutrality?

Republicans argue existing antitrust laws can prevent abuse.

"Man Controlling Trade," by Michael Lantz, 1942; outside the Federal Trade Commission Building.
National Journal
Brendan Sasso
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Brendan Sasso
June 20, 2014, 10:50 a.m.

The whole de­bate over net neut­ral­ity is fo­cus­ing on the wrong agency, ac­cord­ing to con­gres­sion­al Re­pub­lic­ans.

The Fed­er­al Trade Com­mis­sion — not the Fed­er­al Com­mu­nic­a­tions Com­mis­sion — should po­lice ab­uses by In­ter­net ser­vice pro­viders, the law­makers ar­gued dur­ing a House Ju­di­ciary Com­mit­tee hear­ing Fri­day.

While the FCC has broad power to reg­u­late com­mu­nic­a­tions net­works, the FTC fo­cuses on ab­us­ive busi­ness prac­tices that harm com­pet­i­tion and con­sumers in all sec­tors.

Net neut­ral­ity is the prin­ciple that In­ter­net ser­vice pro­viders shouldn’t ma­nip­u­late what con­sumers can ac­cess on­line. Ad­voc­ates fear that without gov­ern­ment rules, pro­viders like Com­cast could lim­it ac­cess to in­form­a­tion or cre­ate a two-tiered In­ter­net that be­ne­fits the largest cor­por­a­tions.

House Ju­di­ciary Com­mit­tee Chair­man Bob Good­latte, a Vir­gin­ia Re­pub­lic­an, said the gov­ern­ment shouldn’t stand by and al­low broad­band pro­viders to en­gage in an­ti­com­pet­it­ive be­ha­vi­or, but he warned that ri­gid net-neut­ral­ity reg­u­la­tions could stifle in­nov­a­tion.

“I be­lieve that vig­or­ous ap­plic­a­tion of the an­ti­trust laws can pre­vent dom­in­ant In­ter­net ser­vice pro­viders from dis­crim­in­at­ing against com­pet­it­ors’ con­tent or en­ga­ging in an­ti­com­pet­it­ive pri­cing prac­tices,” Good­latte said dur­ing the hear­ing of the Sub­com­mit­tee on Reg­u­lat­ory Re­form, Com­mer­cial and An­ti­trust Law.

He ac­know­ledged that the an­ti­trust laws — which pro­hib­it busi­nesses from re­strain­ing com­pet­i­tion — may have to be up­dated so they can be “promptly and ef­fect­ively” ap­plied to the In­ter­net mar­ket­place.

Re­pub­lic­an FTC Com­mis­sion­er Joshua Wright agreed that his agency is up to the task. He ar­gued that an­ti­trust is a “su­per­i­or ana­lyt­ic­al frame­work” be­cause it re­lies on eco­nom­ic ana­lys­is to pro­tect con­sumer wel­fare.

But Demo­crats warned that an­ti­trust en­force­ment by the FTC is too nar­row to pre­vent the range of po­ten­tial ab­uses by In­ter­net ser­vice pro­viders.

Rep. John Con­yers, the top Demo­crat on the Ju­di­ciary Com­mit­tee, said an­ti­trust can’t ad­dress noneco­nom­ic harms, such as re­stric­tions on free speech and polit­ic­al de­bate on the In­ter­net. He sug­ges­ted he could be open to the FTC tak­ing a lead­ing role on net neut­ral­ity if the agency re­lied on a broad in­ter­pret­a­tion of its power to com­bat “un­fair” busi­ness prac­tices — but he noted that Re­pub­lic­ans wouldn’t sup­port that ap­proach.

Tim Wu, a Columbia Uni­versity law pro­fess­or who coined the term “net neut­ral­ity,” also ar­gued that the FCC should con­tin­ue to take the lead on net-neut­ral­ity reg­u­la­tions.

“I have the highest ad­mir­a­tion for the an­ti­trust laws,” Wu test­i­fied. “But I simply don’t think they’re equipped to handle the broad range of val­ues and policies that are im­plic­ated by net neut­ral­ity and the open In­ter­net.”

He ar­gued that the gov­ern­ment must not only pro­tect com­pet­i­tion but also en­sure that In­ter­net pro­viders don’t block polit­ic­ally con­tro­ver­sial web­sites, loc­al news sources, or small blogs. Those val­ues wouldn’t be in­cluded in a tra­di­tion­al an­ti­trust ana­lys­is, he said.

But Rep. Dar­rell Issa, a Cali­for­nia Re­pub­lic­an, laid in­to Wu, claim­ing the law pro­fess­or was ad­voc­at­ing gov­ern­ment con­trol of on­line speech. Issa noted that the FCC already reg­u­lates of­fens­ive speech on broad­cast TV.

“This is the FCC’s role. They’re a reg­u­lat­ory policy en­tity that ac­tu­ally does lim­it free speech,” Issa said. Wu countered that net neut­ral­ity is the “ex­act op­pos­ite” be­cause it en­sures In­ter­net pro­viders don’t con­trol on­line speech.

The FCC en­acted net-neut­ral­ity reg­u­la­tions in 2010 that barred In­ter­net pro­viders from block­ing web­sites or “un­reas­on­ably” dis­crim­in­at­ing against any traffic. But Ve­r­i­zon sued, and the D.C. Cir­cuit Court of Ap­peals struck the rules down earli­er this year.

FCC Chair­man Tom Wheel­er is now try­ing to re­write the reg­u­la­tions in a way that can sur­vive fu­ture court chal­lenges. His pro­pos­al would still bar In­ter­net pro­viders from block­ing web­sites, but would al­low them to charge web­sites for faster ser­vice as long as the agree­ments are “com­mer­cially reas­on­able.” That change has promp­ted a massive blow­back from lib­er­als, who fear it could dis­tort the In­ter­net in fa­vor of com­pan­ies that can pay for the spe­cial “fast lanes.”

What We're Following See More »
CNN/ORC Has Clinton Up 5 Points
12 hours ago

Hillary Clinton leads Donald Trump 49%-44% in a new CNN/ORC poll out Monday afternoon. But it's Gary Johnson's performance, or lack thereof, that's the real story. Johnson, who had cleared 10% in some surveys earlier this fall, as he made a bid to qualify for the debates, is down to 3% support. He must hit 5% nationwide for the Libertarian Party to qualify for some federal matching funds in future elections.

McCarthy, Pelosi Team Up on National Guard Bonuses
14 hours ago

The majority and minority leader of the House are both saying "California's veterans are not to blame for being mistakenly overpaid, after a Los Angeles Times story revealed that officials are trying to claw back millions in bonuses from California National Guardsmen. House Majority Leader Kevin McCarthy called the efforts to recoup the money 'disgraceful,' and asked for the Department of Defense to waive the repayments soldiers would be forced to make if they inappropriately received re-enlistment bonuses for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan." Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi said she's looking for a "legislative fix" in the lame-duck session.

IBD/TIPP Poll Shows a Dead Heat
17 hours ago

A new Investor’s Business Daily/TechnoMetrica Market Intelligence poll shows Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump each earning 41% support. On the one hand, the poll has been skewing in Trump's favor this year, relative to other polls. But on the other, data guru Nate Silver called the IBD/TIPP poll the most accurate in 2012.

Clinton Leads by 12 in ABC Tracking Poll
22 hours ago

Hillary Clinton leads Donald Trump by 12 percentage points among likely voters, 50 to 38 percent, in a new ABC News tracking poll, "her highest support and his lowest to date in ABC News and ABC News/Washington Post polls. Gary Johnson has 5 percent support, Jill Stein 2 percent. Clinton led by only four points in the last ABC/Post poll on Oct. 13.

Morning Consult Poll: Clinton Decisively Won Debate
3 days ago

"According to a new POLITICO/Morning Consult poll, the first national post-debate survey, 43 percent of registered voters said the Democratic candidate won, compared with 26 percent who opted for the Republican Party’s standard bearer. Her 6-point lead over Trump among likely voters is unchanged from our previous survey: Clinton still leads Trump 42 percent to 36 percent in the race for the White House, with Libertarian nominee Gary Johnson taking 9 percent of the vote."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.