The Chattanooga Miracle Leaves Out the Working Class

Companies like Amazon and Volkswagen have flocked to the city — but they offer seasonal, temporary, unsteady work.

Justin Smith, 37, looks through a stack of free suits at a job training program in Chattanooga.
National Journal
Nancy Cook
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Nancy Cook
Aug. 21, 2013, 10:28 a.m.

This art­icle is part of a weeklong Amer­ica 360 series on Chat­tanooga.

CHAT­TANOOGA, Tenn. — The suits in blue dry-clean­ing bags sat in heaps on the con­fer­ence room table — there for the tak­ing, provided the young men could un­earth ones that fit.

Justin Smith’s blazer fit well in the shoulders but fell 2 inches too short in the sleeves — not that it mattered too much to him. He wasn’t sure he would need to wear a jack­et to any job or even to in­ter­view as a truck driver. Driv­ing a big rig, fork­lift, or bus had be­come the 37-year-old’s most re­cent ca­reer plan; it was an idea born in a free job-train­ing pro­gram in down­town Chat­tanooga that also of­fers donated dress suits to its en­rollees.

Already, Smith had run through the gamut of loc­al em­ploy­ment op­tions for someone without a col­lege de­gree. In the late 1990s, he worked as a su­per­visor in at a yarn-dy­ing fact­ory, un­til it shipped those jobs to China. Then he worked at a DuPont plant, where he man­u­fac­tured nylon for bul­let­proof vests and earned as much as $22 per hour. For three years, he tried to make it as a small-busi­ness own­er by open­ing a re­tail store to sell mid­cen­tury mod­ern fur­niture, a pas­sion of his.

When the re­ces­sion forced Chat­tanoogans to pull back on spend­ing and his busi­ness stumbled, Smith found work at the newly opened Volk­swa­gen plant. He de­livered parts on the fact­ory floor for $13.50 an hour for a year, un­til he got laid off in May with hun­dreds of oth­er Volk­swa­gen em­ploy­ees, he says.

Now, Smith would be thrilled to earn $15 to $16 an hour, or the equi­val­ent of $33,000 an­nu­ally. That’s a huge comedown from the $65,000 he made one year in man­u­fac­tur­ing.

For him, Chat­tanooga isn’t primar­ily a tech hub or a city whose eco­nomy is on the up­swing. Smith just sees a dead-end. “If someone paid my mov­ing ex­penses, I would move now,” he says. His friend at the job-train­ing work­shop, 20-year-old Dylan Wade, in­ter­rupts. “I don’t want to be a truck driver, but it pays a lot. It’s not what I want. It’s what my wal­let wants,” Wade says. He’d prefer to work as a land­scaper or garden­er but doesn’t see op­por­tun­it­ies in that field.

Chat­tanooga gov­ern­ment of­fi­cials, eco­nom­ic-de­vel­op­ment gurus, and well-edu­cated loc­als are keen on the idea that the Chat­tanooga eco­nomy is at a turn­ing point thanks to its re­vital­ized down­town; its su­per-speed In­ter­net, one of the fast­est in the coun­try; and the city’s abil­ity to lure new com­pan­ies to the area, in­clud­ing Volk­swa­gen, Amazon, and a hand­ful of call cen­ters such as HomeServe USA or Con­vergys.

But this nar­rat­ive does not ring true to those liv­ing on the city’s lower eco­nom­ic rungs. For them, the past dec­ade has been marked by struggle and a de­cline in wages, with few­er steady, stable job pro­spects, and the on­go­ing loss of man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs. The un­em­ploy­ment rate in Chat­tanooga re­mains at 8.5 per­cent, com­pared with the na­tion­al rate of 7.4 per­cent. About 23 per­cent of Chat­tanooga res­id­ents live be­low the poverty line, ac­cord­ing to the most re­cent census fig­ures; statewide, the av­er­age is 17 per­cent.

An­ec­dot­ally, food-bank work­ers say they’re see­ing more and more fam­il­ies de­pend­ing on the food pan­tries. These are work­ing people, not des­ti­tute enough to qual­i­fy for fed­er­ally fun­ded food stamps but who non­ethe­less re­main hungry. “Be­fore the re­ces­sion, we used to see primar­ily dis­abled people who couldn’t work, or the un­em­ployed,” says Holly Ash­ley, a spokes­per­son for the Chat­tanooga Area Food Bank. “Now, we’re see­ing more people who are un­der­em­ployed.”

When those without col­lege de­grees do find work, they say there’s little job se­cur­ity, even at the new Volk­swa­gen or Amazon plants, ar­gu­ably two of the bright­est stars of the Chat­tanooga eco­nomy. Smith got laid off after one year at Volk­swa­gen. His friend, James Mas­sey, 21, worked a sea­son­al job at Amazon with no hope of it lead­ing to a full-time po­s­i­tion. Res­id­ents say that’s the way both plants hire most of their work­ers: through tem­por­ary agen­cies where people can be hired and fired based on the com­pan­ies’ sup­ply and de­mand.

“When busi­ness goes down, they lay off people. In peak sea­sons, they’ll hire 500 to 600 people and then lay most of them off later,” says Duane Parks, a 29-year-old Chat­tanooga nat­ive. “I want to have some sta­bil­ity in my ca­reer.”

This di­ver­gent Chat­tanooga eco­nomy — with its sep­ar­ate tracks for high-skilled versus low-skilled work­ers — is in­dic­at­ive of the na­tion­wide trend of a dis­ap­pear­ing middle class. From 1999 un­til 2011, the real me­di­an house­hold in­come in the United States dropped by 8.9 per­cent, ac­cord­ing to the Census Bur­eau. Data like this sup­port Smith, Wade, and Mas­sey’s view of the Chat­tanooga eco­nomy as lackluster, at least for them. Still, they’re try­ing to im­prove their lives by gain­ing new skills or ap­ply­ing for a wider ar­ray of jobs.

Mean­while, highly edu­cated work­ers see the Chat­tanooga eco­nomy as on the cusp of something big, a small-sized city full of op­por­tun­ity for those who are eager and am­bi­tious. “We want six-fig­ure jobs to come to Chat­tanooga,” says 30-year-old Jack Studer, an en­tre­pren­eur who re­turned here after work­ing at an in­vest­ment bank and soft­ware com­pany. “Frankly, those 2,000 or so jobs at Volk­swa­gen pay barely above the poverty line. That’s part of the old Chat­tanooga eco­nomy — where things were 10 years ago.”

But, Chat­tanooga’s “old” eco­nomy worked much bet­ter for those with less edu­ca­tion. It gave work­ers like Smith jobs that paid over $20 an hour. The new may­or, Andy Berke, says he wants to im­prove the edu­ca­tion­al sys­tem to give less-skilled work­ers more op­por­tun­it­ies. Yet there is no grand city plan to ac­com­plish that. Many of the city’s elite and eco­nom­ic-de­vel­op­ment of­fi­cials sug­gest that a know­ledge-based eco­nomy will cre­ate wealth, which will trickle down to a great­er swath of res­id­ents. So far, that has failed to hap­pen, even with a spurt of de­vel­op­ment that began in the early 1990s.

This eco­nom­ic di­vide re­mains one of Chat­tanooga’s biggest chal­lenges, ac­cord­ing a 2008 case study by the Brook­ings In­sti­tu­tion. Much of the growth of down­town and the en­su­ing de­vel­op­ment has not linked to or helped Chat­tanooga’s poorest neigh­bor­hoods, the re­port says.

“Chat­tanooga as a tech­no­logy hub? That is b.s.,” says Mas­sey at the job-train­ing work­shop. “There are not many tech jobs here.” For less-edu­cated, lower-skilled work­ers, it just seems that the city has few­er jobs over­all to of­fer them. “Chat­tanooga his­tor­ic­ally has been very fo­cused on man­u­fac­tur­ing,” says Dav­id Penn, an as­so­ci­ate pro­fess­or of eco­nom­ics at Middle Ten­ness­ee State Uni­versity. “It has made some gains in man­u­fac­tur­ing with the Volk­swa­gen plant, but it’s still down in man­u­fac­tur­ing jobs and still down in the total num­ber of jobs.”

Penn com­mends the city for try­ing to di­ver­si­fy its eco­nomy by en­cour­aging growth in tech com­pan­ies and man­u­fac­tur­ing, along­side more tra­di­tion­al com­pan­ies such as Chat­tanooga Bakery or the in­sur­ance com­pany Un­um. But many of Chat­tanooga’s res­id­ents are still wait­ing for that di­ver­si­fic­a­tion to trans­late in­to the good life for them.

What We're Following See More »
FCC Tightens Internet Privacy Standards
3 hours ago

Along party lines, the Federal Communications Commission on Thursday voted to tighten privacy standards for Internet service providers. "The regulations will require providers to receive explicit customer consent before using an individual’s web browsing or app usage history for marketing purposes. The broadband industry fought to keep that obligation out of the rules."

Obama Commutes Another 98 Sentences
4 hours ago

President Obama commuted the sentences of another 98 drug offenders on Thursday. Most of the convicts were charged with conspiracy to distribute drugs or possession with intent to distribute. Many of the sentences were commuted to expire next year, but some will run longer. Others are required to enroll in residential drug treatment as a condition of their release.

DOJ Busts More Than 50 for Call Center Scam
4 hours ago

The Department of Justice announced today it's charged "61 individuals and entities for their alleged involvement in a transnational criminal organization that has victimized tens of thousands of persons in the United States through fraudulent schemes that have resulted in hundreds of millions of dollars in losses. In connection with the scheme, 20 individuals were arrested today in the United States and 32 individuals and five call centers in India were charged for their alleged involvement. An additional U.S.-based defendant is currently in the custody of immigration authorities."

Johnson on Ballot Everywhere, Followed by Stein, McMullin
6 hours ago
Is McMullin Building the GOP in Exile?
8 hours ago

Evan McMullin, the independent conservative candidate who may win his home state of Utah, is quietly planning to turn his candidacy into a broader movement for principled conservatism. He tells BuzzFeed he's "skeptical" that the Republican party can reform itself "within a generation" and that the party's internal "disease" can't be cured via "the existing infrastructure.” The ex-CIA employee and Capitol Hill staffer says, “I have seen and worked with a lot of very courageous people in my time [but] I have seen a remarkable display of cowardice over the last couple of months in our leaders.” McMullin's team has assembled organizations in the 11 states where he's on the ballot, and adviser Rick Wilson says "there’s actually a very vibrant market for our message in the urban northeast and in parts of the south."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.