Visualizing the Obamacare Snafu

IT experts say the online marketplace failed due to flawed website architecture. Here’s a chart that puts that in perspective.

National Journal
Brian Resnick
See more stories about...
Brian Resnick
Oct. 7, 2013, 7:53 a.m.

This is what an on­line health care ex­change looks like:

Func­tions

The fed­er­al health-ex­change mar­ket­place, ar­chi­tec­tur­ally, is a mess. That, at least, is the con­sensus of IT ex­perts ex­plain­ing to re­port­ers why so few people were able to sign up on­line for health in­sur­ance last week.

  • In the Wall Street Journ­al: “Such a hast­ily con­struc­ted web­site may not have been able to with­stand the on­line de­mand last week.”

  • On Re­u­ters: “Five out­side tech­no­logy ex­perts in­ter­viewed by Re­u­ters, however, say they be­lieve flaws in sys­tem ar­chi­tec­ture, not traffic alone, con­trib­uted to the prob­lems.”

  • On Wonkblog: “Most of the prob­lems like these are in the soft­ware. Hard­ware is the easy part. You can add more hard­ware and do it eas­ily. Soft­ware takes more time.”

Health and Hu­man Ser­vices of­fi­cials ad­mit­ted to The Wall Street Journ­al that the web­site has cod­ing is­sues, and that they “can do bet­ter and we are work­ing around the clock to do so.”

Na­tion­al Journ­al‘s Mar­got Sanger-Katz pre­dicted this out­come. In Ju­ly, she wrote about the lo­gist­ic­al dif­fi­culties of open­ing the ex­changes, es­pe­cially in cre­at­ing an in­form­a­tion hub that ties dis­par­ate streams of data from vari­ous gov­ern­ment agen­cies. The chart at the top of the page tries to sim­pli­fy what that looks like.

“In an ideal world,” she re­por­ted, “the ex­change web­sites need to be able to talk to sev­er­al fed­er­al agen­cies — IRS to veri­fy an ap­plic­ant’s in­come and em­ploy­ment status, the De­part­ment of Home­land Se­cur­ity to de­term­ine her cit­izen­ship, and the state gov­ern­ment to see if she qual­i­fies for Medi­caid, to name a few — all in real time.”

She con­tin­ued: “It is in­creas­ingly clear that the kind of Amazon.com, one-stop shop­ping that was once de­scribed … will not be avail­able in most parts of the coun­try.”

Well, Amazon it is not. But time might fix the on­line mar­ket­place. Speak­ing to The Switch, an IT ex­pert in­volved with its im­ple­ment­a­tion said the first rocky week may not be in­dic­at­ive of lar­ger Obama­care in­fra­struc­ture prob­lems. But if it is, prob­lems could con­tin­ue to trickle down, for in­stance, when people get the bills for their new in­sur­ance plans.

While the design com­plex­it­ies don’t ab­solve the ad­min­is­tra­tion from blame, they do put the ex­change prob­lem in some per­spect­ive. If and when health­care.gov is up and run­ning smoothly, it will be con­sidered an ac­com­plish­ment of in­form­a­tion tech­no­logy in gov­ern­ment, which tends to lag far be­hind the private sec­tor.

What We're Following See More »
TIME IS ‘BEST SPENT CAMPAIGNING’
Clinton Won’t Debate Sanders on Fox News
6 minutes ago
THE LATEST

Hillary Clinton will not debate Bernie Sanders on Fox News before the California primary next month. Sanders had already agreed to the debate. Clinton spokeswoman Jennifer Palmieri said Clinton’s time “is best spent campaigning and meeting directly with voters across California and preparing for a general election campaign that will ensure the White House remains in Democratic hands.”

Source:
TIME IS ‘BEST SPENT CAMPAIGNING’
Clinton Won’t Debate Sanders on Fox News
6 minutes ago
THE LATEST

Hillary Clinton will not debate Bernie Sanders on Fox News before the California primary next month. Sanders had already agreed to the debate. Clinton spokeswoman Jennifer Palmieri said Clinton’s time “is best spent campaigning and meeting directly with voters across California and preparing for a general election campaign that will ensure the White House remains in Democratic hands.”

Source:
FORMERLY THE DEPT’S TOP ATTORNEY
Transportation Sec. Names Special Adviser for Metro System
10 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx has appointed a veteran legal insider with strong personal ties to the Obama administration to serve as his special adviser focused exclusively on fixing the Washington region’s troubled Metro system. Kathryn Thomson, who was expected to leave her job as the Department of Transportation’s top lawyer, instead will stay on as Foxx’s special adviser on Metro oversight." She'll start this week.

Source:
THE QUESTION
How Much Has Trump Loaned His Campaign?
20 hours ago
THE ANSWER

"More than $43 million, although the loans are loans in name only — Trump says he has no intention of recouping the cash."

Source:
NO STAFF IN OHIO
Trump Has the Poll Numbers; Does He Have the Organization?
20 hours ago
WHY WE CARE

While Donald Trump's poll numbers are steadily climbing, he "trails far behind" Hillary Clinton "in organizing in key general-election states. Ohio ... presents both ... Trump's best opportunity to carry a big swing state and reveals his team's steep logistical challenges. After winning the GOP nomination on a tight budget with a skeletal staff ... Trump doesn't have any general-election staff in the state, and senior aides in New York and Washington haven't made contact with the state Republican Party. Efforts to recruit the state's experienced operatives who helped elect" John Kasich "have so far been unsuccessful, people familiar with the matter said." Clinton "has a small team of full-time aides in Ohio."

Source:
×