As North American oil production continues to outpace pipeline capacity, railways are increasingly filling the gap. But a series of explosive Canadian derailments have raised questions about rail as a transportation alternative, and some are saying that oil gone off-the-tracks underscores the need for pipeline expansion.
“You saw the train accident in Canada,” said House Energy and Commerce Committee Chairman Fred Upton, R-Mich., when asked about the proposed Keystone XL pipeline carrying heavy crude from Canada to U.S. refineries. He called pipelines “cheaper and safer” than trains.
Even Keystone opponents are wary of the burgeoning oil-by-rail industry. “Oil companies have started facing a pipeline bottleneck,” said Keith Stewart, climate and energy campaign coordinator for Greenpeace Canada. As a result, railcars are carrying more and more oil, a method that has “been unsafe since the 1990s.”¦ [But the cars] continue to be used.”
For Stewart, rail problems and pipeline-safety issues are a signal that it’s time for heavier investment in renewable energy because petroleum transport will always present environmental risks.
Others see it differently. North American oil production continues to climb, say industry groups and pipeline advocates, and current consumer demand dictates that it will reach the market one way or another. In the U.S., oil-by-rail shipments have doubled in two years, from 700,000 barrels a day to 1.4 million. Western Canada, shipping minimal amounts of crude by rail at the start of last year, now exports 150,000 barrels per day on trains. That number could jump to 360,000 barrels by the end of 2014, according to industry data and analysis company IHS.
TransCanada, the prospective builder of the Keystone XL pipeline, estimates North American trains could be moving 2 million barrels a day before 2014 is out.
That expansion has allowed the industry to bring North American oil to market while pipelines catch up. But not everyone sees that as a good thing. In July, a freight train carrying crude oil derailed in Lac-Mégantic, Quebec, killing 42 in the subsequent explosion. Canada tightened safety standards related to the specifics of that disaster, but a Saturday derailment and explosion in Alberta has renewed worries.
Just as the Quebec derailment has become a flash point for the dangers of rail transport, critics often cite the 2010 Enbridge pipeline spill into Michigan’s Kalamazoo River as an example of pipeline dangers. More than 1 million gallons of crude flowed into the river, thanks to a 17-hour delay between the initial alarms and the company’s reaction. Dredging cleanups have continued as recently as this year, as the diluted bitumen shipped in the pipeline sunk to the river bottom.
Still, said Upton, that spill — the effects of which made it downstream to his district — should not be a reason to stop pipeline expansion. He noted that the pipeline-safety bill he sponsored in 2011, and that was signed into law in early 2012, requires faster spill reporting and greater accountability for pipeline operators. “Isn’t it better to put it in a pipeline than it is in a ship or a truck or rail?” he asked.
What We're Following See More »
"Even as he acknowledged the importance of an open internet, FCC Chairman Ajit Pai on Wednesday set his telecom agency on a course to scrap the tough, broad net neutrality protections imposed by the Obama administration. During a major speech in Washington, D.C., Pai outlined the need for a total revision of existing federal rules that seek to prevent companies like AT&T, Charter, Comcast and Verizon from blocking or slowing down web content, including the movie or music offerings from their competitors." Separately, Pai told Reason's Nick Gillespie that the Clinton Administration "basically got it right when it came to digital infrastructure. We were not living in a digital dystopia in the years leading up to 2015."
The White House on Wednesday laid out its plan for tax reform, with Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin saying it would be "the biggest tax cut and the largest tax reform in the history of our country." The tax code would be broken down into just three tax brackets, with the highest personal income tax rate cut from 39.6 percent to 35 percent. The plan would also slash the tax rate on corporations and small businesses from 35 percent to 15 percent. "The White House plan is a set of principles with few details, but it’s designed to be the starting point of a major push to urge Congress to pass a comprehensive tax reform package this year," said National Economic Council Director Gary Cohn.
U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement today established the Victims of Immigration Crime Engagement (VOICE), as called for in a presidential executive order from January. The new office's website states that its staff "will be guided by a singular, straightforward mission—to ensure victims and their families have access to releasable information about a perpetrator and to offer assistance explaining the immigration removal process."