What Kind of Conservative Will Marco Rubio Be Today?

He shifts from pragmatist on immigration to ideologue on Obamacare, a tactical change that says more about his ambition than policy position.

Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL) talks to reporters on Capitol Hill March 22, 2013 in Washington, DC.
National Journal
Beth Reinhard
Oct. 30, 2013, 1:30 p.m.

Sen. Marco Ru­bio once spear­headed com­pre­hens­ive im­mig­ra­tion re­form. Now he’s ad­voc­at­ing a piece­meal ap­proach be­cause “if we stick to the po­s­i­tion of all or noth­ing, we’re go­ing to end up with noth­ing.”

But “all or noth­ing” is ex­actly the strategy the Flor­ida Re­pub­lic­an ad­op­ted earli­er this month, sid­ing with oth­er tea-party-backed law­makers to shut­ter the gov­ern­ment by re­fus­ing to pass a spend­ing bill if it didn’t dis­mantle the health care law.

Ru­bio’s chan­ging tac­tics re­flect strenu­ous ef­forts to keep a foot in each of the war­ring camps of his party as he weighs a pres­id­en­tial bid. Is he an Obama­care-bash­ing tea-party hero who won’t budge from con­ser­vat­ive prin­ciples, like his pos­sible 2016 rival, Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas? Or is he the prag­mat­ic Re­pub­lic­an le­gis­lat­or open to com­prom­ise with Demo­crats to chart pub­lic policy, a la New Jer­sey Gov. Chris Christie?

His sup­port­ers say it may be pos­sible for the son of Cuban im­mig­rants who fre­quently in­vokes the Amer­ic­an Dream to find a middle ground.

“His com­fort zone has al­ways been more of the Re­aganesque op­tim­ist, and that is what en­deared him to Re­pub­lic­ans as a po­ten­tial nom­in­ee,” said long­time strategist Alex Cas­tel­lanos, who launched Ne­wRe­pub­lic­an.org to help get his party on track. “When Ru­bio looks like an in­side-Wash­ing­ton deal-cut­ter or an em­blem of the ‘party of no,’ either one of those un­der­mines his greatest strength, which is ex­actly what the party needs right now: op­tim­ism and vis­ion.”

But Ru­bio’s path is un­clear, con­found­ing even some of his long­time al­lies. This week, as hun­dreds of busi­ness, faith, and law-en­force­ment lead­ers kicked off a massive, last-ditch lob­by­ing ef­fort for im­mig­ra­tion re­form, Amer­ic­an Con­ser­vat­ive Uni­on Chair­man Al Carde­n­as called Ru­bio’s re­treat from a com­pre­hens­ive ap­proach “un­pro­duct­ive.”

“I don’t un­der­stand it,” said Carde­n­as, a former chair­man of the Flor­ida Re­pub­lic­an Party and Ru­bio’s one­time ment­or. “I wasn’t pleased with it.”

Ru­bio’s team says the sen­at­or is simply try­ing to keep the bill mov­ing and find com­mon ground with House Re­pub­lic­ans, who have re­fused to vote on the Sen­ate’s com­pre­hens­ive le­gis­la­tion. “Sen­at­or Ru­bio is just be­ing real­ist­ic about what’s pos­sible in the cur­rent polit­ic­al en­vir­on­ment,” said Alex Con­ant, Ru­bio’s press sec­ret­ary. “It’s not real­ist­ic to be­lieve that the House is go­ing to take up and pass the Sen­ate bill.”

So as he cru­sades against Obama­care and tip­toes on im­mig­ra­tion, Ru­bio ap­pears to be try­ing to pla­cate both the most con­ser­vat­ive wing of his party and a more mod­er­ate GOP es­tab­lish­ment strain­ing to reach a di­ver­si­fy­ing elect­or­ate. (In­deed, while Ru­bio pushed to de­fund Obama­care, once his Re­pub­lic­an col­leagues and the party’s ma­jor donors began con­demning the shut­down, he let Cruz take cen­ter stage.)

On im­mig­ra­tion, though, his shift­ing mes­sage puts him at risk of be­ing dis­missed as a polit­ic­al op­por­tun­ist rather than her­al­ded as a bridge-build­ing party lead­er who tried to tackle one of the na­tion’s thorn­i­est prob­lems.

“There’s a need to go bey­ond polit­ic­al po­s­i­tion­ing and serve as a vis­ion­ary for the party. Ru­bio has polit­ic­al skills you just can’t teach,” said Re­pub­lic­an con­sult­ant Kev­in Mad­den, who ad­vised former GOP nom­in­ee Mitt Rom­ney. “What could Amer­ica look like once we’ve moved past this failed Obama ex­per­i­ment? Ru­bio can frame that an­swer out for the party faith­ful and oth­er voters the party also needs to win.”

Ru­bio didn’t re­spond when House lead­ers quickly re­jec­ted the sweep­ing Sen­ate bill in June and its fate looked un­cer­tain. In­stead, he shif­ted to oth­er is­sues that are far more pop­u­lar with his con­ser­vat­ive base: He con­sidered spon­sor­ing a ban on abor­tion after 20 weeks of preg­nancy but nev­er filed a bill, then spent most of the sum­mer and fall ral­ly­ing op­pos­i­tion to Obama­care.

“What Sen­at­or Ru­bio doesn’t want to do is con­vey the im­pres­sion that he’s look­ing for way to re­deem him­self from an at­tempt to pass im­mig­ra­tion policy that kind of blew apart,” Cas­tel­lanos said. “He doesn’t need to bounce off the walls to find the next vehicle to carry him to the pres­id­ency.”

Ru­bio’s re­pos­i­tion­ing on im­mig­ra­tion is par­tic­u­larly sens­it­ive con­sid­er­ing his re­cord on the is­sue. As the first Cuban-Amer­ic­an lead­er of the Flor­ida House, he dis­tanced him­self from bills aimed at crack­ing down on il­leg­al im­mig­ra­tion. But dur­ing his 2010 Sen­ate cam­paign, as he por­trayed him­self as the true con­ser­vat­ive in the Re­pub­lic­an primary, he de­clared that “earned path to cit­izen­ship is ba­sic­ally code for am­nesty.” He won the elec­tion and was im­me­di­ately hailed as one of the party’s bright­est stars.

Ru­bio began ad­voc­at­ing status for young people brought to this coun­try il­leg­ally in the spring. After the 2012 elec­tion, as a num­ber of prom­in­ent Re­pub­lic­ans lamen­ted the His­pan­ic com­munity’s re­jec­tion of the party, Ru­bio broached the idea of a step-by-step over­haul of the im­mig­ra­tion sys­tem. He didn’t em­brace a more sweep­ing ap­proach to im­mig­ra­tion re­form un­til Janu­ary; then, he joined a bi­par­tis­an group of sen­at­ors and be­came an in­defatig­able cham­pi­on of the bill un­til it passed in June.

The is­sue is likely to keep the Re­pub­lic­an Party tied in knots as it nav­ig­ates the struggle between the tea-party move­ment and busi­ness-ori­ented es­tab­lish­ment from now through the 2014, per­haps even the 2016, elec­tion.

Ru­bio said he’s not giv­ing up on an over­haul. “It’s an is­sue we have a lot of con­sensus on, on 95 per­cent of the is­sues,” he said in a Cap­it­ol Hill in­ter­view. “And my hope is we can start mak­ing pro­gress on those and mov­ing us closer to solv­ing the is­sue in to­tal­ity.”

Re­pub­lic­an con­sult­ant Rob Jes­mer, who at­ten­ded a U.S. Cham­ber of Com­merce event this week aimed at jump­start­ing le­gis­lat­ive ac­tion, said cri­ti­cism of Ru­bio’s re­cent com­ments was un­fair and un­pro­duct­ive. “The way to get im­mig­ra­tion re­form to pass,” he said, “is not to trash the single most im­port­ant guy in passing it.”

What We're Following See More »
FIRST WOMAN NOMINATED BY MAJOR PARTY
Hillary Clinton Accepts the Democratic Nomination for President
3 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"It is with humility, determination, and boundless confidence in America’s promise that I accept your nomination for president," said Hillary Clinton in becoming the first woman to accept a nomination for president from a major party. Clinton gave a wide-ranging address, both criticizing Donald Trump and speaking of what she has done in the past and hopes to do in the future. "He's taken the Republican party a long way, from morning in America to midnight in America," Clinton said of Trump. However, most of her speech focused instead on the work she has done and the work she hopes to do as president. "I will be a president of Democrats, Republicans, and Independents. For the struggling, the striving, the successful," she said. "For those who vote for me and for those who don't. For all Americans together."

COUNTER-CHANTS AT THE READY
Protesters Make Good on Threat to Disrupt Speech
3 hours ago
THE LATEST

Supporters of Bernie Sanders promised to walk out, turn their backs, or disrupt Hillary Clinton's speech tonight, and they made good immediately, with an outburst almost as soon as Clinton began her speech. But her supporters, armed with a handy counter-chant cheat sheet distributed by the campaign, immediately began drowning them out with chants of "Hillary, Hillary!"

SUFFOLK POLL
New Survey Shows Clinton Up 9 in Pennsylvania
11 hours ago
THE LATEST

If a new poll is to be believed, Hillary Clinton has a big lead in the all-important swing state of Pennsylvania. A new Suffolk University survey shows her ahead of Donald Trump, 50%-41%. In a four-way race, she maintains her nine-point lead, 46%-37%. "Pennsylvania has voted Democratic in the past six presidential elections, going back to Bill Clinton’s first win in 1992. Yet it is a rust belt state that could be in play, as indicated by recent general-election polling showing a close race."

Source:
THREE NIGHTS RUNNING
Democrats Beat Republicans in Convention Ratings So Far
12 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Wednesday was the third night in a row that the Democratic convention enjoyed a ratings win over the Republican convention last week. Which might have prompted a fundraising email from Donald Trump exhorting supporters not to watch. "Unless you want to be lied to, belittled, and attacked for your beliefs, don't watch Hillary's DNC speech tonight," the email read. "Instead, help Donald Trump hold her accountable, call out her lies and fight back against her nasty attacks."

Source:
SHIFT FROM ROMNEY’S NUMBERS
Catholics, Highly Educated Moving Toward Dems
16 hours ago
THE LATEST

Catholics who attend mass at least weekly have increased their support of the Democratic nominee by 22 points, relative to 2012, when devout Catholics backed Mitt Romney. Meanwhile, a Morning Consult poll shows that those voters with advanced degrees prefer Hillary Clinton, 51%-34%. Which, we suppose, makes the ideal Clinton voter a Catholic with a PhD in divinity.

×