Medicaid Work Requirements Spur Uncertainty, Legal Challenges

Experts caution there could be effects on everyone in the program, not just the intended targets.

Kentucky Gov. Matt Bevin meeting with President Trump at the White House on Jan. 11.
AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster
Erin Durkin
Add to Briefcase
Erin Durkin
Jan. 17, 2018, 8 p.m.

The Trump administration’s move allowing states to impose work requirements in Medicaid for the first time could have a broader impact on Americans in the entitlement program than intended, experts warn, with the policy shift leading to an increased chance of disenrollment for many patients.

Potentially 1.7 million people could be directly affected by the change, according to estimates from the Kaiser Family Foundation. Under the pathway laid out for states last week, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services will permit states to test work requirements for non-elderly, nonpregnant adult beneficiaries who are eligible for the program on a basis other than disability.

A day later, Kentucky became the first state to get a program approved that would require all able-bodied working-age adults to clock in at least 80 hours a month. Gov. Matt Bevin’s office described the program as a way to improve participants’ health and strengthen Medicaid’s long-term fiscal sustainability.

Although the requirements would apply only to certain beneficiaries, experts caution they could end up affecting all populations in Medicaid and result in the program dropping people who need care.

Most of the non-elderly Medicaid adults either are working already or face significant barriers to work, according to Kaiser, meaning the requirements would be imposed on only 7 percent of the population. But there are implications for everyone due to the documentation required.

“There is a real risk of eligible people losing coverage due to their inability to navigate these processes, miscommunication, or other breakdowns in the administrative process,” stated Kaiser in a brief released Tuesday. “People with disabilities may have challenges navigating the system to obtain an exemption for which they qualify and end up losing coverage.”

The overall effect of the requirements will depend on the way states implement them, Avalere Health President Dan Mendelson said. “It’s conceivable that you could stimulate some individuals to work that hadn’t been working before and that it would have a positive effect, but it’s equally conceivable that the net effects of this will result in denial of care to people who really need it,” he said.

Some experts expressed concern that the exemptions outlined in the CMS guidelines are not strong enough to ensure that people who cannot work won’t fall through the cracks. The guidance indicates that people who are eligible for Medicaid based on disability should be exempted, but that’s a narrow category, said Hannah Katch, senior policy analyst at the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities.

“People with a mental-health disorder, someone who was injured at work and can’t work, someone with uncontrolled diabetes who sometimes can work but sometimes not—none of those people would meet that definition, and so any of them could lose their health coverage as a result of this policy,” Katch said.

CMS’s restriction on states using Medicaid funds to remove challenges to work, such as child care or transportation, has also sparked criticism from opponents. “The bottom line here: This policy is not about helping people work; it’s just about taking health coverage from people who are unemployed,” Katch said.

Some people could also become ineligible for Medicaid in certain states by working at minimum wage, the Kaiser brief notes—and they could potentially be left without an employer-sponsored alternative.

But the change to states’ Medicaid programs does not carry the permanence that a change in statute would. This is because states are using a waiver process that allows them to get the requirements approved by the Health and Human Services Department as a so-called demonstration project.

“I think we’ll see a variety of different approaches, and the beauty is that this period will now give us some experience and that hopefully will inform longer-term policy changes,” said Nina Owcharenko Schaefer, who recently served as senior counselor to the HHS secretary and is now at the Heritage Foundation.

This mechanism, however, may also prove to be the weak spot in the federal government’s strategy, as legal questions have already started to arise in the days following the guidance’s release.

Expect litigation in the wake of the Kentucky waiver, the National Health Law Program warns, with opponents arguing it does not promote the objectives of Medicaid.

“While we are still reviewing the details of this approval … the action appears designed to achieve significant cuts in Medicaid enrollment rather than Medicaid’s stated purpose of furnishing medical assistance to low-income people,” NHeLP Legal Director Jane Perkins said in a statement.

Bevin, however, on Tuesday signed an executive order saying that Kentucky will end its Medicaid expansion if any part of the waiver is stalled in the courts.

“[A]ny delay in the implementation of the Waiver due to judicial action will cause fiscal harm to the Commonwealth and will prevent Medicaid beneficiaries from realizing the benefits under the Waiver,” the order stated.

What We're Following See More »
AND POLICE OFFICERS IN EVERY SCHOOL
Gov. Scott Wants to Raise Gun-Purchase Age to 21
1 days ago
THE LATEST
IN THE WAKE OF NEW CHARGES
Gates Expected to Plead Guilty, Cooperate with Mueller
1 days ago
THE LATEST

Former Trump campaign adviser Rick Gates is expected to plead guilty to a raft of new tax and fraud charges filed against him by special counsel Robert Mueller on Thursday. Gates is expected to cooperate with Mueller's investigation.

Source:
32 COUNTS
Mueller Hits Manafort, Gates with New Charges
1 days ago
THE LATEST

Robert Mueller announced new charges against former Trump campaign chairman Paul Manafort advisor Rick Gates. "The new indictment contains 32 counts, including tax charges." The pair had been indicted on 12 charges in October. Since then, Gates's attorneys have asked to be excused from the case.

Source:
SECOND TIME FBI FAILED TO ACT
FBI Failed To Act On Parkland Shooter Tip
2 days ago
THE DETAILS

The FBI has reported that it failed to respond to a warning from "a person close to" Nikolas Cruz, the teen accused of killing 17 people at Parkland High School on Thursday. "It was the second time the FBI apparently failed to follow up on Cruz." On the first occasion, it failed to properly investigate Cruz after it was reported to them that he left the following comment on a Youtube video: "Im going to be a school shooter."

Source:
FBI MISSED TIP ON PARKLAND SHOOTER
Florida Governor Calls on FBI Director to Resign
2 days ago
THE DETAILS

Florida Governor Rick Scott called on FBI Director Christopher Wray to resign following revelations that the FBI had failed to adequately investigate multiple warnings about Parkland High School gunman Nikolas Cruz. “The FBI’s failure to take action against this killer is unacceptable,'" said Scott. '...We constantly promote ‘see something, say something,’ and a courageous person did just that to the FBI. And the FBI failed to act.'" According to an FBI statement, the FBI failed to inform local offices of information regarding "Cruz's desire to kill people, erratic behavior, disturbing social media posts, as well as the potential of him conducting a school shooting."

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login