How Many Votes Does It Take to Go Nuclear?

WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 21: (L-R) Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN) and Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) leave the Senate floor and head to a news conference on Capitol Hill, November 21, 2013 in Washington, DC. The Senate voted 52-48 to invoke the so-called 'nuclear option', voting to change Senate rules on the controversial filibuster for most presidential nominations with a simple majority vote.
National Journal
Michael Catalini
See more stories about...
Michael Catalini
Nov. 21, 2013, 3:15 p.m.

When pos­ter­ity looks back on the day Sen­ate Ma­jor­ity Lead­er Harry Re­id, D-Nev., changed the Sen­ate’s rules and asks what play­book he was run­ning, let the re­cord show it took four votes for the Sen­ate to blow up its rules on nom­in­a­tions.

First, the scene: Re­id stood at his lectern as sen­at­ors took their seats on the floor. In the rare cases when the Sen­ate gath­ers en masse on the floor, most tend to look bored, check­ing their phones or cas­u­ally chat­ting with one an­oth­er. But on Thursday, most sen­at­ors listened at­tent­ively to Re­id and then to Minor­ity Lead­er Mitch Mc­Con­nell, R-Ky.

Hav­ing filed a mo­tion to re­con­sider Pa­tri­cia Mil­lett’s ap­point­ment to the D.C. Cir­cuit, Re­id ef­fect­ively used her nom­in­a­tion as the in­stru­ment to change the rules.

The Sen­ate’s jar­gon, while ar­cane, has a cer­tain rhythm. And as if this whole pro­cess wer­en’t mind-bend­ing enough, the ac­tu­al vote that res­ul­ted in the rules change saw Demo­crats vot­ing no. That’s be­cause the ques­tion was on up­hold­ing the rul­ing of the chair that 60 votes are needed to end de­bate on nom­in­a­tions.

With that in mind, here’s how each vote went and what you need to know about each.

  • First, there was the mo­tion to pro­ceed to the mo­tion to re­con­sider the mo­tion to in­voke clo­ture on Mil­lett. This ef­fect­ively ended de­bate on re­con­sid­er­a­tion of the clo­ture mo­tion on Mil­lett’s nom­in­a­tion. It was agreed to on a 57-40 vote with three sen­at­ors vot­ing present. All Demo­crats and Re­pub­lic­an Sens. Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska voted yes. Geor­gia Re­pub­lic­ans Saxby Cham­b­liss and Johnny Isak­son along with Or­rin Hatch of Utah voted present.
  • At this point Mc­Con­nell, per­haps stalling for time to work out a com­prom­ise, moved to ad­journ. That vote failed on a mostly party-line vote of 46-54, with Sen. Joe Manchin, D-W.Va., vot­ing with Re­pub­lic­ans.
  • Then came a mo­tion to re­con­sider the mo­tion to in­voke clo­ture on Mil­lett. This vote es­sen­tially put the Sen­ate in po­s­i­tion to in­voke clo­ture once again. It was agreed to 57-43, with Collins and Murkowski vot­ing again with Re­id. Cham­b­liss, Isak­son, and Hatch voted with the GOP.
  • After Mc­Con­nell made a few par­lia­ment­ary in­quir­ies, Re­id sought a rul­ing from the chair on wheth­er Sen­ate rules held that it takes 60 votes to in­voke clo­ture on nom­in­a­tions. Preident Pro Tem­pore Patrick Leahy, D-Vt., ruled that they do. Then Re­id ap­pealed the rul­ing. Sen­at­ors were asked wheth­er the de­cision should stand and voted 48-52 against sus­tain­ing the chair’s rul­ing. Re­id lost three Demo­crats: Manchin and Sens. Carl Lev­in of Michigan and Mark Pry­or of Arkan­sas.

At that point, the Sen­ate had of­fi­cially gone nuc­le­ar. Clear as the sound of a gavel com­ing down, right?

What We're Following See More »
FORMERLY THE DEPT’S TOP ATTORNEY
Transportation Sec. Names Special Adviser for Metro System
6 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Transportation Secretary Anthony Foxx has appointed a veteran legal insider with strong personal ties to the Obama administration to serve as his special adviser focused exclusively on fixing the Washington region’s troubled Metro system. Kathryn Thomson, who was expected to leave her job as the Department of Transportation’s top lawyer, instead will stay on as Foxx’s special adviser on Metro oversight." She'll start this week.

Source:
DEATH PENALTY CASE
SCOTUS Finds Racial Bias in Jury Selection
9 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"The Supreme Court on Monday ruled that prosecutors in Georgia violated the Constitution by striking every black prospective juror in a death penalty case against a black defendant. The vote was 7 to 1, with Justice Clarence Thomas dissenting. The case, Foster v. Chatman, No. 14-8349, arose from the 1987 trial of Timothy T. Foster, an African-American facing the death penalty for killing Queen Madge White, an elderly white woman, when he was 18."

Source:
RETRACTED FUNDING
Congressional Report Says NFL Tried To Influence Concussion Study
9 hours ago
THE LATEST

report from House Democrats charges that NFL officials retracted funding for a $16 million NIH study on head injuries after repeated unsuccessful attempts to direct the money away from a Boston University researcher and instead to scientists who might be more favorable to the league. Democrats have been trying to go after the NFL over its handling of concussion science, although the sport's popularity and increased lobbying presence has made that difficult. The new revelations about meddling in the NIH study should offer more ammo. 

Source:
LETS LOWER COURT RULING STAND
SCOTUS Denies Appeal from Virginia GOP
11 hours ago
THE LATEST

"A unanimous Supreme Court has dismissed a Republican appeal over congressional districts in Virginia. The justices on Monday left in place a decision by a lower court that said Virginia illegally packed black voters into one district to make adjacent districts safer for Republican incumbents." The Court said the Republican elected officials who challenged the decision did not have standing to do so.

Source:
THE QUESTION
How Much Has Trump Loaned His Campaign?
16 hours ago
THE ANSWER

"More than $43 million, although the loans are loans in name only — Trump says he has no intention of recouping the cash."

Source:
×