Is This the End of Antibacterial Soap?

National Journal
Brian Resnick
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Brian Resnick
Dec. 16, 2013, 7:33 a.m.

The Food and Drug Ad­min­is­tra­tion an­nounced that it is crack­ing down on soap, and this is great news for Purell.

The FDA pub­lished a con­sumer up­date Monday on triclosan, the act­ive in­gredi­ent in an­ti­bac­teri­al soap, stat­ing, “In fact, there cur­rently is no evid­ence that over-the-counter an­ti­bac­teri­al soap products are any more ef­fect­ive at pre­vent­ing ill­ness than wash­ing with plain soap and wa­ter.”

And, “Moreover, an­ti­bac­teri­al soap products con­tain chem­ic­al in­gredi­ents, such as triclosan and triclo­car­b­an, which may carry un­ne­ces­sary risks giv­en that their be­ne­fits are un­proven.”

The FDA will pro­pose a rule that would put great­er onus on man­u­fac­tur­ers to back up the “an­ti­bac­teri­al” claim.

True, much of the be­ne­fit of soap comes from the mere act of rub­bing your hands to­geth­er and rins­ing them with wa­ter. But as the FDA casts a wary eye to­ward hand soaps, there is a (slightly more) proven al­tern­at­ive — al­co­hol.

Ac­cord­ing to the Cen­ters for Dis­ease Con­trol and Pre­ven­tion, “Al­co­hol-based products are more ef­fect­ive for stand­ard hand­wash­ing or hand an­ti­sepsis by HCWs [health care work­ers] than soap or an­ti­mi­cro­bi­al soaps.” However, the CDC notes, in too-small volumes (.2 to .5 ml) soap and wa­ter are bet­ter than al­co­hol-based san­it­izers. The FDA does men­tion, however, that for food-ser­vice per­son­nel, hand san­it­izers are no sub­sti­tu­tion for wash­ing.

That be­ing said, there’s still some ques­tions be­ing raised about hand san­it­izers. The FDA has also called out al­co­hol-based hand san­it­izers in the past for claims that they can pre­vent MRSA in­fec­tions. And it is still un­clear wheth­er they work “equally well for all classes of germs,” the CDC re­ports.

In any case, GOJO, the maker of Purell, is happy to point out that its product does not con­tain triclosan.

What We're Following See More »
FORMER GOVERNOR, AMBASSADOR TO CHINA
Jon Huntsman in Line to be #2 at State
24 minutes ago
THE DETAILS
SHOW OF UNITY
Ellison Bringing New DNC Chair Perez To Trump’s Address
29 minutes ago
BREAKING
CASE TO CARRY ON
DOJ Drops Claim Against Texas’s Voter ID Law
59 minutes ago
THE LATEST

The Department of Justice "is dropping a discrimination claim against a Texas law that required voters to present identification at the polls." The case will continue to carry on with private groups who filed the lawsuit. The DOJ dropped the claim because Texas is planning to "cure the deficiencies" with the law, according to a draft copy of the dismissal motion the DOJ sent to the Campaign Legal Center. Texas Governor Jim Abbott tweeted a picture of a headline sharing the information with a caption saying "It's a new day in D.C."

Source:
TROUBLE LOOMING?
Durbin Says Government Shutdown Possible
2 hours ago
THE LATEST
AT LEAST 19 TODAY
Jewish Community Keeps Receiving Threats
2 hours ago
THE DETAILS
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login