Is the Death Penalty Dying?

Washington became the eighth state in 10 years to suspend the death penalty, as growing numbers of Americans are opposing the practice.

A view of the death chamber from the witness room at the Southern Ohio Correctional Facility in Lucasville, Ohio. 
National Journal
Add to Briefcase
Scott Bland
Feb. 13, 2014, midnight

The im­me­di­ate con­sequence of Wash­ing­ton Gov. Jay Inslee’s de­cision to sus­pend the state’s death pen­alty Tues­day fits in­to a na­tion­al trend. Eight states in the past dec­ade have rolled back the death pen­alty, an ac­cel­er­ated pace mim­ick­ing the rap­idly chan­ging pub­lic opin­ion sur­round­ing same-sex mar­riage that star­ted at the same time.

Pub­lic opin­ion over these two cul­tur­al wedge is­sues of the 1990s has changed dra­mat­ic­ally since that time. And in blue states, both pub­lic opin­ion and pub­lic policy have moved sig­ni­fic­antly since Bill Clin­ton said Demo­crats “should no longer feel guilty about pro­tect­ing the in­no­cent” with cap­it­al pun­ish­ment. (To prove he was tough on crime, Clin­ton left the cam­paign trail in 1992 to preside over the ex­e­cu­tion of con­victed mur­der­er Rickey Ray Rect­or.) Clin­ton also later signed the De­fense of Mar­riage Act bar­ring fed­er­al re­cog­ni­tion of same-sex mar­riages two dec­ades ago.

{{third­PartyEmbed type:in­ter­act­ive­google­charts source:ht­tps://docs.google.com/a/na­tion­al­journ­al.com/spread­sheet/oimg?key=0AlxQ0e­jtCLId­dE5ZW­m­VZZ2N­qLXN­vZjBx­WTdpNUl­HVlE&oid=1&zx=q7jll­h8n­bf02}}

Now, more than 100 mil­lion people live in states without the death pen­alty. Like Wash­ing­ton, Ore­gon’s death-pen­alty roll­back is a pause, not a full re­peal: Gov. John Kitzhaber an­nounced a morator­i­um on ex­e­cu­tions in 2011. Six oth­er states have per­man­ently ended cap­it­al pun­ish­ment since 2004. New York kicked things off with a court de­cision that year find­ing cap­it­al pun­ish­ment un­con­sti­tu­tion­al, a ver­dict fi­nal­ized in 2007. That’s the year New Jer­sey en­acted the coun­try’s first death-pen­alty re­peal le­gis­la­tion in dec­ades. New Mex­ico, Illinois, Con­necti­c­ut, and Mary­land all fol­lowed suit in the last sev­en years. No states had moved to undo their death pen­al­ties in the 20 years be­fore New York did a dec­ade ago.

The same day that Inslee an­nounced his de­cision in Wash­ing­ton, a state House com­mit­tee in New Hamp­shire voted 14-3 to ad­vance a death-pen­alty re­peal bill there. Ac­cord­ing to the Con­cord Mon­it­or, some of the sup­port­ers had pre­vi­ously voted against re­peal­ing cap­it­al pun­ish­ment.

Wash­ing­ton’s move is a tem­por­ary one, but Inslee said Tues­day that a goal of his de­cision was to push the state to de­cide more per­man­ently if it still wants to im­pose death on some crim­in­als. “With my ac­tion today I ex­pect Wash­ing­ton state will join a grow­ing na­tion­al con­ver­sa­tion about cap­it­al pun­ish­ment,” Inslee said in a speech. “I wel­come that and I’m con­fid­ent that our cit­izens will en­gage in this very im­port­ant de­bate.”

Richard Di­eter, the ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of the Death Pen­alty In­form­a­tion Cen­ter, said states that im­pose morator­i­ums of­ten go on to ab­ol­ish the death pen­alty en­tirely. “New Jer­sey had a morator­i­um and even­tu­ally be­came an ab­ol­i­tion state,” Di­eter said. “Illinois took 11 years and a num­ber of gov­ernors be­fore they ab­ol­ished it, but it did end up that way. But there have been states where ex­e­cu­tions were on hold and they got back to them. One gov­ernor doesn’t con­trol things.”

The Politics of the Death Penalty National Journal

Sup­port for the death pen­alty for murders, which peaked at 80 per­cent in 1994, ac­cord­ing to Gal­lup, has de­clined markedly since. The last time the polling com­pany meas­ured pub­lic opin­ion, in Oc­to­ber, sup­port was down to 60 per­cent, the low­est mark since the 1970s.

While sup­port for cap­it­al pun­ish­ment trends down­ward, sup­port for same-sex mar­riage has swung up at about the same rate, from 27 per­cent in 1996 to 54 per­cent last year, again ac­cord­ing to Gal­lup. And again, 17 mostly Demo­crat­ic-lean­ing states have moved to al­low same-sex mar­riages, start­ing with Mas­sachu­setts via a court de­cision in 2004.

Both over­lap­ping col­lec­tions of states — those without a death pen­alty and those with same-sex mar­riage — are clustered in the North­east and Up­per Mid­w­est and on the West Coast. Pres­id­ent Obama won every state that leg­al­ized same-sex mar­riage in both 2008 and 2012 and re­cor­ded the same per­fect re­cord in the states that have rolled back cap­it­al pun­ish­ment, too.

So far, Re­pub­lic­an-lean­ing states haven’t joined the last dec­ade worth of activ­ity on the death pen­alty and same-sex mar­riage, re­flect­ing how pub­lic opin­ion on both is­sues does re­main po­lar­ized. But the burst of le­gis­la­tion, court de­cisions, and gubernat­ori­al de­cisions in these blue states demon­strate how these two “cul­ture war” is­sues of two dec­ades past have joined the polit­ic­al main­stream.

×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login