Democrats Pre-But Tomorrow’s Republican Obamacare Talking Point, Today

They’re hoping to get out ahead of a new government report that suggests that premiums will go up for most small businesses.

House Democratic leaders (L-R) House Budget Committee ranking member Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D-MD), Minority Whip Steny Hoyer, Rep. Steve Israel (D-NY), Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-CA), Rep. James Clyburn (D-SC) and Rep. Xavier Becerra (D-CA) talk to reporters after meeting with U.S. President Barack Obama and Vice President Joe Biden in the Oval Office at the White House October 15, 2013 in Washington, DC.
National Journal
Alex Seitz Wald
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Alex Seitz-Wald
Feb. 21, 2014, 2:26 p.m.

After get­ting hammered on a series of gov­ern­ment re­ports that they felt Re­pub­lic­ans un­fairly char­ac­ter­ized, Demo­crats are tak­ing the un­usu­al step of re­spond­ing to an­oth­er po­ten­tially dam­aging re­port be­fore the GOP at­tacks even start.

The re­port, re­leased late Fri­day by the Ac­tu­ary of the Cen­ters for Medi­care and Medi­caid Ser­vices, looks at the im­pact two pro­vi­sions of the Af­ford­able Care Act will have on health in­sur­ance premi­ums for small busi­nesses. Re­pub­lic­ans re­ques­ted the re­port in 2011 when they slipped it in­to an ap­pro­pri­ations bill.

Demo­crats ex­pect the GOP to seize on a por­tion of the re­port that es­tim­ates that premi­ums will go up for most small firms.

“[W]e are es­tim­at­ing that 65 per­cent of the small firms are ex­pec­ted to ex­per­i­ence in­creases in their premi­um rates while the re­main­ing 35 per­cent are an­ti­cip­ated to have rate re­duc­tions,” the CMS re­port reads. “This res­ults in roughly 11 mil­lion in­di­vidu­als whose premi­ums are es­tim­ated to be high­er as a res­ult of the ACA and about 6 mil­lion in­di­vidu­als who are es­tim­ated to have lower premi­ums.”

Those are very scary words for Demo­crats, and something you could ex­pect to see in a Re­pub­lic­an at­tack ad.

But that pas­sage doesn’t tell the whole pic­ture, says Drew Ham­mill, a spokes­man for House Minor­ity Lead­er Nancy Pelosi. “This re­port is the latest in­stance of House Re­pub­lic­ans at­tempt­ing to peddle half-truths and in­com­plete data to jus­ti­fy their blind ob­ses­sion with re­peal­ing the Af­ford­able Care Act,” Ham­mill said in a state­ment. “The Ac­tu­ary notes in the re­port that the find­ings are in­com­plete, but Re­pub­lic­ans are only in­ter­ested in what they can use to mis­lead and de­ceive Amer­ic­ans about the ACA and its ef­fect on what small busi­nesses will pay for health cov­er­age.”

The staff of Rep. Henry Wax­man, the rank­ing mem­ber of the House En­ergy and Com­merce Com­mit­tee, re­spon­ded to the re­port Fri­day in de­tail, not­ing that nowhere does it say that the av­er­age premi­um for small busi­nesses over­all will go up. While premi­ums might go up for some, Wax­man’s re­but­tal says, they won’t over­all, and “[o]n av­er­age, the premi­um de­creases would be lar­ger than the premi­um in­crease.”

The re­port’s 65-35 con­clu­sion is based on the as­sump­tion that about 65 per­cent of busi­nesses cur­rently pay be­low-av­er­age prices, while 35 per­cent pay above av­er­age. After Obama­care, all busi­nesses will end up closer to the av­er­age.

That dis­par­ity comes from the fact that in­sur­ance com­pan­ies used to be able to charge more to com­pan­ies that em­ployed sick work­ers, and could also charge more for wo­men. That meant dis­pro­por­tion­ately high­er bills for a minor­ity of com­pan­ies.

Un­der Obama­care, however, that’s no longer al­lowed. In­sur­ance com­pan­ies can’t dis­crim­in­ate against sick people or wo­men. They can only charge more based on age, geo­graph­ic area, to­bacco use, and wheth­er the policy is for an in­di­vidu­al or fam­ily.

This change is good, Demo­crats say, be­cause it will make the mar­ket­place more fair. They also point out that the CMS re­port it­self leaves a lot of wiggle room. “There is a rather large de­gree of un­cer­tainty as­so­ci­ated with this es­tim­ate,” the re­port reads, adding that the real im­pact “could vary sig­ni­fic­antly.”

A RAND Cor­por­a­tion study, cited by the new re­port, ana­lyzed the im­pact of the en­tire health law on small busi­nesses’ av­er­age premi­ums and de­term­ined that “the ef­fect would be min­im­al.” The Con­gres­sion­al Budget Of­fice looked at the same ques­tion and also con­cluded that the over­all im­pact would be small, ran­ging “from an in­crease of 1 per­cent to a re­duc­tion of 2 per­cent in 2016.”

Wheth­er their pre-push-back works re­mains to be seen. In the past two weeks, Demo­crats have been raked over the coals for two dif­fer­ent CBO re­ports, and had trouble chan­ging the nar­rat­ive, even when the facts were on their side.

What We're Following See More »
A CANDIDATE TO BE ‘PROUD’ OF
Chicago Tribune Endorses Gary Johnson
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

No matter that his recall of foreign leaders leaves something to be desired, Gary Johnson is the choice of the Chicago Tribune's editorial board. The editors argue that Donald Trump couldn't do the job of president, while hitting Hillary Clinton for "her intent to greatly increase federal spending and taxation, and serious questions about honesty and trust." Which leaves them with Johnson. "Every American who casts a vote for him is standing for principles," they write, "and can be proud of that vote. Yes, proud of a candidate in 2016."

FUNERAL FOR ISRAELI LEADER
Obama Compares Peres to ‘Giants of the 20th Century’
2 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Speaking at the funeral of former Israeli Prime Minister Shimon Peres, President Obama "compared Peres to 'other giants of the 20th century' such as Nelson Mandela and Queen Elizabeth who 'find no need to posture or traffic in what's popular in the moment.'" Among the 6,000 mourners at the service was Palestinian President Mahmoud Abbas. Obama called Abbas's presence a sign of the "unfinished business of peace" in the region.

Source:
THE QUESTION
How Many New Voters Does the Clinton Campaign Aim to Register?
2 hours ago
THE ANSWER

Three million—a number that lays "bare the significant gap between Donald Trump’s bare-bones operation and the field program that Clinton and her hundreds of aides have been building for some 17 months."

Source:
“STANDING FOR PRINCIPLES”
Chicago Tribune Endorses Johnson
3 hours ago
THE LATEST

In a somewhat shocking move, the Chicago Tribune has endorsed Libertarian candidate Gary Johnson for president, saying a vote for him is one that voters "can be proud of." The editorial barely touches on Donald Trump, who the paper has time and again called "unfit to be president," before offering a variety of reasons for why it can't endorse Hillary Clinton. Johnson has been in the news this week for being unable to name a single world leader who he admires, after earlier this month being unable to identify "Aleppo," a major Syrian city in the middle of the country's ongoing war.

Source:
NEVER TRUMP
USA Today Weighs in on Presidential Race for First Time Ever
16 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"By all means vote, just not for Donald Trump." That's the message from USA Today editors, who are making the first recommendation on a presidential race in the paper's 34-year history. It's not exactly an endorsement; they make clear that the editorial board "does not have a consensus for a Clinton endorsement." But they state flatly that Donald Trump is, by "unanimous consensus of the editorial board, unfit for the presidency."

Source:
×