Why Obamacare’s Not Playing in Governors’ Races

Republicans’ attacks don’t translate well into gubernatorial contests, forcing a mixed approach to the GOP’s anti-ACA strategy.

Obamacare supporters react to the U.S. Supreme Court decision to uphold President Obama's health care law, on June 28, 2012 in Washington, DC. Today the high court upheld the whole healthcare law of the Obama Administration.
National Journal
Karyn Bruggeman
Add to Briefcase
Karyn Bruggeman
April 2, 2014, 5:42 p.m.

Anti-Obama­care mes­sages have already blanketed the air­waves in the na­tion’s com­pet­it­ive Sen­ate and House races. But so far, the Re­pub­lic­an Party’s sig­na­ture is­sue has played a con­spicu­ously small role in 2014’s com­pet­it­ive gubernat­ori­al races.

The Re­pub­lic­an Gov­ernors As­so­ci­ation has star­ted TV ad­vert­ising in four states, but Pres­id­ent Obama’s health care law fea­tures in just one: South Car­o­lina. The group’s cam­paigns against Demo­crats in Arkan­sas, Michigan, and Wis­con­sin have all fo­cused on jobs and the eco­nomy — a stark con­trast to the nearly $30 mil­lion in Obama­care at­tack ads already weathered by con­gres­sion­al Demo­crats.

Amer­ic­ans for Prosper­ity, the group tak­ing the lead in early ad­vert­ising against House and Sen­ate Demo­crats, has so far run only one tele­vi­sion ad in a gov­ernor’s race, tar­get­ing Demo­crat­ic Gov. Pat Quinn in Illinois. The fo­cus? Taxes and spend­ing. Flor­ida Gov. Rick Scott is already run­ning TV ads tar­get­ing Re­pub­lic­an-turned-Demo­crat Charlie Crist on Obama­care, but at this point, Scott’s cam­paign looks like an ex­cep­tion.

The black-and-white at­tacks seen in Sen­ate and House races fade to a muddled gray in the na­tion’s gov­ernors’ races. For starters, most of this year’s com­pet­it­ive cam­paigns are in states Obama won in 2012, mak­ing at­tacks on the law and the pres­id­ent less po­tent than in the red states that will de­term­ine con­trol of the Sen­ate.

The po­s­i­tion of Sen­ate can­did­ates is also crys­tal-clear. House Re­pub­lic­ans run­ning for the Sen­ate have all voted to re­peal Obama­care; the Sen­ate Demo­crats run­ning for reelec­tion all voted to en­act it. Gov­ernors, however, have a dif­fer­ent re­cord to run on. More than half a dozen Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernors have ex­pan­ded Medi­caid (which in the eyes of some their RGA col­leagues makes them com­pli­cit in the law’s im­ple­ment­a­tion), leav­ing at­tacks on the is­sue some­where between tricky and im­possible.

In Michigan, Demo­crat­ic former Rep. Mark Schauer has been a vo­cal sup­port­er of the law. Were he run­ning for the Sen­ate, that would make him an easy tar­get. But Re­pub­lic­an Gov. Rick Snyder has taken a more con­cili­at­ory ap­proach to­ward the Af­ford­able Care Act’s im­ple­ment­a­tion and pur­sued both Medi­caid ex­pan­sion and the cre­ation of a state in­sur­ance ex­change, the lat­ter of which ul­ti­mately failed. And he was the only Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernor who didn’t sign a let­ter from the RGA call­ing for re­peal.

In­deed, the RGA’s first two TV ads against Schauer fo­cused squarely on eco­nom­ic is­sues. Mean­while, the Demo­crat­ic Sen­ate can­did­ates in Arkan­sas and Michigan have been top tar­gets for health care-ori­ented at­tacks.

“I just don’t see a strong anti-Obama­care or ACA mes­sage mak­ing its way in­to the gov­ernor’s race,” said Doug Koop­man, a polit­ic­al sci­ence pro­fess­or at Calv­in Col­lege and a long­time ob­serv­er of Michigan polit­ics. “I don’t see the core cam­paign op­er­a­tions of the Snyder cam­paign really do­ing much with it.

“Gov­ernors ac­tu­ally have to man­age, and they’re eval­u­ated dif­fer­ently,” Koop­man con­tin­ued. “Snyder’s got some skin in the game to man­age Medi­caid ex­pan­sion well.” This is par­tic­u­larly true right now since en­roll­ment in Michigan’s ex­pan­ded Medi­caid pro­gram launched on Monday.

While some Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernors are tied to the law, some Demo­crats run­ning have suc­cess­fully dis­tanced them­selves from it. In Arkan­sas, Demo­crat­ic former Rep. Mike Ross proudly touts his four “no” votes against the ori­gin­al bill and 23 sub­sequent votes for re­peal. His Re­pub­lic­an op­pon­ent, Asa Hutchin­son, and the Arkan­sas Re­pub­lic­an Party have tried to go after an ob­scure vote taken by Ross to get the ori­gin­al bill out of com­mit­tee, but the at­tack hasn’t gained much trac­tion. In­stead, tele­vised at­tack ads are ty­ing Ross to Obama by fo­cus­ing on Ross’s votes on the eco­nom­ic stim­u­lus bill and the bail­outs of Wall Street and the auto in­dustry.

Amer­ic­ans for Prosper­ity’s un­re­lent­ing cri­ti­cism of Obama­care in Sen­ate races in­cludes Medi­caid ex­pan­sion, which it as­serts “is Obama­care” no mat­ter which way you slice it. RGA spokes­man Jon Thompson, on the oth­er hand, put it this way: “Every state is dif­fer­ent and unique — and in some states with Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernors, they saw Medi­caid ex­pan­sion as something their state could fin­an­cially nav­ig­ate, and in oth­er states, the gov­ernors saw it as something [they] could not nav­ig­ate.”

The dif­fer­ence, as Thompson ex­plained, is that “Re­pub­lic­an gov­ernors who have ex­pan­ded Medi­caid are all on re­cord say­ing Obama­care is a bad law, a dis­aster, and they are com­ply­ing with a law the best they can,” while Demo­crats like Schauer, Crist, and Vin­cent Sheheen in South Car­o­lina have been “cheer­lead­ers” for the law. It’s cer­tainly an ar­gu­ment against, but a far cry from the cut-and-dried rhet­or­ic offered by AFP and oth­ers in Sen­ate races.

It also helps that Demo­crats are mostly on of­fense in this year’s top gubernat­ori­al races, and the two key seats they are de­fend­ing in Illinois and Con­necti­c­ut are in blue states where state ex­changes have run smoothly and the pres­id­ent re­mains re­l­at­ively pop­u­lar. “Bruce Rau­ner would be mis­guided to at­tack Obama­care in the pres­id­ent’s home state, and in Con­necti­c­ut, Gov­ernor Mal­loy has done a great job get­ting people en­rolled. It’s a Demo­crat­ic state that likes the pres­id­ent. The ar­gu­ment will work in those places even less than it will in oth­ers,” said Danny Kan­ner, com­mu­nic­a­tions dir­ect­or at the Demo­crat­ic Gov­ernors As­so­ci­ation.

Obama­care won’t be far from any ma­jor elec­tion in 2014. The is­sue has already de­pressed the na­tion­al polit­ic­al en­vir­on­ment for Demo­crats, and this will mani­fest it­self in cam­paigns across the coun­try. Re­pub­lic­ans at every level have made it clear they in­tend to go after any and all ties between Demo­crats, the law, and its short­com­ings. To sum up the party’s strategy in gov­ernor’s races, RGA Chair­man Chris Christie may have said it best dur­ing his ad­dress to the Re­pub­lic­an Jew­ish Co­ali­tion in Las Ve­gas last week­end: “Here is what we stand for in 2014: Win­ning. That’s what we stand for.”

If the GOP’s early strategy is any in­dic­a­tion, Obama­care isn’t al­ways as good a path to gubernat­ori­al vic­tory as it is in fed­er­al races.

What We're Following See More »
ASSAILS FORMER PRESIDENT, STAFF
Trump: Obama Likely Behind Leaks
28 minutes ago
THE LATEST
PARTY UNITY
Perez to Be Ellison’s Guest at Trump’s Speech
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

Only three days removed from their race for the Democratic National Committee chairmanship, Rep. Keith Ellison and former Labor Secretary Tom Perez are burying the hatchet at President Trump's address to Congress. Late Monday afternoon, Ellison announced that Perez, who defeated him for the DNC job, will be his guest at the speech. "I look forward to joining Keith in the days and months ahead to show the American people that we stand with them against Donald Trump and his billionaire boys club that couldn't care less about the plight of working people," said Perez.

WOULD HAVE BROUGHT MORE WATERWAYS UNDER FEDERAL CONTROL
Trump to Sign Order Undoing Obama Water Rule
1 hours ago
THE DETAILS
RSC OPPOSITION
House Conservatives Balk on Obamacare Replacement
7 hours ago
THE LATEST

"The chairman of the influential Republican Study Committee said Monday he would vote against a draft ObamaCare replacement bill that leaked last week. Rep. Mark Walker (R-NC), head of the 172-member committee, said Monday his opposition stems from the draft bill's use of refundable tax credits." He said the current plan simply "kicks the can down the road" rather than attempt any real reform.

Source:
ENLISTS THEIR HELP IN REPEAL/REPLACE
Trump Meets with Health Execs
7 hours ago
THE LATEST
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login