How Safe Are U.S. Ferries?

Major accidents, like the one in South Korea, are unpredictable — and can be unavoidable.

Buildings on the Manhattan (right) and Jersey City skyline are seen from the Staten Island Ferry in June 2013.
National Journal
Marina Koren
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Marina Koren
April 16, 2014, 7:45 a.m.

Al­most 300 people are miss­ing off the coast of South Korea after a ferry there, car­ry­ing mostly school­chil­dren, cap­sized and sank. About 164 people have been pulled from the wreck­age, and the race to find sur­viv­ors is well un­der­way.

No one ever ex­pects a dis­aster, but this one has es­pe­cially stunned people. Pas­sen­gers say they heard a loud thud, which sug­gests the ves­sel col­lided with something, but it’s too early to tell. “This par­tic­u­lar ferry was built in Ja­pan, who make some of the best ships in the world. It wasn’t any­where near full and it was trav­el­ling a well-worn route in reas­on­ably calm seas,” the BBC’s Richard West­cott ex­plains. “The speed with which it flipped over and sank is a ma­jor con­cern.”

So if con­di­tions were near-per­fect for a smooth jour­ney, what happened? And could the same hap­pen in U.S. wa­ters?

The Amer­ic­an ferry in­dustry, which car­ries tens of mil­lions of people each year, has a good safety re­cord. It’s also heav­ily reg­u­lated by the U.S. Coast Guard and state gov­ern­ment­al agen­cies, from ves­sel design and con­struc­tion to re­pair and in­spec­tion. In a typ­ic­al year, private ferry-re­lated deaths are in the single di­gits, ac­cord­ing to the Pas­sen­ger Ves­sel As­so­ci­ation.

Still, some are wor­ried about ferry in­fra­struc­ture. An an­onym­ous cap­tain for the Staten Is­land Ferry re­cently told the New York Post that the eight boats that carry 60 mil­lion people to and from Man­hat­tan are “ill-de­signed, poorly main­tained safety haz­ards.”

“I don’t un­der­stand how the Coast Guard al­lows these boats to go out some­times,” he con­tin­ued. “They really do put people at risk. If this were a private com­pany, the Coast Guard would be all over them.”

In 2010, a ferry­boat car­ry­ing 244 people crashed in­to the St. George Ter­min­al on Staten Is­land after an elec­tric­al mal­func­tion took out its pro­pellers, in­jur­ing 50 pas­sen­gers.

The Coast Guard re­buked the un­named cap­tain’s claims. The Staten Is­land Ferry’s op­er­at­or, New York City’s De­part­ment of Trans­port­a­tion, “has been re­cog­nized as hav­ing an ag­gress­ive, pro-act­ive safety pro­gram,” the agency said. The Coast Guard con­ducts safety in­spec­tions of the ferry four times a year.

The bleak real­ity, however, is that no num­ber of in­spec­tions can ever pre­vent mari­time ac­ci­dents, in South Korea or in the U.S., es­pe­cially when ex­tern­al factors are in­volved. “It doesn’t mat­ter how well built the ship is,” BBC’s West­cott writes, “col­li­sions can sink ves­sels very quickly.”

What We're Following See More »
AFRAID HE’S TAKING SUPPORT FROM CLINTON
Democrats Taking Aim at Gary Johnson
0 minutes ago
WHY WE CARE

"Democrats panicked by third-party candidates drawing support away from Hillary Clinton are ramping up their attacks against Gary Johnson and warning that a vote for a third party is a vote for Donald Trump. Liberal groups are passing around embarrassing videos of Johnson and running ads against him warning about his positions on issues like climate change that are important to young voters and independents."

Source:
RUSSIA DENIES
Dutch Investigators: MH17 Was Downed by Russian Launcher
2 minutes ago
THE LATEST

Russo-Western relations are getting thornier all the time. "Dutch-led criminal investigators said Wednesday they have solid evidence that a Malaysian jet was shot down by a Buk missile moved into eastern Ukraine from Russia. Wilbert Paulissen, head of the Central Crime Investigation department of the Dutch National Police, said communications intercepts showed that pro-Moscow rebels had called for deployment of the mobile surface-to-air weapon, and reported its arrival in rebel-controlled areas of eastern Ukraine." Russia, of course, is denying culpability.

Source:
FIRST DEMOCRAT ENDORSEMENT EVER
Arizona Republic Endorses Clinton
6 minutes ago
WHY WE CARE

In its roughly 125-year history, the Arizona Republic has never endorsed a Democratic candidate for president. Until now. "The 2016 Republican candidate is not conservative and he is not qualified," the editors write, as they throw their support to Hillary Clinton.

Source:
TO BE INCLUDED IN SEPARATE BILL
Deal on Flint Aid Likely to Avert Shutdown
10 minutes ago
WHY WE CARE

Speaker of the House Paul Ryan and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi have reached a deal which is likely to avert a government shutdown. The biggest impediment had been the GOP's refusal to include funding for Flint water system reconstruction in the continuing resolution, and this solution provides an alternative measure likely to appease both sides. The funding for Flint will be included in the Water Resources and Development Act as an amendment to the version passed by the House of Representatives, one which will be passed in the senate. It now appears likely that Congress will in fact be able to keep the government open.

Source:
GOP REFUSED VOTE ON FCC COMMISIONER
Reid Blocks Tech Bill Over “Broken Promise”
16 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Monday night's debate may have inspired some in Congress, as Senate Minority Leader has decided to take a stand of his own. Reid is declining to allow a vote on a "bipartisan bill that would bolster U.S. spectrum availability and the deployment of wireless broadband." Why? Because of a "broken promise" made a year ago by Republicans, who have refused to vote on confirmation for a Democratic commissioner on the Federal Communications Commission to a second term. Harry Reid then took it a step further, invoking another confirmation vote still outstanding, that of Supreme Court nominee Merrick Garland.

Source:
×