How Hillary Clinton Could Squander Her Second Chance

Webb Hubbell offers his old friend and partner redemptive advice: Get real.

National Journal
Ron Fournier
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Ron Fournier
June 14, 2014, 1:49 p.m.

Har­old Ickes’ whis­key-gravel voice rolls like a storm cloud above the crowd of 60 people jammed in­side a church par­lor to hon­or Webb Hub­bell, a newly pub­lished au­thor and dis­graced pal of Bill and Hil­lary Clin­ton. “You went through un­mit­ig­ated hell,” Ickes thun­ders. “How did that ex­per­i­ence in­flu­ence your book?”

Hub­bell blinks hard three times and grins at Ickes, the Demo­crat­ic Party le­gend pushed out of the Clin­ton White House in 1996. “I couldn’t have writ­ten this if I hadn’t gone through the hell,” Hub­bell replies. “Then again, I couldn’t have writ­ten it if I hadn’t had the heights.”

Just six blocks away ““ at this ex­act mo­ment ““ Hil­lary Clin­ton marches in­to a George Wash­ing­ton Uni­versity aud­it­or­i­um. Like a moth­er duck and her duck­lings, she’s trailed at every stop of her book tour by rest­less journ­al­ists and ad­or­ing crowds.

She wants a second chance at the pres­id­ency. Hub­bell knows all about second chances, and he cer­tainly knows Clin­ton, the wo­man he brought in­to Little Rock’s Rose Law Firm, ment­ored, and later fol­lowed to Wash­ing­ton, where the sprawl­ing White­wa­ter in­vest­ig­a­tion swept him in­to pris­on and polit­ic­al ex­ile.

“This time around, be true to your­self,” Hub­bell tells me, us­ing the second-per­son pro­noun to in­dir­ectly ad­vise Clin­ton. “You’re still try­ing to cre­ate — ” he stops him­self.  “You’ve got so many people around you try­ing to shape your im­age that you lack “¦”

“Au­then­ti­city?” I sug­gest.

Hub­bell nods. Shift­ing to the third-per­son, he says of Clin­ton, “I think that in­stead she needs to be her­self. She’s a great per­son.”

Who is Hil­lary?

Her book tour is not go­ing great. Clin­ton seems to be re­peat­ing the cent­ral mis­take of her 2008 pres­id­en­tial cam­paign, bury­ing her per­son­al­ity and pas­sion be­neath re­dund­ant lay­ers of cau­tion, cal­cu­la­tion and de­fens­ive­ness.

The cam­paign to sell “Hard Choices” ““ a test run for the 2016 pres­id­en­tial cam­paign ““ began with Clin­ton telling ABC’s Di­ane Saw­yer that she and her hus­band were “dead broke” when they left the White House. While that’s per­haps true in a lit­er­al sense, the re­mark ig­nored dead-cer­tain plans for the Clin­tons to make more money per speech than an av­er­age Amer­ic­an earns in a year.

Then, dur­ing an ex­cru­ci­at­ing sev­en-minute span with NPR’s Terry Gross, Clin­ton fought a fair-minded at­tempt to cla­ri­fy her evol­u­tion on gay mar­riage. A bet­ter an­swer would have been the easi­est one: “Like many Amer­ic­ans, I didn’t al­ways sup­port gay mar­riage. It was a mis­take. As pres­id­ent, I’ll nev­er let polit­ics de­term­ine my de­cision-mak­ing. Now, let me tell you when and why I changed …”

On Fri­day, Clin­ton was asked wheth­er she feels more able to speak her mind freely. “I think that’s true, from some of the re­ac­tions I’ve had the last few days.” The sold-out audi­ence laughed. But she soun­ded ser­i­ous about tap­ping her in­ner-hon­esty.

“Maybe be­cause I’m totally done with be­ing really care­ful about what to say be­cause some­body might think this in­stead of that,” Clin­ton con­tin­ued, ac­cord­ing to the Wash­ing­ton Ex­am­iner. “It just gets too ex­haust­ing, and it just seems a whole lot easi­er to just put it out there and hope people get used to it.”

Hub­bell isn’t the only per­son en­cour­aging Clin­ton to get real. I wrote a column six months ago that channeled her closest as­so­ci­ates ur­ging Clin­ton to run a rad­ic­ally atyp­ic­al cam­paign ““ ac­cess­ible, au­then­t­ic, in­sur­gent and pop­u­list. One of the sources of that column, a top ad­viser, told me last week, “My friend is mak­ing the same old mis­takes.”

Second chances

It’s after 9 p.m. be­fore Hub­bell’s friends and fam­ily clear out the front par­lor of St. John’s Church, across La­fay­ette Park from the White House. While we’re not per­son­al friends, I’ve known and liked Hub­bell since the 1980s, when I worked in Arkan­sas me­dia. He’s had a life of second chances.

Hub­bell was draf­ted by the Chica­go Bears, but a shred­ded knee got him cut by le­gendary coach George Halas, who Hub­bell still calls “Papa Bear.” A $1,000 sev­er­ance check helped Hub­bell pay for gradu­ate school and launch his ca­reer.

A top Arkan­sas law­yer, a former Little Rock, Ark., may­or (one of the na­tion’s young­est from 1979-82) and former chief justice of the Arkan­sas Su­preme Court, Hub­bell be­came the third-rank­ing law­yer in the Clin­ton ad­min­is­tra­tion. For a single, chaot­ic year, he was the fam­ily’s man at Justice.

Then came the White­wa­ter in­vest­ig­a­tion. Launched to re­view a Clin­ton land deal that was nev­er proven any­thing but small-bore and leg­al, White­wa­ter grew in­to a sprawl­ing web of in­quires that in­cluded Hub­bell’s work at the Rose Law Firm. He ad­mit­ted to over-billing some of his former cli­ents and was sen­tenced in 1995 to 21 months’ in pris­on.

Now he’s the au­thor of a well-re­ceived nov­el, “When Men Be­tray.” At his book party, sev­er­al friends cornered me to gripe about Bill Clin­ton. He let Hub­bell go to jail, they com­plained, while the in­vestor Marc Rich re­ceived an in­fam­ous el­ev­enth-hour par­don.

I tell Hub­bell about the com­plaints, and he shrugs. “I nev­er asked for a par­don,” he says softly. “I didn’t want to put a friend in a bad po­s­i­tion by ask­ing for a polit­ic­al fa­vor.”

In 2010, Hub­bell was dia­gnosed with a liv­er dis­ease. He was dy­ing, and Bill Clin­ton vis­ited his home in North Car­o­lina to say good­bye. Then came new life: A young man died in a hunt­ing ac­ci­dent, and his fam­ily had donated his liv­er. Hub­bell got it.

He’s healthy now, thank­ful for his wife, Su­zy, grand­chil­dren, friends and George ““ the nick­name he gave his liv­er be­fore he learned that the young donor’s name was “¦. George.

Hub­bell gives me a hug and nods out the church win­dow ““ to­ward the White House and the aud­it­or­i­um bey­ond where Hil­lary Clin­ton and her en­tour­age are gath­er­ing. “I hope she’s happy, too,” he says. “This is a coun­try of second chances.”

What We're Following See More »
House to Vote on Iran Sanctions Renewal in Lame Duck
2 minutes ago

Republican House leaders are planning on taking up a vote to renew the Iran Sanctions Act as soon as the lame-duck session begins in mid-November. The law, which expires on Dec. 31, permits a host of sanctions against Iran's industries, defense, and government. The renewal will likely pass the House, but its status is unclear once it reaches the Senate, and a spokesman from the White House refused to say whether President Obama would sign it into law.

Trump Stops Holding Fundraisers to Benefit GOP
7 minutes ago

Just two weeks from Nov. 8, Donald Trump's campaign is not scheduling anymore high-dollar fundraisers, the type which usually benefit the Republican Party as a whole. The move comes as a surprise and could be a big blow to the GOP's turnout operations. Many down-ballot candidates are relying on the party apparatus to turn out voters in their districts and/or states, something that could be compromised. The last formal fundraiser occurred on Wednesday, Oct. 19.

Republican Polling Shows Close Race
Roundup: National Polling Remains Inconsistent
16 hours ago

The national polls, once again, tell very different stories: Clinton leads by just one point in the IBD, Rasmussen, and LA Times tracking polls, while she shows a commanding 12 point lead in the ABC news poll and a smaller but sizable five point lead in the CNN poll. The Republican Remington Research Group released a slew of polls showing Trump up in Ohio, Nevada, and North Carolina, a tie in Florida, and Clinton leads in Pennsylvania, Wisconsin, and Virginia. However, an independent Siena poll shows Clinton up 7 in North Carolina, while a Monmouth poll shows Trump up one in Arizona

Colin Powell to Vote for Clinton
18 hours ago
Clinton Reaching Out to GOP Senators
23 hours ago

If you need a marker for how confident Hillary Clinton is at this point of the race, here's one: CNN's Jeff Zeleny reports "she's been talking to Republican senators, old allies and new, saying that she is willing to work with them and govern."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.