Obamacare Premiums Aren’t Living Up to Doomsayers’ Predictions

Early results suggest single-digit increases, not a price apocalypse.

PASADENA, CA - NOVEMBER 19: A healthcare reform specialist helps people select insurance plans at the free Affordable Care Act (ACA) Enrollment Fair at Pasadena City College on November 19, 2013 in Pasadena, California. The event, sponsored by the Chamber of Commerce and the Los Angeles Association of Health Underwriters, offers one-on-one sessions with insurance experts certified by Covered California to help people enroll for healthcare coverage under the ACA. 
National Journal
Sam Baker
Add to Briefcase
Sam Baker
July 21, 2014, 5:46 p.m.

Obama­care’s crit­ics prom­ised the law would send in­sur­ance premi­ums skyrock­et­ing. They were wrong.

Or, if they’re not wrong, they’re at least not right yet.

Nearly 20 states have re­leased pre­lim­in­ary in­form­a­tion about premi­ums for in­sur­ance policies sold on their in­sur­ance ex­changes, and the night­mare scen­ari­os have not come to pass. In most of those states, the av­er­age in­crease across all ex­change plans is in the single di­gits.

Ac­cord­ing to a Price­wa­ter­house­Coopers ana­lys­is of 18 states’ ini­tial fil­ings, 10 states will see av­er­age premi­um in­creases of less than 10 per­cent—nom­in­al hikes in line with the stand­ard in­creases that have happened every year with or without Obama­care.

The out­liers so far are In­di­ana, with an av­er­age in­crease of 15 per­cent, and Rhode Is­land, where the av­er­age premi­um will fall by about 1 per­cent.

Ini­tial rates could still change; sev­er­al states have the power to re­view pro­posed in­creases and bar­gain for a bet­ter deal. But the early look at states’ 2015 rates helps shed some light on wheth­er Obama­care’s second year will bring steep cost hikes.

There are wild vari­ations among dif­fer­ent in­sur­ance plans. In Ore­gon alone, one plan wants to cut its premi­ums by 21 per­cent, while an­oth­er wants to raise its rates by 28 per­cent. The ex­tremes make for easy talk­ing points (“Look how much premi­ums are go­ing up!” “No, they’re go­ing down!”), but they don’t re­flect the ex­per­i­ence most people will have when it’s time to pony up for plans: The av­er­age Ore­gon in­sur­ance premi­um will rise by 2.2 per­cent.

Larry Levitt, vice pres­id­ent for spe­cial ini­ti­at­ives at the Kais­er Fam­ily Found­a­tion, said he’s sur­prised by the vari­ation in pro­posed changes but that on av­er­age, premi­ums are work­ing out to about what he ex­pec­ted: hikes of 7 per­cent to 8 per­cent in most places.

Premi­ums go up every year, and Levitt said in­creases of about 8 per­cent were to be ex­pec­ted based on rising med­ic­al spend­ing and ad­just­ments based on the first year of en­roll­ment.

In­surers had to set their 2014 premi­ums based on their best guesses about who would sign up, and they don’t have much more in­form­a­tion as they head in­to 2015.

“In­surers were fly­ing pretty blind when they put to­geth­er their 2014 premi­ums and, frankly, they’re still fly­ing pretty blind,” Levitt said.

Be­cause so many of Obama­care’s 2014 en­rollees signed up at the very end of the en­roll­ment win­dow, they haven’t filed a ton of med­ic­al claims for in­surers to work from as they try to fig­ure out how much their new cus­tom­ers will cost them.

That helps ex­plain some of the biggest changes in 2015 premi­ums—big cuts are most likely from in­surers that were es­pe­cially cau­tious about 2014 and ended up do­ing bet­ter than they ex­pec­ted, while big in­creases are most likely from plans that thought they’d end up with health­i­er cus­tom­ers than they did.

An in­flux of new in­surers is also help­ing to keep premi­um in­creases in check, ac­cord­ing to health care ana­lysts. Ma­jor in­surers, in­clud­ing United­Health­care, are en­ter­ing more states’ ex­changes next year after sit­ting on the side­lines for 2014.

What We're Following See More »
PAC WILL TARGET INCUMBENTS
Sanders Acolytes Taking the Movement Local
28 minutes ago
WHY WE CARE

"While Democrats nationwide have put the focus on President Trump, the Sanders wing of the party has engaged in an intramural fight to remake the party in a more populist, liberal mold." From Washington state to California to Florida, Sanders loyalists are making good on their promise to remake the party from the ground up. And just last week, a "group of former Sanders campaign aides launched a super PAC with the explicit goal of mounting primary challenges to Democratic incumbents."

Source:
THANKS TO MILITARY ROLE
McMaster Requires Congressional Approval
41 minutes ago
THE DETAILS

Congress will need to vote on Donald Trump's pick of Lt. General H.R. McMaster to be his next national security adviser, but not for the reason you think. The position of NSA doesn't require Senate approval, but since McMaster currently holds a three-star military position, Congress will need to vote to allow him to keep his position instead of forcing him to drop one star and become a Major General, which could potentially affect his pension.

Source:
THE QUESTION
How Many Signatures Has the Petition for Trump’s Tax Returns Received?
4 hours ago
THE ANSWER

More than 1 million, setting a record. More than 100,000 signatures triggers an official White House response.

Source:
SENT LETTERS TO A DOZEN ORGANIZATIONS
Senate Intel Looks to Preserve Records of Russian Interference
4 hours ago
THE LATEST

"The Senate Intelligence Committee is seeking to ensure that records related to Russia’s alleged intervention in the 2016 U.S. elections are preserved as it begins investigating that country’s ties to the Trump team. The panel sent more than a dozen letters to 'organizations, agencies and officials' on Friday, asking them to preserve materials related to the congressional investigation, according to a Senate aide, who was not authorized to comment publicly. The Senate Intelligence Committee is spearheading the most comprehensive probe on Capitol Hill of Russia’s alleged activities in the elections."

Source:
MORE COOPERATION WITH LOCAL AUTHORITIES
Deportation, Detention Rules Released
4 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Memos issued by the Department of Homeland Security on Tuesday night "implemented sweeping changes to the way immigration policy is enforced, making clear that millions of people living illegally in the U.S. are now subject to deportation and pushing authorities to fast-track the removal of many of them. ... The policy calls for enlisting local authorities to enforce immigration law, jailing more people while they wait for their hearings and trying to send border crossers back to Mexico to await proceedings, even if they aren’t Mexican."

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login