How Hillary Clinton Once Disappointed Elizabeth Warren on Wall Street Reform

As a senator, Clinton doubled back on the advice Warren once gave her.

National Journal
Emma Roller
Add to Briefcase
Emma Roller
Sept. 5, 2014, 9:48 a.m.

On Fri­day, the Bill Moy­ers show re­leased a vin­tage clip of Sen. Eliza­beth War­ren ap­pear­ing on the show in 2004. In the video, War­ren talks about a pres­ci­ent meet­ing with then-first lady Hil­lary Clin­ton.

War­ren tells the story like this: In the late 1990s, Con­gress was set to pass a bill that would make it harder for cus­tom­ers to al­le­vi­ate their debt by claim­ing bank­ruptcy. Banks and cred­it card com­pan­ies were push­ing the bill hard.

War­ren wrote an op-ed op­pos­ing the le­gis­la­tion, ar­guing the bill would dis­pro­por­tion­ately hurt single moth­ers. The first lady ap­par­ently read the piece, be­cause War­ren got a call from the White House ask­ing if she’d meet with Clin­ton to dis­cuss bank­ruptcy.

After Clin­ton gave a speech in Bo­ston, War­ren met with her. Over ham­burgers and french fries, Clin­ton said to War­ren, “Tell me about bank­ruptcy.”

{{third­PartyEmbed type:vimeo id:105062617}}

“I gotta tell you, I nev­er had a smarter stu­dent,” War­ren told Moy­ers, say­ing Clin­ton un­der­stood the prin­ciples of bank­ruptcy “quick right to the heart of it.”

After their con­ver­sa­tion, Clin­ton got up and said, “Pro­fess­or War­ren, we’ve got to stop that aw­ful bill.” And stop the bill they did. The bank­ruptcy bill was the last one to cross Pres­id­ent Bill Clin­ton’s desk, and he ve­toed it. On the cam­paign trail in 2007, Hil­lary Clin­ton used the bill as evid­ence that she “fought the banks.”

But when Clin­ton joined the Sen­ate in 2001 and the bank­ruptcy bill came up again, Clin­ton the sen­at­or did what Clin­ton the first lady op­posed — she voted for it.

“As Sen­at­or Clin­ton, the pres­sures are very dif­fer­ent,” War­ren told Moy­ers. “She has taken money from the groups, and more to the point, she wor­ries about them as a con­stitu­ency.”

As War­ren sees it, the “stu­dent” she saw in that meet­ing over bur­gers and fries ul­ti­mately fell vic­tim to a cor­rupt sys­tem. In Clin­ton-as-ideo­logue, War­ren saw an abil­ity to res­ist the lure of Wall Street. But Clin­ton the law­maker could not res­ist its in­flu­ence. “This is the scary part about demo­cracy today,” War­ren said.

War­ren’s com­ments from 10 years ago align with her po­s­i­tion on Wall Street today. In an in­ter­view with Katie Cour­ic on Wed­nes­day, War­ren took former House Ma­jor­ity Lead­er Eric Can­tor to task for tak­ing a well-pay­ing gig at an in­vest­ment bank. When Cour­ic asked War­ren what she thought about Clin­ton’s “cozy” re­la­tion­ship with Wall Street, War­ren de­murred — but did not go so far as to de­fend Clin­ton’s track re­cord.

While some pun­dits may prof­fer a su­per­fi­cial “cat­fight” nar­rat­ive between War­ren and Clin­ton, there is a more sub­stant­ive ideo­lo­gic­al gulf between them. And even though Clin­ton’s re­versal came all those years ago, it’s a linger­ing con­trast neither of them can avoid.

What We're Following See More »
VOTE TO GO FORWARD
Collins, Cruz Appear to Oppose Health Bill
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

Republican opposition to the GOP health care bill swelled to near-fatal numbers Sunday as Sen. Susan Collins all but closed the door on supporting the last-ditch effort to scrap the Obama health care law and Sen. Ted Cruz said that "right now" he doesn't back it. White House legislative liaison Marc Short and Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., one of the measure's sponsors, said Republicans would press ahead with a vote this week." Collins said she doesn't support the bill's cuts to Medicaid, while Cruz said it wouldn't do enough to lower premiums.

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login