What’s the Value of a $10,000 Degree?

The Florida College System’s low-cost, workforce-oriented degrees could serve graduates just as well as a liberal-arts diploma from a public university.

National Journal
Sophie Quinton
See more stories about...
Sophie Quinton
Feb. 2, 2014, 12:05 a.m.

Tu­ition in­creases at in­de­pend­ent col­leges have been sus­tained, in part, by a be­lief among af­flu­ent fam­il­ies that high­er prices sig­nal bet­ter qual­ity. If that were true, Al­berto Partida, 43, would be in big trouble. His four-year de­gree from Broward Col­lege, a former com­munity col­lege in South Flor­ida, will cost him less than $10,000. The Amer­ic­an As­so­ci­ation of State Col­leges and Uni­versit­ies has ques­tioned the mar­ket­place cred­ib­il­ity of de­grees offered for $10,000, which have been in­tro­duced by Texas and Flor­ida.

Al­berto Partida is a stu­dent at Broward Col­lege. (Cour­tesy photo)Luck­ily for Partida, em­ploy­ers don’t meas­ure the value of edu­ca­tion that way. Gradu­ates from the Flor­ida Col­lege Sys­tem’s work­force-ori­ented bach­el­or’s de­gree pro­grams earn about $8,000 more the year after gradu­ation than uni­versity gradu­ates, ac­cord­ing to re­search man­dated by the state le­gis­lature. Tu­ition for four-year de­grees from FCS in­sti­tu­tions typ­ic­ally cost $13,000 — less than half the cost of four years at a state uni­versity.

As jobs have be­come more soph­ist­ic­ated, there’s a great­er need for bac­ca­laur­eate de­grees that dir­ectly re­late to the work­force, says Linda Howdy­shell, prov­ost and seni­or vice pres­id­ent for aca­dem­ics and stu­dent suc­cess of Broward Col­lege. At the same time, uni­versity tu­ition has be­come un­af­ford­able for many fam­il­ies. Flor­ida’s ex­per­i­ence sug­gests that lower-cost, less-se­lect­ive path­ways to a bach­el­or’s de­gree can serve stu­dents just as well as four years at a uni­versity — at least when it comes to get­ting a job.

The FCS (formerly the Flor­ida Com­munity Col­lege Sys­tem) has offered a small num­ber of four-year de­grees in fields such as nurs­ing and com­puter en­gin­eer­ing tech­no­logy for about a dec­ade. In Flor­ida, as­so­ci­ate’s de­gree gradu­ates are guar­an­teed ad­mis­sion to a state uni­versity, and FCS bac­ca­laur­eate pro­grams hon­or this struc­ture by re­quir­ing stu­dents to com­plete an as­so­ci­ate’s de­gree be­fore ap­ply­ing.

So far, un­like uni­versity stu­dents, FCS bach­el­or’s de­gree seekers have skewed to­ward work­ing adults seek­ing a cre­den­tial that will lead to a pro­mo­tion or a new ca­reer. About 42 per­cent of stu­dents have been non­white. FCS in­sti­tu­tions don’t of­fer lib­er­al arts de­grees, and can’t of­fer pro­grams that dir­ectly com­pete with those at nearby uni­versit­ies.

But in pro­grams roughly equi­val­ent to uni­versity ma­jors, FCS gradu­ates do just fine. Busi­ness ad­min­is­tra­tion and ele­ment­ary edu­ca­tion ma­jors at state uni­versit­ies earn about the same their first year out of school as FCS gradu­ates, the re­port found. Re­gistered nurses who gradu­ate from FCS in­sti­tu­tions ac­tu­ally earn about $10,000 more their first year out than their uni­versity-edu­cated peers.

Even gradu­ates of the state flag­ships, Uni­versity of Flor­ida and Flor­ida State Uni­versity, don’t seem to ex­per­i­ence an im­me­di­ate earn­ings boost. The av­er­age gradu­ate who finds work in Flor­ida after gradu­ation ac­tu­ally earns less than the statewide av­er­age, while ow­ing more in stu­dent debt. UF and FSU gradu­ates are more likely, however, to pur­sue gradu­ate school im­me­di­ately or to leave the state.

De­grees from truly brand-name in­sti­tu­tions, like those in the Ivy League, do pay off, says Mark Schneider of the Amer­ic­an In­sti­tutes for Re­search, the au­thor of the Flor­ida re­port and an ex­pert on col­lege-de­gree out­comes. It’s not clear wheth­er that’s due to the qual­ity of an elite edu­ca­tion or be­cause of the tal­ent of stu­dents ac­cep­ted to elite schools.

(Col­lege­Meas­ures.org)But the ma­jor­ity of Amer­ic­an col­lege stu­dents don’t go to Prin­ceton. They earn their de­grees from the cam­puses of a state uni­versity sys­tem, which may not be par­tic­u­larly dif­fer­en­ti­ated by se­lectiv­ity and price with­in the state. In that con­text, what stu­dents study is more im­port­ant than the in­sti­tu­tion they choose. “With very few ex­cep­tions, if you start out with a low-pay­ing job be­cause you’ve got­ten a philo­sophy ma­jor, 10 years later you’re still be­low every­body else,” Schneider says.

“We need to do a bet­ter job of in­form­ing the pub­lic that this isn’t a less­er de­gree,” Howdy­shell says. Broward may not have res­id­ence halls, well­ness cen­ters, or Greek life, but that doesn’t mean classroom in­struc­tion is in­feri­or. The col­lege is known loc­ally for its caring fac­ulty, and many courses al­most ex­actly mir­ror uni­versity course­work.

Partida hopes that, by get­ting a de­gree aligned with work­force needs, he’ll have an easi­er time find­ing work than he did with just a high school dip­loma. The former res­taur­ant own­er and fath­er of two will soon gradu­ate with a bach­el­or of ap­plied sci­ence in sup­ply chain man­age­ment. Ac­cord­ing to Broward’s ana­lys­is of state data, by 2019 there’ll be 3,555 new jobs in the county for people with sup­ply chain man­age­ment ex­pert­ise. The ex­pan­sion of two area ports will drive that in­crease.

Partida likely will pay a whole lot less for his de­gree than $10,000, be­cause he qual­i­fies for sub­stan­tial fin­an­cial aid. At Broward, the guar­an­tee that a de­gree costs no more than $10,000 is struc­tured like a mer­it schol­ar­ship, offered to stu­dents who have good grades and can com­mit to en­rolling full-time. How much Partida pays out of pock­et isn’t go­ing to show up on his tran­script, or his dip­loma.

For par­ents think­ing about their child’s edu­ca­tion, a four-year de­gree from a Flor­ida col­lege is be­com­ing an in­creas­ingly at­tract­ive op­tion. Just look at re­cent sales data from Flor­ida Pre­paid, a state pro­gram fam­il­ies can use to pay for col­lege in ad­vance. For new­born ba­bies, a four-year uni­versity plan cur­rently costs $53,729, al­most three times as much as a four-year FCS de­gree plan.

“It’s gradu­al, but we are see­ing a little bit of an up­tick. Each year that goes by we’re start­ing to see more fam­il­ies pur­chas­ing the four-year Flor­ida Col­lege plan and the 2+2 plan,” says Kev­in Thompson, ex­ec­ut­ive dir­ect­or of Flor­ida Pre­paid. The 2+2 plan com­bines an as­so­ci­ate’s de­gree with two years at a state uni­versity.

Last year, 35 per­cent of fam­il­ies chose the uni­versity plan, 25 per­cent chose the FCS plan, and 16 per­cent chose the 2+2 plan. “All three of those plans can get you a four-year de­gree, just dif­fer­ent paths of get­ting there,” Thompson says.

What We're Following See More »
In Dropout Speech, Santorum Endorses Rubio
2 days ago

As expected after earlier reports on Wednesday, Rick Santorum ended his presidential bid. But less expected: he threw his support to Marco Rubio. After noting he spoke with Rubio the day before for an hour, he said, “Someone who has a real understanding of the threat of ISIS, real understanding of the threat of fundamentalist Islam, and has experience, one of the things I wanted was someone who has experience in this area, and that’s why we decided to support Marco Rubio.” It doesn’t figure to help Rubio much in New Hampshire, but the Santorum nod could pay dividends down the road in southern states.

Rubio, Trump Question Obama’s Mosque Visit
2 days ago

President Obama’s decision to visit a mosque in Baltimore today was never going to be completely uncontroversial. And Donald Trump and Marco Rubio proved it. “Maybe he feels comfortable there,” Trump told interviewer Greta van Susteren on Fox News. “There are a lot of places he can go, and he chose a mosque.” And in New Hampshire, Rubio said of Obama, “Always pitting people against each other. Always. Look at today – he gave a speech at a mosque. Oh, you know, basically implying that America is discriminating against Muslims.”

Cruz Must Max Out on Evangelical Support through Early March
2 days ago

For Ted Cruz, a strong showing in New Hampshire would be nice, but not necessary. That’s because evangelical voters only make up 21% of the Granite State’s population. “But from the February 20 South Carolina primary through March 15, there are nine states (South Carolina, Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Oklahoma, Tennessee, Kentucky, Mississippi, and North Carolina) with an estimated white-Evangelical percentage of the GOP electorate over 60 percent, and another four (Texas, Kansas, Louisiana, and Missouri) that come in over 50 percent.” But after that, he better be in the catbird’s seat, because only four smaller states remain with evangelical voter majorities.

Rubio Now Winning the ‘Endorsement Primary’
2 days ago

Since his strong third-place finish in Iowa, Marco Rubio has won endorsement by two sitting senators and two congressmen, putting him in the lead for the first time of FiveThirtyEight‘s Endorsement Tracker. “Some politicians had put early support behind Jeb Bush — he had led [their] list since August — but since January the only new endorsement he has received was from former presidential candidate Sen. Lindsey Graham.” Meanwhile, the New York Times reports that fueled by resentment, “members of the Bush and Christie campaigns have communicated about their mutual desire to halt … Rubio’s rise in the polls.”

Sanders: Obama Is a Progressive
1 days ago

“Do I think President Obama is a progressive? Yeah, I do,” said Bernie Sanders, in response to a direct question in tonight’s debate. “I think they’ve done a great job.” But Hillary Clinton wasn’t content to sit out the latest chapter in the great debate over the definition of progressivism. “In your definition, with you being the gatekeeper of progressivism, I don’t think anyone else fits that definition,” she told Sanders.