PayPal Billionaire, Boeing Battle Over Who Can Build a Better Space Taxi

Elon Musk thinks his company can do a better job of sending military satellites into space, and he wants Congress’s help to break into the game.

A SpaceX rocket takes off on a 2012 mission for NASA.
National Journal
Alex Brown
March 5, 2014, 10:38 a.m.

Bil­lion­aire en­tre­pren­eur Elon Musk has a plan to launch mil­it­ary satel­lites that he claims could save the gov­ern­ment hun­dreds of mil­lions, but to make it work, he says he needs Con­gress’s help to break up a mil­it­ary-in­dus­tri­al mono­poly.

“Com­pet­i­tion and the free mar­ket is a good thing,” Musk told Con­gress on Wed­nes­day, es­tim­at­ing that his SpaceX rock­ets would cost nearly $300 mil­lion less per launch if giv­en the op­por­tun­ity to com­pete with United Launch Al­li­ance — a part­ner­ship of Boe­ing and Lock­heed Mar­tin that the mil­it­ary cur­rently re­lies on to ferry its satel­lites.

SpaceX ships have already con­duc­ted re­sup­ply mis­sions for NASA to the In­ter­na­tion­al Space Sta­tion, but have found it more dif­fi­cult to break in­to the De­fense De­part­ment’s launch pro­gram.

At present, the Air Force is slated to buy up to 36 rock­ets from ULA, while an­oth­er 14 will be made open to com­pet­i­tion for SpaceX and oth­er com­pan­ies. ULA CEO Mi­chael Gass said his com­pany’s ex­clus­ive role in mil­it­ary launches is a good thing, of­fer­ing re­li­ab­il­ity (the com­pany boasts 68 straight suc­cess­ful launches; Musk and Gass had a back-and-forth over each com­pany’s mis­haps and what con­sti­tutes a “suc­cess­ful” launch) and pre­vent­ing spend­ing on re­dund­ant tech­no­logy.

But Musk took is­sue with the re­li­ab­il­ity ar­gu­ment, us­ing events in Ukraine to un­der­cut ULA’s stand­ing. “It makes no sense to claim that ULA’s At­las V [rock­et] provides as­sured ac­cess to space when it de­pends on a Rus­si­an en­gine,” he told re­port­ers after the hear­ing. “In light of Rus­sia’s re­cent ac­tions, with the de facto an­nex­a­tion of Ukraine’s Crimea re­gion and the fact that we’ve severed mil­it­ary ties with Rus­sia — we’re con­tem­plat­ing sanc­tions — it does not make sense to award Rus­sia right now with a huge multi-hun­dred-mil­lion dol­lar con­tract for rock­et en­gines.”

He pro­posed that SpaceX’s Fal­con rock­ets could re­place the At­las V, with ULA still provid­ing its Delta rock­ets to the mil­it­ary.

Gass countered that his com­pany has a two-year sup­ply of At­las V en­gines already stock­piled, mean­ing near-term ten­sions between the two coun­tries are un­likely to keep the U.S. out of or­bit. “We are not at any risk,” he said.

Sen. Di­anne Fein­stein — a Cali­for­nia Demo­crat whose state hosts both SpaceX and some ULA launches — came to Musk’s aid, pro­du­cing a chart from the Gov­ern­ment Ac­count­ab­il­ity Of­fice that showed spend­ing in­creas­ing rap­idly after Boe­ing and Lock­heed merged their launch pro­grams. “The costs to the gov­ern­ment, to the tax­pay­er, have skyrock­eted,” she said. “Com­pet­i­tion is the Amer­ic­an ba­sic de­mand for the ac­cord­ance of a con­tract. So what keeps us from do­ing this?”

Ad­ded Musk: “When Boe­ing and Lock­heed merged, the point at which they stopped be­ing com­pet­it­ors, the costs doubled,” The gov­ern­ment, he said, fur­ther di­min­ishes com­pet­i­tion with a bil­lion-dol­lar an­nu­al pay­ment — which he re­ferred as a sub­sidy — to ULA. He ar­gued that fund­ing “ex­clus­ively in sup­port of the in­cum­bent pro­vider” should be elim­in­ated, or at least factored in­to cost ana­lyses when ULA com­petes for con­tracts.

That pay­ment, known as the ELC, is cru­cial for en­sur­ing ULA’s read­i­ness to meet Amer­ica’s space needs, even when de­mand ebbs, Gass replied. “The na­tion needs a launch vehicle com­pany to stand ready,” he said.

Sen. Richard Shelby — whose home state of Alabama hosts ULA’s pro­duc­tion plant — praised the com­pany’s track re­cord. The Re­pub­lic­an ar­gued that com­pet­i­tion, while gen­er­ally a driver of pro­gress, could lead to “du­plic­a­tion of ex­ist­ing in­fra­struc­ture” and ex­pressed skep­ti­cism at “re-cre­at­ing the wheel.” He also pressed Musk on a SpaceX en­gine fail­ure that sent a cargo ship in­to the wrong or­bit.

Mean­while, Gass used an ar­gu­ment Musk couldn’t — his know­ledge of clas­si­fied tech­no­logy — to in­sist that get­ting mul­tiple com­pan­ies the cap­ab­il­ity to handle such pay­loads isn’t feas­ible. “Those mis­sions can’t work in a com­pet­it­ive com­mer­cial en­vir­on­ment,” he said. “If you don’t have a win­ner-take-all, sur­viv­al of the fit­test com­pet­i­tion “¦ it doesn’t work.”

Musk replied that his com­pany is pre­pared to meet the needs of any mil­it­ary launch, adding that ex­pan­ded cap­ab­il­it­ies are built in­to its cost es­tim­ates. He dis­missed the no­tion that ULA’s longer track re­cord should give it the edge in launch­ing mil­it­ary satel­lites. “Re­li­ab­il­ity is a key factor in com­pet­i­tion. It doesn’t be­come less im­port­ant; it be­comes more im­port­ant,” he said. “If our rock­ets are good enough for NASA, why are they not good enough for the Air Force?”

What We're Following See More »
BAD NEWS FOR CLINTON
Trump and Clinton Equally Disliked
4 hours ago
THE DETAILS

According to the most recent Gallup poll, Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump are equally disliked. The poll, conducted between July 18 and July 25, shows both major party candidates for president are viewed favorably by 37 percent of respondents and unfavorably by 58 percent of respondents. This poll is bad news for Clinton, who has received better favorable and unfavorable ratings in nearly every poll over the last year.

Source:
VP PICK TAKES DIFFERENT TONE THAN TRUMP
Pence: “Serious Consequences” if Russia Hacked DNC
4 hours ago
THE DETAILS

The same day that Donald Trump encouraged Russia to hack the State Department and "find the 30,000 emails that are missing," the GOP nominee for vice president took a more serious approach. "If it is Russia and they are interfering in our elections, I can assure you both parties and the United States government will ensure there are serious consequences," Pence said in a statement. Trump's comments at a press conference this morning were rebuked by individuals across the political spectrum, while some on Trump's team, including prominent surrogate Newt Gingrich, have called his comments a "joke."

Source:
ECONOMY STABILIZING
Fed Leaves Rates Alone, but Signals Hikes to Come
6 hours ago
THE DETAILS

The Federal Open Market Committee today voted to leave interest rates alone, but "upgraded its assessment of the economy’s recent performance and said near-term risks to the outlook have diminished, effectively leaving the door open to raise rates later this year, possibly as early as September."

Source:
CHARM OFFENSIVE
Pence Is Trump’s Man on Capitol Hill
8 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Spurred by VP pick Mike Pence, a former congressman with close ties to many lawmakers, the Trump campaign in recent weeks has stepped up its courtship of wary Capitol Hill Republicans. And the efforts appear to be bearing fruit." Central to the charm offensive: invitations to more than a dozen "Senate and House members into his family’s private box for some power-schmoozing with him and his kids" during the Republican National Convention.

Source:
PAUL RYAN: STOP IT
Trump Encourages More Spying by Russia
8 hours ago
THE LATEST

Donald Trump essentially encouraged more Russian espionage against Democrats in a press conference this morning. "Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing,” he said. “I think you will probably be rewarded mightily by our press.” That prompted Brendan Buck, spokesman for House Speaker Paul Ryan to say: “Russia is a global menace led by a devious thug. Putin should stay out of this election.”

Source:
×