Republican Senator on GOP Shutdown Strategy: ‘Wow. Is That the Best You Can Do?’

Sen. Mike Johanns waits for the beginning of a news conference November 30, 2011 on Capitol Hill.
National Journal
Michael Catalin
Add to Briefcase
Michael Catalin
Oct. 7, 2013, 1:51 p.m.

Sen. Mike Jo­hanns, the soft-spoken Neb­raskan, walks from the Rus­sell Build­ing along the con­crete un­der­ground path to the Cap­it­ol when he’s needed on the floor for a vote. He’s not one to get taken for a ride — not on the Sen­ate sub­way or by con­ser­vat­ive col­leagues whose strategy he views with skep­ti­cism. Jo­hanns, the former Neb­raska gov­ernor and Ag­ri­cul­ture sec­ret­ary un­der George W. Bush, has held back snip­ing at his Re­pub­lic­an col­leagues in the in­tern­al GOP de­bate over wheth­er to press Demo­crats for con­ces­sions on Obama­care in re­turn for fund­ing the gov­ern­ment.

But his po­lite man­ner has not stopped him from cri­tiquing the mer­its of the plan.

Jo­hanns de­cided earli­er this year he wouldn’t seek reelec­tion in 2014, a de­cision that means he is not glan­cing over his shoulder at at­tacks from the right or the left. That also means there’s little down­side to speak­ing his mind about what’s hap­pen­ing in Con­gress.

When the ar­chi­tects of the GOP strategy, in­clud­ing Sens. Ted Cruz of Texas and Mike Lee of Utah, ex­plained the path to vic­tory, Jo­hanns quickly real­ized what the rest of Wash­ing­ton soon would as well: The plan re­quires the pres­id­ent and Demo­crats to back off their sig­na­ture le­gis­la­tion. It was a non­starter.

“If that’s your strategy? Wow,” he said. “Is that the best you can do? Like I said, I didn’t get it.”

A cer­tain level of polit­ic­al prag­mat­ism could have gone a long way in this case, the think­ing goes, and Re­pub­lic­ans could have se­cured more fisc­al con­ces­sions had they steered clear of try­ing to short-cir­cuit the Af­ford­able Care Act.

“My ad­vice, when I do speak up, is think about what you’re fight­ing for and make sure the strategy you’ve chosen ac­tu­ally gets you to a res­ult. I didn’t see how this got to a res­ult. I could nev­er un­der­stand de­fund­ing Obama­care as the strategy for the con­tinu­ing res­ol­u­tion,” Jo­hanns said.

Part of the prob­lem with the strategy is that Sen­ate Ma­jor­ity Lead­er Harry Re­id, D-Nev., whose Sen­ate Demo­crats have held firm, in­sists that the House vote on the up­per cham­ber’s so-called “clean” con­tinu­ing res­ol­u­tion.

Now, Re­pub­lic­ans in the House and Sen­ate aim to dis­cred­it Re­id by ty­ing him to the gov­ern­ment shut­down in the same way he has tried to taint the GOP. The prob­lem with that is the dif­fi­culty in pier­cing Re­id’s ar­mor. He doesn’t care about the in­sults, in oth­er words.

“I don’t think he’s es­pe­cially bothered by some­body say­ing this, that, or the oth­er thing,” Jo­hanns said. “He’s been around a lot of years and fought a lot of fights.”

The big­ger is­sue is that fo­cus­ing on Obama­care takes away from a dis­cip­lined and uni­fied fo­cus on fisc­al is­sues, such as en­for­cing the Budget Con­trol Act caps, which Demo­crats op­pose.

“We some­how got off on a cul-de-sac,” Jo­hanns said.

Jo­hanns lends his cri­ti­cism to a chor­us of oth­er Sen­ate Re­pub­lic­ans, in­clud­ing Sens. Bob Cork­er of Ten­ness­ee, who char­ac­ter­ized the Cruz ap­proach as the “box-canyon” strategy, and Tom Coburn of Ok­lahoma, who said he thinks the GOP will fold over the shut­down.

The path out of that canyon, to use Cork­er’s meta­phor, is easy, ac­cord­ing to the Re­pub­lic­an skep­tics in the Sen­ate. But it’s also easi­er said than done, with both the White House and Re­id’s Demo­crat­ic Caucus un­will­ing to move off their po­s­i­tions.

“I think there’s just a point where both sides have to agree that con­tinu­ing to fight has no re­deem­ing fea­tures to it, that the down­side of set­tling beats the beat­ing that you’re tak­ing,” Jo­hanns said. “I think when both sides reach that con­clu­sion, then it will be re­solved.”

What We're Following See More »
SAUDI ARABIA BILL
Veto Override Scheduled for Wednesday in Senate
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said this afternoon that the Senate on Wednesday will take up an override of President Obama's veto of legislation that would allow the families of 9/11 victims to sue the government of Saudi Arabia. "The vote is expected garner the two-thirds majority necessary to override the veto."

Source:
MEDIA SHOULD HOLD TRUMP RESPONSIBLE
Reid Devotes Senate Floor Speech to Trump’s ‘Racism’
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Donald Trump is a racist," announced Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid from the Senate floor this afternoon. Reid said all of us are occasionally politically incorrect, but "I don't know of anyone that when that happens doesn't acknowledge it and, if necessary, apologize quickly." But Trump, he added, says things with "full intent to demean and to denigrate." Reid argued that the media isn't holding Trump to account, and should explicitly call him a racist.

ABSENT FROM LIST: GENNIFER FLOWERS
Most Trump Guests Have Military Ties
5 hours ago
THE LATEST
TOP OF MIND
Trending on Google: ‘Why Should Trump Not Be President’
6 hours ago
THE DETAILS
WHO PLAYED THE DONALD?
Longtime Clinton Aide Played Trump in Mock Debates
8 hours ago
THE DETAILS

After keeping the information private for most of the lead-up to the debate on Monday, it has been revealed that longtime Clinton aide Philippe Reines has been playing the role of Donald Trump in her debate prep. Reines knows Clinton better than most, able to identify both her strengths and weaknesses, and his selection for a sparring partner shows that Clinton is preparing for the brash and confrontational Donald Trump many have come to expect.

Source:
×