The Debt Ceiling Is Breaking Ben Bernanke’s Heart

The cardiac Congress is undermining the Fed chairman’s economic crusade.

WASHINGTON, DC - SEPTEMBER 18: Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke pauses as he speaks during a news conference at the Federal Reserve, September 18, 2013 in Washington, DC. Chairman Bernanke spoke after a closed door meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee. The Federal Reserve announced today that it will not scale back the bond-buying program and continue buying bonds at $85 billion a month. 
National Journal
Catherine Hollander and Patrick Reis
Add to Briefcase
See more stories about...
Catherine Hollander Patrick Reis
Oct. 9, 2013, 2 a.m.

Ben Bernanke has spent half of a dec­ade try­ing to coax in­vestors out of their postre­ces­sion bunkers. Now, Con­gress is set to send them run­ning for cov­er again.

The gov­ern­ment may not de­fault on its loans in the com­ing weeks, but just by com­ing close to the edge, law­makers will pull mar­kets in the ex­act op­pos­ite dir­ec­tion from where the Fed­er­al Re­serve has been try­ing to push them.

Bernanke’s bid to re­sus­cit­ate the eco­nomy de­pends on per­suad­ing people to make two leaps of faith. First, busi­nesses re­quire enough con­fid­ence in the fu­ture to ask for the big loans they need to ex­pand their op­er­a­tions, in part by hir­ing some of the coun­try’s 11.3 mil­lion un­em­ployed work­ers. Second, lenders need to be­lieve that mak­ing those loans is the best use of their money.

The Fed’s quest to drive down in­terest rates tar­gets both goals. By keep­ing rates low, Bernanke makes it cheap­er for bor­row­ers to take out loans. And to per­suade lenders to take a risk on those loans, the Fed has bought up massive quant­it­ies of Treas­ury bonds — con­sidered the ul­ti­mate safe in­vest­ment — in an ef­fort to drive down the rate at which those bonds pay off to private in­vestors. The hope is that in­vestors, dis­sat­is­fied with the low rate of re­turn they get from the fed­er­al gov­ern­ment, will in­stead put their money in­to the private sec­tor.

That’s where Con­gress’s be­ha­vi­or is so dam­aging. By pre­cip­it­at­ing one crisis after an­oth­er, law­makers are send­ing in­vestors run­ning back to in­vest­ments like Treas­ury bonds — which keep their money safe but do pre­cious little in the way of stim­u­lus. If Con­gress wanted to spook lenders, it could hardly pick a bet­ter meth­od than flirt­ing with de­fault. “It would be the op­pos­ite of what the Fed’s wanted to do,” says Stu­art Hoff­man, chief eco­nom­ist at PNC Fin­an­cial Ser­vices. “It ba­sic­ally says something has happened out­side the Fed’s con­trol that could shock the eco­nomy in­to re­ces­sion.”

For Bernanke, the cur­rent debt-ceil­ing stan­doff may be all the more in­furi­at­ing be­cause he’s seen it, and its de­struct­ive ef­fects, play out be­fore. When the coun­try last brushed up against the debt ceil­ing in the sum­mer of 2011, in­vestors flocked to Treas­ury bonds, look­ing for a safe place to park their as­sets while they waited to see wheth­er Con­gress was go­ing to un­leash eco­nom­ic chaos.

As in­vestors sought refuge in bonds, they fled from stocks. The stock mar­ket — fa­cing a de­fault threat in the U.S. and a sov­er­eign-debt crisis in Europe — plunged as the Aug. 2 debt-ceil­ing dead­line ap­proached and con­gres­sion­al Re­pub­lic­ans, Demo­crats, and Pres­id­ent Obama re­mained dead­locked. The Dow Jones in­dus­tri­al av­er­age began slid­ing on Ju­ly 22, and the losses wer­en’t erased un­til Janu­ary of this year. A gov­ern­ment de­fault was aver­ted in the nick of time, but Stand­ard & Poor’s cut the coun­try’s AAA cred­it rat­ing.

His­tory ap­pears poised to re­peat it­self as bond in­terest rates are fall­ing sharply in the run-up to the new dead­line, Oct. 17. The yield on the 10-year Treas­ury bond, the mar­ket’s bench­mark, hit a two-month low on Oct. 3, sig­nal­ing that in­vestors are will­ing to swal­low lower pay­outs on their in­vest­ment in ex­change for safe har­bor. Yields on the one-month T-bill soared Tues­day; the high­er short-term fed­er­al bor­row­ing costs re­flec­ted in­vestors’ con­cerns about a de­fault in the com­ing weeks. Stocks have slipped in re­cent weeks, too, as a gov­ern­ment shut­down stretches on and the bor­row­ing-lim­it dead­line nears.

On the face of it, it’s con­fus­ing that in­vestors would seek refuge with the U.S. gov­ern­ment at the same time the gov­ern­ment is in danger of de­fault­ing on its debts. But in­vestors fig­ure Wash­ing­ton will even­tu­ally meet those ob­lig­a­tions, and that in the tur­moil ac­com­pa­ny­ing a brush with de­fault — or if the coun­try’s cred­it rat­ing is lowered — oth­er in­vest­ments would fare worse.

“Treas­ur­ies are worth a little less [after a down­grade],” Hoff­man says. “And guess what? Every­body else is also worth a little less.”

The Fed may already be re­spond­ing to the un­cer­tainty of today’s gov­ern­ment shut­down and po­ten­tial de­fault. Bernanke was ex­pec­ted to an­nounce the be­gin­ning of a di­al­ing-back in Fed stim­u­lus in Septem­ber, but his policy-mak­ing com­mit­tee shocked in­vestors by an­noun­cing the Fed would keep go­ing full speed ahead and ob­liquely ref­er­en­cing Wash­ing­ton’s fisc­al tur­moil as one of the causes for the de­cision.

It’s un­clear how much lever­age they have left. The Fed has already bought more than a tril­lion dol­lars worth of bonds and has kept the fed­er­al funds rate, the cent­ral bank’s bench­mark in­terest rate, close to zero for more than four years — and none of that has man­aged to move the un­em­ploy­ment rate down to 6.5 per­cent, the point at which the Fed said it would be­gin to slow down its stim­u­lus ef­forts. Bernanke has said the stim­u­lus pro­grams could of­fer “di­min­ish­ing re­turns” over time.

There are also risks in the Fed’s re­spond­ing to fisc­al chaos by buy­ing more bonds and keep­ing in­terest rates low. Fed­er­al Re­serve Board Gov­ernor Gov­ernor Jeremy Stein has warned that a pro­longed low-rate en­vir­on­ment could cause in­vestors to “reach for yield,” Fed­speak for in­vestors who seek profit so des­per­ately that they pile in­to the ris­ki­est in­vest­ments and im­per­il the en­tire fin­an­cial sys­tem. And Kan­sas City Fed Pres­id­ent Es­th­er George has voted against the Fed’s stim­u­lus ef­forts this year, cit­ing con­cerns about cre­at­ing “fin­an­cial im­bal­ances.”

But for now, with un­em­ploy­ment still high, and with a gen­er­a­tion of work­ers watch­ing as the pro­longed eco­nom­ic slump dam­ages their long-term eco­nom­ic pro­spects, Bernanke’s big­ger worry is that all his ef­forts have failed to pro­duce the good-times-are-here-again growth that Amer­ic­ans are wait­ing for.

Throughout his ten­ure, Bernanke has spoken op­tim­ist­ic­ally about the Fed’s power to heal a dam­aged eco­nomy, but bar­ring a dra­mat­ic course cor­rec­tion, the chair­man will spend his fi­nal few months watch­ing Con­gress break it all over again. Maybe Janet Yel­len, whom the White House nom­in­ated Wed­nes­day to suc­ceed him, will have bet­ter luck with Cap­it­ol Hill.

What We're Following See More »
Las Vegas Review-Journal Backs Trump
51 minutes ago

The Las Vegas Review-Journal, owned by casino magnate and GOP donor Sheldon Adelson, became the first major city newspaper to endorse Donald Trump over the weekend.“Mr. Trump represents neither the danger his critics claim nor the magic elixir many of his supporters crave,” the editorial read, acknowledging concerns about Trump’s temperament. “But neither candidate will ever be called to the dais to accept an award for moral probity and character,” the paper said. “And we are already distressingly familiar with the Clinton way, which involves turning public service into an orgy of influence peddling and entitlement designed to line their own pockets — precisely what a disgruntled electorate now rises up to protest.”

Clinton Leads by 12 in ABC Tracking Poll
52 minutes ago

Hillary Clinton leads Donald Trump by 12 percentage points among likely voters, 50 to 38 percent, in a new ABC News tracking poll, "her highest support and his lowest to date in ABC News and ABC News/Washington Post polls. Gary Johnson has 5 percent support, Jill Stein 2 percent. Clinton led by only four points in the last ABC/Post poll on Oct. 13.

Obama to Endorse 150 Down-Ballot Democrats
52 minutes ago

President Obama "will make a late splash into races for state senate and assembly over the next week, endorsing roughly 150 candidates across 20 states. He’ll also back a candidate for the North Carolina Supreme Court. The endorsements — which will come along with a variety of robocalls, social media posts, mailers, photos of Obama with the candidates taken as he’s been traveling to campaign in recent weeks, and even a few radio ads — are Obama’s biggest investment in state races ever by far."

Clinton Reaching Out to GOP Senators
52 minutes ago

If you need a marker for how confident Hillary Clinton is at this point of the race, here's one: CNN's Jeff Zeleny reports "she's been talking to Republican senators, old allies and new, saying that she is willing to work with them and govern."

Morning Consult Poll: Clinton Decisively Won Debate
2 days ago

"According to a new POLITICO/Morning Consult poll, the first national post-debate survey, 43 percent of registered voters said the Democratic candidate won, compared with 26 percent who opted for the Republican Party’s standard bearer. Her 6-point lead over Trump among likely voters is unchanged from our previous survey: Clinton still leads Trump 42 percent to 36 percent in the race for the White House, with Libertarian nominee Gary Johnson taking 9 percent of the vote."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.