Working, Voting, and Bowling Alone

Americans are drifting away from religion, getting married less, switching jobs more, rejecting political parties, and preferring solitary pursuits to group activities.

AP Photo/Charles Rex Arbogast
Charlie Cook
Add to Briefcase
Charlie Cook
Oct. 12, 2017, 8 p.m.

It’s hard not to read the morning newspapers or watch the evening news and not see evidence that the fabric of our nation is coming unraveled. The seventh from the last word in our Pledge of Allegiance is “indivisible,” but we seem to be as badly divided as at any time since the Civil War. Volatility, instability, and rootlessness seem to be all around us. More people than in previous generations seem to have lost their moorings.

Think about the institutions that once helped foster stability: religion, party affiliation, marriage, and jobs. A study of the American religious landscape based on a poll of more than 100,000 Americans was released last week by the Public Religion Research Institute. It showed that the number of people who are religiously unaffiliated has roughly tripled since the early 1990s. Fully 24 percent defined themselves as “atheist,” “agnostic,” or “nothing in particular,” three times as many who characterized themselves this way in the 1980s.

While most people used to identify themselves as Democrat or Republican, that’s no longer the case. A Gallup poll conducted in September showed that 40 percent of American adults classify themselves as independents, compared to 30 percent as Democrats and 29 percent as Republicans. Affiliation with a party meant a framework of beliefs. To be sure, each party accommodated a diversity of views, but members shared a loose ideology. Now the electorate is more fragmented and changeable. As a political analyst, I have trouble understanding how a substantial number of counties and communities could vote twice for Barack Obama and then flip to Donald Trump.

The marriage rate has been in a decline for decades, though interestingly the divorce rate seems to have leveled off or declined slightly in the last few years. But marriage has historically been seen as a stabilizing force in people’s lives and certainly better for raising children. More people are just choosing not to marry, whether they live alone or with someone else, though the increase in gay marriage may mitigate this trend some.

While previous generations were slow to change jobs and employers, Americans jump from job to job with alacrity today, though statisticians disagree about the frequency and even what constitutes a job change. But the days when people stayed with the same employer for decades are pretty much over, another sign of volatility in our society. People today tend to identify less with what they do and where they do it. Their universe of coworkers—who share on-the-job experiences, satisfactions, and frustrations—has shrunk commensurately, further diminishing the social cohesion that marked us all as Americans.

In his 2000 bestseller, Bowling Alone: The Collapse and Revival of American Community, Harvard political scientist Robert D. Putnam wrote about how Americans have become increasingly disengaged from politics. Fewer vote, attend public meetings, and work in campaigns.

He also pointed to a decline in membership in many civic organizations—the Knights of Columbus, B’nai Brith, PTAs, the League of Women Voters, women’s clubs, Scouts, labor unions, Freemasons, Rotary Clubs, the Kiwanis, and military veterans’ groups. The book title came from the finding that while bowling leagues were in decline, bowling was up — a sign that social interaction was giving way to solitary pursuits.

The sense of community, of belonging to something larger than one’s self, seems to have given way to a rootlessness. It could be that social media such as Facebook give people a sense of community and allow them to stay in contact with old friends, but these disembodied connections are different than the face-to-face experiences of going out to dinner or to a ballgame or, for that matter, bowling together. And how do Americans make new friends whose company they enjoy and whose character they trust? A circle of friends consisting of high school classmates is pretty limiting.

Where does this increasing solitariness lead us? As someone who has ADHD (self-diagnosed), I can say in a non-pejorative spirit that our society has shorter attention spans, less focus, and less continuity. In my opinion, it is not a healthy trend for the country, and it may well be happening around the world (which is above my pay grade). But it is something to think about—and to worry about.

What We're Following See More »
Administration Pressing Senate for Rules Changes
12 minutes ago

"The Trump administration is putting pressure on Senate Republicans to crack down on Democratic efforts to delay its agenda, fueling talk about the need for rules reform among Republicans on Capitol Hill. Republicans are in discussions with Democrats about bipartisan changes to Senate rules to speed up consideration of President Trump’s judicial and executive branch nominees, but if that effort flounders — as similar ones have in the past — they’re not ruling out unilateral action."

Trump Had Staff Sign Nondisclosure Agreements
12 minutes ago

During his campaign, Donald Trump indicated to Washington Post reporters that he'd like to have White House employees sign nondisclosure agreements. That is, in fact, what he's done, according to a scoop by the Post's Ruth Marcus. "Some balked at first but, pressed by then-Chief of Staff Reince Priebus and the White House Counsel’s Office, ultimately complied, concluding that the agreements would likely not be enforceable in any event." The administration intended the agreements to remain in force beyond Trump's tenure. An early draft included penalties of up to $10 million.

Rubio Says McCabe Should Have Been Allowed to Retire
10 hours ago
Trump Asking for Bill to “Break the WTO”
11 hours ago

"Trump is asking for a bill" that would effectively break the WTO. One of the core WTO principles — which has underpinned globalization and trade for 70 years — is an idea called 'most favored nation status.' Countries that belong to the WTO have all agreed to charge the same tariff rate for imports from all other WTO members." But Trump covets reciprocal tariffs "nation-by-nation, product-by-product." The GOP free-traders in Congress are unlikely to support such an effort.

Barry McCaffrey Calls Trump “Serious Threat to National Security”
1 days ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.