Border-Tax Foes Look for Next Reform Targets

The coalition that successfully fended off a levy on imports is now focused mostly on cutting corporate rates.

AP Photo/April L. Brown, file
Sept. 19, 2017, 8 p.m.

Major business groups and conservative foundations fought to kill the proposed $1 trillion border-adjustment tax earlier this year. Victory in hand, they’ve turned their effort to pushing down the corporate rate in the Republicans’ planned tax bill, perhaps at the cost of another proposed break.

The border-adjustment tax—a 20 percent levy on imports but not exports—met sharp opposition from the retail sector, which lobbied heavily against the revenue raiser unveiled as part of the House GOP’s 2016 tax-reform blueprint.

With the border tax dead, there’s a big revenue hole in the GOP tax plan, and some business and conservative groups say that tax writers should prioritize cutting the corporate tax rate over other provisions, such as allowing companies to immediately deduct the cost of some capital equipment, a $2.2 trillion proposal known as full expensing. Some retailers are also putting a higher priority on lowering corporate rates rather than fighting another proposal to eliminate the deduction for interest paid on business debt.

“We have members who would be concerned about the loss of the interest deduction, and I think it’s fair to say that it’s an issue that we want to share some concern about how they structure that provision. But far and away our No. 1 priority is rate reduction,” said David French, chief lobbyist at the National Retail Federation, who adds that expensing is not a priority for retail.

And these groups may have a winning strategy to get their message across. FP1 Strategies, a firm hired by both the NRF and Retail Industry Leaders Association to head up their anti-BAT effort, released a “case study” last week detailing the grassroots- and research-driven campaign to kill the tax.

“From day one, FP1 catalogued all critical voices of opposition against the BAT, from President Trump calling it ‘too complicated’ to the steady drumbeat of criticism that soon followed, resulting in over 130 pages of dissent,” the report said.

Those quotes were sent to out to media, amplifying the perception that the BAT was not well supported and was losing momentum, the report said.

After House Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady proposed the BAT as part of the tax-reform blueprint, the idea never got much traction in the Senate or in the White House. After months of opposition from importers and antitax groups, lawmakers dropped the BAT from their tax plan in July.

Tax writers had hoped the border tax would help make their bill revenue-neutral. Its demise has sent them scrambling for new revenue, and many tax principals such as House Speaker Paul Ryan have backed off the call for revenue-neutrality.

“Most of our members are willing to accept a certain amount of deficit if we think it’s a very pro-growth tax bill that will accomplish our objectives, and that’s greater growth in the economy,” Senate Finance Committee member John Thune told reporters Tuesday.

The BAT had some corporate backers. Domestic manufacturers such as The Boeing Company and General Electric formed the American Made Coalition to support the proposal. But ultimately, foes captured the narrative, successfully arguing that the tax would increase prices on the consumer, and the idea was doomed.

Today, the AMC has refocused its effort toward permanently lowering tax rates, sending a Sept. 14 letter outlining its new tax-reform principles to Brady, Ryan, and other members of the Big Six group of lawmakers and administration officials working on tax reform. The AMC is also pushing for a switch to a territorial tax system, in which only U.S. income is taxed, a proposal important for exporters.

Conservative groups instrumental in killing the BAT have shifted their effort as well. The Koch brothers-backed Americans for Prosperity has shifted its multimillion-dollar campaign to focus on lowering the corporate rate and killing the full-expensing proposal, which they say is too expensive.

“That is money that could otherwise be utilized to drive down those rates,” said Brent Gardner, chief government affairs officer at Americans for Prosperity.

Gardner said one lesson from the BAT fight will inform AFP’s tax-reform efforts going forward: the value of coalition building. Retailers, conservative groups, and center-right groups lined up to defeat the border proposal, and that effort could work as a model for other tax provisions going forward.

Some in real estate aren’t fans of the expensing provision, either.

Under current law, property owners can write off the value depreciation of a building over several years—39 years for commercial buildings and 27.5 years for residential rental buildings. Switching to full expensing would allow one big, immediate deduction, but that doesn’t encourage as much growth and could distort the market, said Jeffrey DeBoer, president and CEO of the Washington-based Real Estate Roundtable, during a Sept. 19 Senate Finance hearing on tax reform.

“It will incentivize our industry to build, but we see no benefit in buildings that are ahead of demand and the economy,” DeBoer said.

He instead supported applying a 20-year recovery period for both commercial and residential real estate.

Not all tax groups favor a corporate rate cut over expensing, however. Scott Hodge, president of the conservative-leaning Tax Foundation, said during the hearing that while his group prefers expensing along with a corporate rate cut, expensing drives more growth because it incentivizes new investment.

“We see expensing as the most powerful policy change you can make to improve economic growth, and on an apples-to-apples basis, our models show that full expensing delivers twice the economic growth than a comparable rate cut,” Hodge said.

What We're Following See More »
LOWER COURT HAD INVALIDATED LIFE SENTENCE
SCOTUS Will Hear DC Sniper Case
4 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"The Supreme Court on Monday agreed to consider Virginia’s plea to reinstate the life-without-parole sentence of a man who as a teenager participated in sniper shootings that terrorized the Washington, D.C., region in 2002. The justices said they will take up the state’s appeal in the case of Lee Boyd Malvo, who was 17 when he and John Allen Muhammad fatally shot 10 people in Maryland, Virginia and Washington. Malvo was sentenced to life-without-parole terms in Virginia and in Maryland, and Muhammad was sentenced to death and was executed in 2009. Malvo was sentenced to four life terms for crimes he committed in Virginia. But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit ruled last year that while Malvo’s life-without-parole sentences were legal when they were imposed."

Source:
PROSECUTORS, DOT ARE INVOLVED
U.S. Grand Jury Seeks info on How 737 MAX Is Made
5 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Federal prosecutors and Department of Transportation officials are scrutinizing the development of Boeing Co.’s 737 MAX jetliners, according to people familiar with the matter, unusual inquiries that come amid probes of regulators’ safety approvals of the new plane. A grand jury in Washington, D.C., issued a broad subpoena dated March 11 to at least one person involved in the 737 MAX’s development, seeking related documents, including correspondence, emails and other messages."

Source:
HAS NOT ATTENDED HIGH-LEVEL MEETINGS OF LATE
MBS Stripped of Some Powers
5 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"The heir to the Saudi throne has not attended a series of high-profile ministerial and diplomatic meetings in Saudi Arabia over the last fortnight and is alleged to have been stripped of some of his financial and economic authority, the Guardian has been told. The move to restrict, if only temporarily, the responsibilities of Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman is understood to have been revealed to a group of senior ministers earlier last week by his father, King Salman."

Source:
TURKISH MAN BEING SOUGHT
Mass Shooting in Dutch City of Utrecht
5 hours ago
THE DETAILS
AUTHORIZED TO UNLOCK PHONES
Feds Raided Broidy's Offices Last Year
5 hours ago
THE LATEST

"Federal authorities raided the office of Republican fundraiser Elliott Broidy last summer, seeking records related to his dealings with foreign officials and Trump administration associates, according to a sealed search warrant obtained by ProPublica. Agents were authorized to use the megadonor’s hands and face to unlock any phones that required fingerprint or facial scans."

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login