Both Parties Battle Long Odds in Quest to Capture New Majorities

WASHINGTON, DC - NOVEMBER 21: Senate Minority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) speaks during a news conference on Capitol Hill, November 21, 2013 in Washington, DC. The Senate voted 52-48 to invoke the so-called 'nuclear option', voting to change Senate rules on the controversial filibuster for most presidential nominations with a simple majority vote. 
National Journal
Charlie Cook
Add to Briefcase
Charlie Cook
Dec. 2, 2013, 4:29 p.m.

The 2014 elec­tions are now 11 months away, but the polit­ic­al scene has already un­der­gone dra­mat­ic changes just in the past three months. Re­pub­lic­ans went in­to a polit­ic­al free fall after the gov­ern­ment shut­down, and shortly there­after Demo­crats plunged in­to boil­ing wa­ter thanks to the botched launch of and early pub­lic re­ac­tion to the Af­ford­able Care Act. This column has cau­tioned against pre­ma­turely cast­ing either of these de­vel­op­ments as the de­fin­ing events of the cam­paign. There is a nat­ur­al hu­man tend­ency to be­lieve that any ma­jor de­vel­op­ment, no mat­ter how long be­fore an elec­tion, will be the last im­port­ant in­flu­ence on said elec­tion. This the­ory is fine in the last days be­fore an elec­tion, but with al­most a year to go, it is pretty un­likely that the na­tion­al polit­ic­al situ­ation will sud­denly be­come stat­ic for well over 300 days.

As Demo­crats at­tempt to gain the 17 seats they need to win a House ma­jor­ity and Re­pub­lic­ans work to­ward a six-seat net gain to cap­ture an equally im­port­ant Sen­ate ma­jor­ity, each side faces an up­hill slog — fight­ing in­er­tia as much as any­thing else. For House Demo­crats, the chal­lenge is that both parties have ef­fect­ively con­sol­id­ated their po­s­i­tions in the House, leav­ing little room for either party to make sig­ni­fic­ant gains. Between a his­tor­ic­ally low num­ber of com­pet­it­ive dis­tricts in play — 93 per­cent of House Re­pub­lic­ans oc­cupy dis­tricts car­ried by Mitt Rom­ney, and 96 per­cent of Demo­crats rep­res­ent Obama-won dis­tricts — the House is pretty much sor­ted out. There are few “fish-out-of-wa­ter” dis­tricts (mem­bers hold­ing seats that ought to be held by the oth­er party), along with only a few “jump ball” dis­tricts (where each side has more or less an equal chance of pre­vail­ing).

This curi­ous phe­nomen­on is the res­ult of a num­ber of factors. First, re­dis­trict­ing, car­ried out in an era of highly ef­fect­ive tech­no­logy and data­bases, has been con­duc­ted in such a way as to al­low the dom­in­ant party in each state to draw bound­ar­ies for op­tim­al per­form­ance at a level nev­er be­fore seen. Pop­u­la­tion sort­ing, oth­er­wise known as the “birds-of-a-feath­er-flock-to­geth­er” dy­nam­ic, is an­oth­er im­port­ant factor. Demo­crat­ic voters tend to live in urb­an areas and col­lege towns, while Re­pub­lic­ans are more of­ten found in the ex­urbs — small-town and rur­al Amer­ica. As our coun­try has be­come more po­lar­ized along polit­ic­al lines, we have be­come di­vided geo­graph­ic­ally as well. Fi­nally, the last four elec­tions have ef­fect­ively culled each party’s hold on dis­tricts they prob­ably shouldn’t have held in nor­mal polit­ic­al cir­cum­stances.

In the Sen­ate — now di­vided among 53 Demo­crats, two in­de­pend­ents who caucus with them, and 45 Re­pub­lic­ans — 10 seats will likely see most of the ac­tion; eight of these are held by Demo­crats, two by Re­pub­lic­ans. The GOP needs a net gain of six seats in the Sen­ate to cap­ture a ma­jor­ity. Re­pub­lic­ans have ex­cel­lent pro­spects to win open Demo­crat-held seats in Montana (Max Baucus), South Dakota (Tim John­son), and West Vir­gin­ia (Jay Rock­e­feller). Of course, Demo­crats could man­age to hold onto one or two seats, but at this point, that looks pretty un­likely. As­sum­ing Re­pub­lic­ans pick up those three Demo­crat­ic open seats, the GOP still needs to win three more from the re­main­ing five vul­ner­able seats Demo­crats hold. These in­clude in­cum­bents Mark Be­gich (Alaska), Kay Hagan (North Car­o­lina), Mary Landrieu (Louisi­ana), and Mark Pry­or (Arkan­sas), as well as an open seat in Michigan (Carl Lev­in). This as­sumes that Re­pub­lic­ans don’t lose either of their own vul­ner­able seats to Demo­crat­ic chal­lengers, those vul­ner­ab­il­it­ies be­ing Sen­ate Minor­ity Lead­er Mitch Mc­Con­nell in Ken­tucky and the open seat in Geor­gia (Saxby Cham­b­liss). Mc­Con­nell is fa­cing both a rear-guard at­tack from a tea-party chal­lenger in the GOP primary and an ag­gress­ive gen­er­al-elec­tion op­pon­ent in Demo­crat Al­is­on Lun­der­gan Grimes. The race between Mc­Con­nell and Grimes right now is es­sen­tially even, with about 10 per­cent of the elect­or­ate un­de­cided (pub­lic polls show sub­stan­tially high­er levels of un­de­cided Ken­tucky voters).

The up­hill battle Sen­ate Re­pub­lic­ans face is that even as­sum­ing they pick up Montana, South Dakota, and West Vir­gin­ia, and just for a mo­ment as­sum­ing that they hold onto both Mc­Con­nell and Cham­b­liss’s open seats (neither are safe as­sump­tions), the GOP would still have to de­feat two out of the four in­cum­bent Demo­crats (Be­gich, Hagan, Landrieu, and Pry­or) and win the open Michigan seat. If they fail the lat­ter, the GOP will have to beat three out of the four Demo­crat­ic in­cum­bents. This chal­lenge to over­come in­er­tia comes in­to play for the GOP in two ways. First, over the past five elec­tions (2004-12), Demo­crats have un­seated 11 Re­pub­lic­an Sen­ate in­cum­bents, while Re­pub­lic­ans have only de­feated three Demo­crat­ic in­cum­bents: Tom Daschle (South Dakota), Russ Fein­gold (Wis­con­sin), and Blanche Lin­coln (Arkan­sas). De­pend­ing upon Michigan, the GOP must beat two or three in­cum­bents at min­im­um, something that has been very dif­fi­cult for the party as of late. Keep in mind that one of those five elec­tion years, 2010, was one of the best GOP years in mod­ern his­tory. The oth­er way to look at it is that even if Re­pub­lic­ans win Montana, South Dakota, and West Vir­gin­ia, they still need to win five out of the sev­en races that are not­ably ex­pec­ted to be the closest. Even in 2010 when Re­pub­lic­ans picked up a net gain of six seats, most of those were fore­gone con­clu­sions. The GOP lost five of the sev­en seats that The Cook Polit­ic­al Re­port had rated as Toss Ups go­ing in­to Elec­tion Day that year. Last year, of the 10 races we had rated as Toss Up, Re­pub­lic­ans lost eight of them. So Sen­ate Re­pub­lic­ans have had trouble de­feat­ing in­cum­bent Demo­crats and, for that mat­ter, win­ning the close races. In 2014, they have to do both.

COR­REC­TION: Due to an edit­ing er­ror, a pre­vi­ous ver­sion of this story in­cor­rectly stated that the GOP needs six seats in the House to cap­ture a ma­jor­ity. In fact, the GOP needs a net gain of six seats in the Sen­ate to win a ma­jor­ity.

What We're Following See More »
PER SOURCES
Trump to Visit UK In July
29 minutes ago
THE DETAILS

"US President Donald Trump will visit the UK in mid-July, according to Sky sources," with a formal announcement expected soon. "Mr Trump was due to open the new US Embassy in London in February but cancelled the trip saying the building was too expensive and tweeting that he was not a 'big fan' of the decision to move its location."

Source:
TESTS WERE SUSPENDED LAST WEEK
North Korea Testing Site Collapsed
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

"North Korea’s underground nuclear test site has become unusable after a large part of it collapsed," say experts from the University of Science and Technology of China. "Their evidence comes just one week after a surprise announcement from leader Kim Jong Un that North Korea would stop nuclear tests." The finding contradicts the Trump Administration's claim that the closure was a major concession by North Korean leader Kim Jung Un, who is set to meet with him for talks with President Trump in May.

Source:
WILL REDUCE DEBATE TIME FROM 30 HOURS TO 8
Senate Rules Aims to Speed Confirmation of Nominees
1 hours ago
THE DETAILS

"Republicans on Wednesday will begin a push to change Senate rules in a way that would allow the faster confirmation of President Trump's nominees, after months of complaints that Democrats are dragging out the process. The Senate Rules Committee will meet in the afternoon to consider a resolution that would reduce post-cloture debate for most Executive Branch nominees from 30 hours to just 8 hours. The goal is to prevent Democrats from stretching out debate over several days."

Source:
LESKO WILL FILL FRANKS’S SEAT
GOP Holds onto AZ-08 Seat Narrowly
2 hours ago
THE DETAILS

Arizona Republican Debbie Lesko won a special election to fill the deep red seat Trent Franks retired from earlier this year. Unofficial balloting had her up 52.9% to 47.2%. This victory is a bit close for comfort, considering Donald Trump's 21-point victory there in 2016. This victory will do very little to calm GOP nerves five months before Election Day.

TRUMP CALLED HIM A “GREAT GUY”
Apple CEO To Meet With Trump
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

Apple CEO Tim Cook will meet with President Trump today, "at a time of heightened trade tensions between the U.S. and China with technology caught up in the spat. Both countries have proposed import tariffs on each others' products, but the U.S. has been tough on Chinese technology firms." China is an important market for Apple, and Cook is expected to bring up the worsening trade relationship.

Source:
×
×

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.

Login