Is Anti-Trump Message a Winning Strategy for Democrats?

An upcoming race in suburban Atlanta will test the idea that the party can take back Congress by turning an election into a referendum on the president.

Then-Rep. Tom Price (right) at his confirmation hearing before the Senate Finance Committee on Jan. 24.
AP Photo/Andrew Harnik
Josh Kraushaar
Add to Briefcase
Josh Kraushaar
Feb. 21, 2017, 8 p.m.

The emer­ging view among many Demo­crats is that Pres­id­ent Trump is so un­pop­u­lar, even in many GOP-friendly areas, that their can­did­ates simply need to run against the White House to win back con­trol of Con­gress. As long as the party pro­motes cha­ris­mat­ic, tele­gen­ic re­cruits, the think­ing goes, their ideo­logy won’t mat­ter a whit. Nu­mer­ous out­side groups are pop­ping up, de­clar­ing them­selves part of the “res­ist­ance” against the White House. These par­tis­ans ar­gue that GOP ob­struc­tion un­der Pres­id­ent Obama helped Re­pub­lic­ans win con­trol of the House, Sen­ate, and pres­id­ency. Now Demo­crats feel they can use sim­il­arly ag­gress­ive tac­tics and do the same.

The emer­ging view in Re­pub­lic­an circles is that par­tis­an loy­alty is strong enough that GOP can­did­ates will be able to win in states and dis­tricts where the party holds a nu­mer­ic­al ad­vant­age. They point to the res­ults of last year’s pres­id­en­tial elec­tion, in which con­gres­sion­al Re­pub­lic­ans were able to dis­tin­guish their own brand from Trump’s blustery pop­u­lism. They ar­gue that the Demo­crat­ic Party is so dom­in­ated by its left wing that even anti-Trump Re­pub­lic­ans will con­tin­ue to vote for their party’s con­gres­sion­al can­did­ates, so long as they run on a tra­di­tion­al con­ser­vat­ive agenda.

These two ar­gu­ments will col­lide in an up­com­ing spe­cial elec­tion in sub­urb­an At­lanta for the seat of just-con­firmed Health and Hu­man Ser­vices Sec­ret­ary Tom Price—the first con­gres­sion­al elec­tion dur­ing Trump’s pres­id­ency. A lengthy roster of Re­pub­lic­ans and Demo­crats are vy­ing to win a once-solidly Re­pub­lic­an dis­trict which has be­come highly com­pet­it­ive in the age of Trump. Nestled in up­scale Fulton and Cobb counties, the dis­trict is filled with af­flu­ent Re­pub­lic­ans work­ing for For­tune 500 com­pan­ies like Home De­pot and Coca Cola. Trump car­ried the dis­trict by only 2 points in 2016, a 20-point drop-off from Mitt Rom­ney’s win­ning mar­gin four years earli­er.

On pa­per, this elec­tion should be a golden op­por­tun­ity for Demo­crats to make polit­ic­al in­roads. The dis­trict is filled with the type of col­lege-edu­cated voters who have grav­it­ated away from Trump—in­clud­ing in­de­pend­ents who don’t have strong par­tis­an loy­al­ties but tend to vote Re­pub­lic­an. El­ev­en Re­pub­lic­ans will be fight­ing against each oth­er on an all-party primary bal­lot, mak­ing it likely the even­tu­al GOP stand­ard-bear­er will be wounded head­ing in­to an ex­pec­ted run­off. Trump’s pres­id­ency has got­ten off to a rocky start, giv­ing any Demo­crat plenty of ma­ter­i­al to work with.

But the early Demo­crat­ic fa­vor­ite in the race is about as awk­ward a fit for this par­tic­u­lar dis­trict as Demo­crats could find. Jon Os­soff, a self-de­scribed in­vest­ig­at­ive film­maker, is a 30-year-old former na­tion­al se­cur­ity staffer for lib­er­al Rep. Hank John­son. His can­did­acy has been en­dorsed by Rep. John Lewis and cham­pioned by the lib­er­al Daily Kos web­site, which has helped him raise nearly $1 mil­lion for his cam­paign—a re­mark­able sum for an ob­scure can­did­ate in an off-year House elec­tion. He’s fa­cing an­oth­er Demo­crat, former state Sen. Ron Slot­in, whose more-mod­er­ate cre­den­tials are passé at a time when his party is look­ing for con­front­a­tion­al voices.

Os­soff fills the con­front­a­tion­al role to a tee. In case his cam­paign mes­sage wasn’t clear, his web­site is em­blazoned with the head­line: “Geor­gia: Stand Up To Trump.” Mak­ing the race about Trump is help­ing him raise his pro­file and bring­ing in loads of cam­paign cash. But money isn’t a sub­sti­tute for a mes­sage that can win over Re­pub­lic­ans who will find Os­soff’s down-the-line lib­er­al views as prob­lem­at­ic as Trump’s pop­u­lism. Demo­crat­ic act­iv­ists may be en­er­gized by Os­soff’s broad­sides against the pres­id­ent, but they will end up dis­ap­poin­ted if he doesn’t meld them with a cent­rist mes­sage de­signed to at­tract dis­af­fected Re­pub­lic­ans.

Re­pub­lic­ans are also poised to test how deep par­tis­an­ship runs, even among con­ser­vat­ive voters who aren’t thrilled with Trump. A few of the 11 Re­pub­lic­ans who filed to run are latch­ing onto Trump’s coat­tails, most prom­in­ently Trump cam­paign sur­rog­ate Bruce LeV­ell. But most of the can­did­ates are con­ven­tion­al Re­pub­lic­ans who have long been in­volved in Geor­gia polit­ics. The best-known Re­pub­lic­an in the race, former Sec­ret­ary of State Kar­en Han­del, was an un­suc­cess­ful gubernat­ori­al and con­gres­sion­al can­did­ate. State Sen. Jud­son Hill, the first can­did­ate to enter the race, has a polit­ic­al base in Cobb County and is a for­mid­able fun­draiser. Former state Sen. Dan Moody is close to former Gov. Sonny Per­due, and has enough per­son­al wealth to fin­ance his cam­paign.

If Demo­crats can even run com­pet­it­ively in this dis­trict, it would be a sign that an unadul­ter­ated anti-Trump mes­sage can pay di­vidends. But if the next Re­pub­lic­an nom­in­ee per­forms like Price—who nev­er won less than 62 per­cent of the vote in his sev­en cam­paigns—it will send a sig­nal that simply be­ing the op­pos­i­tion isn’t enough to win back con­trol of Con­gress.

“If you have an old white guy who’s hard right-wing, pro-Trump, anti-Muslim, and anti-gay mar­riage run­ning against a wo­man who comes across like Michelle Nunn, that’s the dy­nam­ic that could be a prob­lem for us,” said one GOP strategist track­ing the race. “But you’re not go­ing to have that dy­nam­ic.”

COR­REC­TION: Os­soff’s cam­paign spokes­man said Os­soff voted for Hil­lary Clin­ton in Geor­gia’s 2016 pres­id­en­tial primary. This story ori­gin­ally wrote he backed Bernie Sanders.

What We're Following See More »
Rubio Says McCabe Should Have Been Allowed to Retire
5 hours ago
Trump Asking for Bill to “Break the WTO”
5 hours ago

"Trump is asking for a bill" that would effectively break the WTO. One of the core WTO principles — which has underpinned globalization and trade for 70 years — is an idea called 'most favored nation status.' Countries that belong to the WTO have all agreed to charge the same tariff rate for imports from all other WTO members." But Trump covets reciprocal tariffs "nation-by-nation, product-by-product." The GOP free-traders in Congress are unlikely to support such an effort.

Barry McCaffrey Calls Trump “Serious Threat to National Security”
1 days ago
Trump to Fire McMaster
2 days ago

"Trump is ready to oust Lt. Gen. H.R. McMaster and find a new national security adviser before the North Korea meetings in May, multiple sources told CNN Thursday. The move may be delayed because there's no final decision on a replacement, sources say. The timing of an announcement is unclear -- one source said it could come as soon as Friday, though others say that is unlikely."

Mueller Subpoenas Trump Organization
3 days ago

"Robert S. Mueller III has subpoenaed the Trump Organization to turn over documents, including some related to Russia, according to two people briefed on the matter. The order is the first known time that the special counsel demanded documents directly related to President Trump’s businesses." The subpoena is proof that the investigation will likely drag on "for at least several more months," and also indicates Mueller may be "broadening his investigation to examine the role foreign money may have played in funding Mr. Trump’s political activities."


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.