Why Clinton Has a Millennial Problem

The younger they get, the less supportive voters are for her.

Chelsea Clinton answers questions from students at York College in York, Pa., during a campaign stop for her mother, Democratic presidential hopeful, Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton, D-N.Y., Wednesday, April 2, 2008.
AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster
Colin Diersing
Add to Briefcase
Colin Diersing
Sept. 15, 2016, 8 p.m.

Bernie Sanders prom­ised them a re­volu­tion. Now Hil­lary Clin­ton has to con­vince them to settle.

Amer­ica’s young­est voters helped pro­pel Sanders to a sur­pris­ingly strong show­ing in the Demo­crat­ic primar­ies. Now, as Clin­ton faces Don­ald Trump, re­cent polling in­dic­ates she is strug­gling to win them over at the level of Sanders or Pres­id­ent Obama, and it sug­gests the prob­lem is con­cen­trated among the very young­est voters, who could flee for a third-party can­did­ate.

In a new sur­vey of Mil­len­ni­al likely voters re­leased Thursday by lib­er­al group Nex­t­Gen Cli­mate, in col­lab­or­a­tion with Glob­al Strategy Group, sup­port for Clin­ton was only 5 points lower than sup­port for Barack Obama among those 25 to 34 years old. But it was far lower in com­par­is­on with 18-24-year-olds. Her fa­vor­ab­il­ity rat­ing among the young­est group was just 38 per­cent, com­pared to 45 per­cent with those 24 to 29, and 50 per­cent with those 30 to 34.

The poll is con­sist­ent with ana­lys­is of Sur­vey Mon­key data pub­lished this week on Five Thirty Eight, which showed Clin­ton un­der­per­form­ing Obama’s ap­prov­al rat­ing by 18 points among 18-24-year-olds, while more or less match­ing it with every oth­er age group, in­clud­ing older mil­len­ni­als.

“As you get young­er, the prob­lems for her get more pro­nounced, in terms of reach­ing her full po­ten­tial and per­form­ing re­l­at­ive to par­tis­an­ship,” said An­drew Bau­mann, a Glob­al Strategy Group poll­ster who over­saw the sur­vey. “Views to­ward Pres­id­ent Obama, Sen­at­or Sanders, Don­ald Trump, and the Re­pub­lic­an Party—all those things are con­sist­ent across [Mil­len­ni­al] age groups. Views to­ward Sec­ret­ary Clin­ton are lower as they get young­er.”

While their slightly older coun­ter­parts likely re­mem­ber Clin­ton as a pop­u­lar sec­ret­ary of State who worked closely with a pres­id­ent they deeply ad­mire, the young­est voters in this elec­tion are more likely to have defined their views of Clin­ton in the con­text of this hard-fought cam­paign, in which her trust­wor­thi­ness and pro­gress­ive bon­afides have come un­der fire.

“Their view to­ward Sec­ret­ary Clin­ton is pretty much en­tirely based on what they’ve gone through in this cam­paign,” Bau­mann said. “They really liked Sen­at­or Sanders, and he spent a year telling them Hil­lary Clin­ton was a tool of the ol­ig­archs, for the Ir­aq war, all these bad things.”

In a sep­ar­ate in­ter­view, Demo­crat­ic poll­ster Celinda Lake said these voters are fur­ther re­moved from the strong eco­nomy of Bill Clin­ton’s pres­id­ency and more likely to feel rest­less about the eco­nom­ic and polit­ic­al sys­tem with which they con­nect Clin­ton.

“The older mil­len­ni­als have par­ents who speak quite fondly of the Clin­ton years,” Lake said. “The young­er mil­len­ni­als have par­ents who don’t tend to have as much re­cog­ni­tion of how good the eco­nomy was dur­ing the ‘90s.

While the older end of the gen­er­a­tion rose up through a tough eco­nomy and has made it, Lake ad­ded, the young­er ones “are the baris­tas at Star­bucks, haven’t been able to get a job, are very heav­ily in­debted, and are back home on the couch dur­ing the re­ces­sion, none of which made them happy.”

The young­est voters also don’t have as much ex­per­i­ence in party polit­ics. They haven’t voted for either party many times and, strategists said, that might leave them open to con­sid­er­ing oth­er op­tions more read­ily.

“Folks who are late 20s, early-to-mid-30s, those are the hope-and-change Mil­len­ni­als. They re­membered 2008 be­cause they got re­gistered and prob­ably got re­gistered as Demo­crats. They’ve de­veloped a little bit longer-term loy­alty to the Demo­crat­ic Party la­bel and tra­di­tion­al par­tis­an di­vides,” said Re­pub­lic­an poll­ster Kristen Solt­is An­der­son, au­thor of The Selfie Vote. “If you’re young­er you don’t ne­ces­sar­ily have a his­tory of cast­ing votes in na­tion­al elec­tions, maybe you haven’t even re­gistered with a party.”

Sev­er­al poll­sters poin­ted out they are also less likely to re­mem­ber the 2000 elec­tion, when third-party vot­ing was widely seen as hav­ing thrown the elec­tion to George Bush. Greg Speed, pres­id­ent of Amer­ica Votes, said he thinks these voters need to be re­minded of the cost of vot­ing third party.

“Not only is the Clin­ton pres­id­ency not their ex­per­i­ence, the 2000 elec­tion is also not part of their polit­ic­al ex­per­i­ence. They see vot­ing for a Gary John­son or a Jill Stein as more of a free pass than it really is,” Speed said. “We need to make clear that the only way to de­feat Trump is to vote for Clin­ton.”

Of John­son, Lake said, “Older voters will say ‘He’s the pot can­did­ate.’ Young­er Mil­len­ni­als will say, ‘No, he’s a re­form can­did­ate.’”

All of this has some Demo­crat­ic strategists ques­tion­ing how the Clin­ton cam­paign has handled its out­reach to young voters so far, and wor­ried that they could face prob­lems without a plan to win back the ones cur­rently sup­port­ing third-parties. Paint­ing a neg­at­ive im­age of Trump might not be enough, they point out, with a co­hort of voters par­tic­u­larly will­ing to pass Clin­ton over for John­son or Stein.

“It’s im­per­at­ive here for us to be able to com­mu­nic­ate and double down and win these voters and bring these voters along, be­cause there is no Demo­crat win­ning co­ali­tion without them,” Demo­crat­ic poll­ster Cor­nell Belch­er said.

Ben Tulchin, who polled for Sanders in the primary, said Clin­ton should spend more time talk­ing about the col­lege af­ford­ab­il­ity plan she in­tro­duced after the primary, say­ing, “She’s got to have more repu­ta­tion, more con­vic­tion to it.”

No mat­ter her out­reach, Belch­er said there should be no ex­pect­a­tion for Clin­ton to match Obama’s sup­port with young voters.

“It’s un­fair for Hil­lary or really al­most any Demo­crat to come on the back end of that love af­fair to think the same sort of en­ergy and love would be there for them,” Belch­er said. “They fell in love with Barack Obama and now their lov­er is leav­ing.”

Bau­man took a dif­fer­ent view, say­ing he would have ex­pec­ted clear­er sup­port for Clin­ton at this point.

“I would have been sur­prised Sec­ret­ary Clin­ton hadn’t been able to bring them around and con­sol­id­ate them as much as I thought they would, but it doesn’t sur­prise me without the ef­fort that they don’t come around,” Bau­man said.

What We're Following See More »
White House Announcing STEM Initiative
3 minutes ago

"Trump is set to sign a presidential memorandum at the White House later today that tasks the Department of Education to devote at least $200 million of its grant funds each year to so-called STEM fields...And on Tuesday, Trump’s daughter and advisor, Ivanka, is expected to head to Detroit, where she will join business leaders for an event unveiling a series of private-sector commitments — from Amazon, Facebook, Google, GM, Quicken Loans and others — meant to boost U.S. coding and computer-science classes and programs."

One America Appeal Expands
16 minutes ago
N. Korea Says Trump’s Words were a War Declaration
1 hours ago
Sen. Rand Paul Still Doesn’t Approve
1 hours ago
Anthony Weiner: 21 Months in Prison
1 hours ago

"Anthony Weiner was sentenced to 21 months in prison for exchanging sexually explicit messages with a 15-year-old girl, capping the spectacular fall of the former congressman whose self-destructive behavior wrecked his career and marriage and played a role in the final days of the 2016 presidential campaign. A tearful Weiner told U.S. District Judge Denise Cote that 'the crime I committed is my rock bottom.'"


Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.