After months on the defensive over allegations that it facilitated access to illegal products, Google is now going on offense.
The Internet giant sued Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood on Friday to block a subpoena it claims would violate its constitutional rights. Kent Walker, Google’s general counsel, said the subpoena “constitutes an unjustified attack that violates well-established U.S. laws.”
Google also created a webpage to rally its millions of users to combat a “secret campaign” by the movie industry to “bring back web censorship.”
The company is launching its attacks after emails leaked from the Sony hack revealed that movie-industry lobbyists have been working closely with state officials to crack down on Google.
Hollywood’s goal, according to reports from The New York Times and The Verge, is to force Google to cut off access to sites that offer pirated copies of movies. The industry has long argued that rampant online piracy hurts filmmakers and destroys U.S. jobs.
In October, the Mississippi attorney general issued a 79-page subpoena demanding that Google turn over documents related to advertisements and search results for illegal products, such as drugs and pirated movies. Hood’s investigation has been closely coordinated with Hollywood lobbyists, according to the leaked emails.
In response to Google’s legal action, Hood said he is calling a “time out” and will reach out to Google’s lawyers to “negotiate a peaceful resolution.” But he also defended his decision to target Google, which he said is “raking in advertising dollars off of drug dealers.”
“Now, feeling emboldened with its billions of dollars, media prowess and political power, some of its more excitable people have sued trying to stop the State of Mississippi for daring to ask some questions,” he said. “We expect more from one of the wealthiest corporations in the world.”
In its lawsuit Friday, Google claimed Hood’s subpoena would be “enormously burdensome” and that federal law protects its right to host third-party content, even if the content is illegal.
“The Attorney General may prefer a pre-filtered Internet—but the Constitution and Congress have denied him the authority to mandate it,” the company wrote.
Google also sent notices to the Motion Picture Association of America and its law firm, Jenner and Block, demanding that they preserve documents related to their lobbying campaign.
The legal salvos follow a blog post from Google on Thursday, which accused the MPAA of “trying to secretly censor the Internet.”
Kate Bedingfield, a spokeswoman for the MPAA, called the blog post “shameful,” and argued that the company is just trying to deflect attention away from its role in “enabling and facilitating illegal conduct.”
The movie industry will continue to “seek the assistance of any and all government agencies, whether federal, state or local, to protect the rights of all involved in creative activities,” she said.
—This article has been updated with a response from the Mississippi attorney general.
What We're Following See More »
Last Wednesday, a Federal Judge in San Francisco ruled that the Obama-era DACA program must be allowed to continue until lawsuits play out in court. The Trump administration has appealed that decision on the grounds that President Obama exceeded his authority by creating the program, and that Congress must pass legislation protecting dreamers if they are to be allowed to stay. “It defies both law and common sense," said Attorney General Sessions in a statement, that a “single district court in San Francisco” had halted the administration’s plans. The White House will also petition the Supreme Court to intervene in the case, in an unusual bid to bypass the Ninth Circuit altogether.
A number of historical and environmental groups oppose construction of President Obama's presidential center in the proposed site, Jackson Park. Charles Birnbaum, president and founder of D.C.-based nonprofit, the Cultural Landscape Foundation, said that there is "plenty of land on the South Side that they could and should use," but that the organizers "have been adamant that they must have historic public parkland for the purpose." Birnbaum is joined by Friends of the Parks, Jackson Park Watch, Openlands, National Association for Olmsted Parks, Save the Midway, Landmarks Illinois, Preservation Chicago, and 200 faculty at the University of Chicago, Obama's alma mater. President Trump's Environmental Protection Agency gets final say on approval, and may reject it if the center is found to have "adverse effects" on Jackson Park.
"The move marked the first time Mr. Mueller is known to have used a grand jury subpoena to seek information from a member of Mr. Trump’s inner circle. ...Mr. Mueller is likely to allow Mr. Bannon to forgo the grand jury appearance if he agrees to instead be questioned by investigators in the less formal setting of the special counsel’s offices in Washington."