The Climate Conspiracy Theory Coming to Your Congressman’s Twitter Feed

It’s an innovative app, but it’s being used to push an odd, odd message.

There's a better way for geoengineering conspiracy theorists to get their elected officials' attention.
National Journal
Jason Plautz
Add to Briefcase
Jason Plautz
Feb. 5, 2015, 3 p.m.

Filmmaker George Barnes first grew suspicious after he left his camera on all day to create a time-lapse effect for a car commercial. The sky, he noticed, had turned entirely white. When he played back his tape, he saw jets flying in a grid pattern across the New Jersey sky. He asked a fellow producer to look into it, resulting in a packet of information with terms like “chemtrails” and “geoengineering.”

And from there, to Barnes, the conclusion was inescapable: His tape was evidence of a broad, high-level conspiracy to use airplanes to spray chemicals into the Earth’s atmosphere and alter its climate — a desperate, secret, and misguided attempt to fight global warming.

Barnes has since dedicated his life to raising awareness of chemtrails and pushing those in power to acknowledge them. Since his New Jersey discovery more than two years ago, he’s rolled out a documentary film with a Baldwin brother, a petition with the former speaker of the Florida House, and an app that could change the way citizens get in touch with Congress.

The chemtrails conspiracy isn’t a new one, but it has taken off in recent years. It’s part of the premise behind the summer movie Snowpiercer, in which humans geoengineer the Earth until it completely froze over. (In the opening credits, a shot of airplane contrails is heralded with an ominous blast of brass, kicking off a story in which post-chemtrail-apocalypse humanity is confined to a single class-stratified train that circumnavigates the globe.)

Geoengineering — a catchall term for intentional, large-scale human actions aimed at combating climate change — is real, at least as a studied theory. The National Research Council will release a report on the topic next week, while academics and the United Nations have acknowledged it as a hypothetical — but far off — option to combat global warming.

The chemtrail conspiracy, however, is concerned about something that’s as fictional as Snowpiercer. Regular airplane contrails can linger for hours, based on the moisture content of the air, and that’s been the case for as long as there has been air travel. Grid patterns are just the result of airplanes flying on predetermined paths. And given the number of people who would be needed to pull off such a stunt, it’s extremely unlikely that it’s going on — and being kept secret.

But does not deter the believers, to whom denials amount to nothing more than catnip. They’re trying to bring the issue to people in power, from local government to the halls of Congress, to try to stop what they see as a fatal experiment.

“Short of a nuclear cataclysm, there’s no more greater or immediate threat to all of us than climate engineering,” said Dane Wigington, lead researcher at the chemtrails tracking site GeoEngineering Watch. “Just speaking statistically and mathematically.”

It’s tempting to write off Barnes as a run-of-the-mill conspiracy theorist, his quest has produced an interesting side benefit: a tool that could make it easier for activists of all stripes to command their elected officials’ attention.

Barnes created the Skyder Alert app, which combines photo and geolocation technology to make it easy for everyday Twitter users to communicate with their elected officials. Through the app, users snap pictures of “suspicious” contrails and can then — via the locator portion of the app — tweet them directly at the House representatives, senators, and governor who represent the spot where the user is standing, along with a prewritten petition with the hashtag #CivilRightsViolation.

The geolocation feature, which allows citizens to quickly contact a district’s officials even if they don’t already know who those officials are, was a creation of Barnes’s and appears to be unique. It also opens a host of possibilities: Imagine being able to quickly tweet photos of uncollected trash or of potholes to your local alderman, or images of a people benefiting from a federal program that local officials favor cutting.

“It’s a brilliant concept for an entry-level citizen to get engaged,” said Steven Polunsky, a research scientist at Texas A&M University who also worked on technology for the Texas state Senate. “For someone who doesn’t contact their government regularly, it’s going to start with this kind of single-issue motivator that gets them out of their chair.”

And, because many elected officials run their own Twitter accounts personally, Barnes says it’s a chance to make direct contact in a way one couldn’t through traditional media.

“You always hear stuff like ‘contact your congressman, call this number,’ and it’s something nobody ever does,” said Barnes. “So I’m thinking, what’s the easiest way to do it? How can we get the most amount of people to contact Congress from their own information?”

Barnes, then new to coding, wrote the app himself with the help of a team of more-experienced programmers, manually inputting the boundaries of congressional districts.

But is it working to bring attention to the “chemtrails conspiracy”? National Journal contacted congressional offices that had been pinged with SkyderAlert notices. Multiple offices acknowledged seeing the tweets, some with a chuckle, but hadn’t responded to them.

Sen. Dean Heller, a Nevada Republican, responded last year to a constituent inquiry on chemtrails with a letter that discussed his own work on chemical-safety reform. New Jersey Republican Rodney Frelinghuysen also responded to a request about “the ongoing Stratospheric Aerosol GeoEngineering, Solar, Radiation Management programs” with a promise to meet with staff, although there does not appear to be any followup.

For Barnes, the app is one part of an attempt to lend more legitimacy to a movement that has its fair share of off-kilter behavior. The chemtrails conspiracy may be best known for its extreme believers, such as a woman who filmed herself yelling at the sky and spraying vinegar to clear contrails. Or a line of parody songs from YouTube user Michael Fleming, including “Smells Like Chemtrail Spirit,” “Satan Claws Is Sprayin’ Your Town,” and “Under the Chembow” (“Somewhere under the chembow / children die / There’s a land that’s been gassed with / sulfur dioxide”).

But with big data, the hope is to lend some credence to the arguments and raise the issue at the top. Skyder Alert compiles pictures of suspicious contrails on a map, an effort that Barnes said has paid off. In the days before a massive storm dumped 6 feet of snow on Buffalo in November, Barnes said his map showed a rash of unusual contrails (meteorologists said the storm was an escalated lake-effect snow).

Geoengineering Watch has pointed to a whole slew of negative effects resulting from “weather warfare,” from UV radiation killing trees to clusters of cancer cases that it links to aluminum being sprayed on unsuspecting citizens. Even California’s drought and the warming oceans have been linked to chemtrails.

So supporters are pushing to raise the issue with anyone they think can answer their questions. Skyder Alert joined the People’s Climate March outside of a U.N. meeting in September amid established green groups. Arizona state Sen. Kelli Ward convened a two-hour meeting this spring in response to activists’ concerns about chemtrails, where dozens of citizens slammed the government’s secret experiments and raised alarms about being poisoned. The board of supervisors in Shasta County in Northern California even voted this summer to research chemtrails after a three-hour meeting that local media said was the best attended by citizens.

Barnes has also been promoting his film Look Up! about chemtrails, which features narration from William Baldwin (the one from Backdraft). Under a deal with a theater distribution service, it’s hitting cinemas, and people can petition local theaters to hold screenings. The movie includes repeated clips of Holdren talking about geoengineering and interviews with Foster Gamble, a descendant of the founder of Procter & Gamble, who has founded the Thrive Movement to assist “humanity in thriving through the evolutionary challenges threatening our survival.”

The movement has even drawn some academic attention. A November study in The Geographic Journal looked at the chemtrails movement as part of a broader social shift on climate change and geoengineering, drawing a line between the “paranoid” and “normal” views. “Certain elements of the discourse (such as the moral outrage at the idea of powerful elites controlling the climate, or the importance of emotional and spiritual connections to weather and climate) highlight concerns of relevance to mainstream geoengineering debates,” wrote author Rose Cairns of the University of Sussex.

The debate over geoengineering is heating up, although with no real work being done. A section of the United Nations Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report discusses its possibilities, but notes a lack of evidence, and a recent Newsweek cover examined its potential. The pending National Research Council report will examine a “limited number of potential” geoengineering techniques.

White House science adviser John Holdren said in a 2009 interview that geoengineering ought to be on the table to combat global warming, although he later clarified that it was not under consideration by the administration.

As with many conspiracy theories, attempts to dispel believers’ accusations are immediately converted into evidence those accusations are true.

Tom Gustafson, a former Florida House speaker who offered technical assistance to Barnes and was interviewed in Look Up!, said the denials demonstrate the secrecy of those behind the chemtrails effort.

“The secrecy around this is a symptom of the problem,” said Gustafson. “The problem here is a lack of honesty in what they know. We want the citizens who have to react, be able to react. I suspect that people might panic “¦ but that doesn’t get addressed by keeping it quiet.”

What We're Following See More »
Lawmakers May Need Second Short-Term Spending Bill to Avoid Shutdown
1 minutes ago

"Ten days before the government would run out of funding, bipartisan negotiators are still struggling to reach a budget deal, and many lawmakers on Capitol Hill are already admitting Congress will need another stopgap bill to avoid a shutdown." Senator Cornyn (R-TX) said that while he "hopes" the government can avoid a shutdown, it's "likely" that there Congress will pass another short term budget before the January 19 deadline. "The clock is ticking," Cornyn told CNN, for legislators to compromise on border security and DACA, which is the primary sticking point in negotiations. Conservative GOP representatives are pushing for a party-line vote in the House, rather than wait for a bipartisan proposal from the Senate.

Trump Administration Appeals 9th Circuit Decision on DACA
17 minutes ago

Last Wednesday, a Federal Judge in San Francisco ruled that the Obama-era DACA program must be allowed to continue until lawsuits play out in court. The Trump administration has appealed that decision on the grounds that President Obama exceeded his authority by creating the program, and that Congress must pass legislation protecting dreamers if they are to be allowed to stay. “It defies both law and common sense," said Attorney General Sessions in a statement, that a “single district court in San Francisco” had halted the administration’s plans. The White House will also petition the Supreme Court to intervene in the case, in an unusual bid to bypass the Ninth Circuit altogether.

Senate Democrats Need GOP Ally in Vote to Reinstate Net Neutrality
2 hours ago
Chicago Advocacy Groups Oppose New Obama Foundation Center
2 hours ago

A number of historical and environmental groups oppose construction of President Obama's presidential center in the proposed site, Jackson Park. Charles Birnbaum, president and founder of D.C.-based nonprofit, the Cultural Landscape Foundation, said that there is "plenty of land on the South Side that they could and should use," but that the organizers "have been adamant that they must have historic public parkland for the purpose." Birnbaum is joined by Friends of the Parks, Jackson Park Watch, Openlands, National Association for Olmsted Parks, Save the Midway, Landmarks Illinois, Preservation Chicago, and 200 faculty at the University of Chicago, Obama's alma mater. President Trump's Environmental Protection Agency gets final say on approval, and may reject it if the center is found to have "adverse effects" on Jackson Park.

DHS Sec. Nielsen Going to Canada
2 hours ago

Welcome to National Journal!

You are currently accessing National Journal from IP access. Please login to access this feature. If you have any questions, please contact your Dedicated Advisor.