It’s Primary Day in D.C., but My Vote Won’t Count

Seventeen percent of District voters don’t identify with a party. Thanks to closed primaries, they won’t have much of a say in selecting the city’s new mayor.

Citizens vote on Election Day at Fire Station #71 in Alhambra, Los Angeles County, on November 6, 2012 in California.
National Journal
Sarah Mimms
April 1, 2014, 8:59 a.m.

As a D.C. res­id­ent for the past sev­en years, I’ve been denied rep­res­ent­a­tion in Con­gress. Today, I was denied the right to vote — or at least to have it coun­ted.

After ar­riv­ing at my polling place in sunny East­ern Mar­ket on Tues­day morn­ing, I in­tro­duced my­self as a non­par­tis­an voter, one of the in­de­pend­ents whom na­tion­al polit­ic­al parties are so eager to track down dur­ing con­gres­sion­al elec­tion years. I was giv­en a spe­cial bal­lot and told to choose a party primary to vote in. A call to the Board of Elec­tions after I cast my bal­lot, however, con­firmed my sus­pi­cions: My bal­lot will not be coun­ted.

Wash­ing­ton is hold­ing its may­or­al primary elec­tion, in which scan­dal-fraught Vin­cent Gray is seek­ing the Demo­crat­ic nom­in­a­tion for a second term against sev­en oth­er can­did­ates. The Dis­trict is over­whelm­ingly Demo­crat­ic, with nearly 76 per­cent of Dis­trict voters re­gistered with the Demo­crat­ic Party.

Giv­en that elect­or­al makeup, the win­ner of the Demo­crat­ic primary is typ­ic­ally guar­an­teed to be­come may­or, mak­ing the gen­er­al elec­tion in Novem­ber, which is open to mem­bers of all parties (and even no party), a moot point. This year, giv­en the in­cum­bent’s his­tory, if Gray re­ceives the Demo­crat­ic nom­in­a­tion, polling shows that in­de­pend­ent Coun­cil­man Dav­id Catania could give him a run for his money in Novem­ber.

After Demo­crats, the next highest num­ber of re­gistered voters are in­de­pend­ents. Fully 17 per­cent of Wash­ing­ton’s voters are not re­gistered with any party. In oth­er words, thanks to the Dis­trict’s closed primary sys­tem, more than a sixth of the city’s voters will not have a real choice for may­or.

Wash­ing­ton has had a closed primary since it began hold­ing loc­al elec­tions in 1974, mean­ing that only voters re­gistered with a par­tic­u­lar party can vote in that party’s primary. In D.C., al­though you can re­gister to vote at a polling sta­tion on Elec­tion Day, voters can­not change their party af­fil­i­ation with­in 30 days be­fore the elec­tion — around the time the av­er­age voter ac­tu­ally real­izes that an elec­tion is ap­proach­ing. The former op­tion, it should be noted, of­fers a sol­id work-around for col­lege stu­dents and oth­ers re­gistered as in­de­pend­ents in oth­er states.

Former May­or Ad­ri­an Fenty fought in 2010 to change the rules to al­low un­af­fili­ated voters to switch their party re­gis­tra­tion on Elec­tion Day, but lost. That pro­pos­al was op­posed by his then-op­pon­ent Vin­cent Gray, and we all know how that turned out. City Coun­cil mem­ber Dav­id Grosso pro­posed a sim­il­ar meas­ure this month — not­ably with the sup­port­ive of may­or­al can­did­ates Tommy Wells, a Demo­crat, and Catania, a Re­pub­lic­an-turned-in­de­pend­ent. But that bill didn’t go any­where either.

Closed primary elec­tions are hardly unique to the Dis­trict of Columbia. Twenty-three states in ad­di­tion to the Dis­trict of Columbia have closed primar­ies (al­though in Alaska, Idaho, Kan­sas, and South Dakota, only the Re­pub­lic­an primar­ies are closed).

From the party’s per­spect­ive, this sys­tem makes per­fect sense. The parties want their most faith­ful voters de­cid­ing which can­did­ate will face the op­pos­ing party in the gen­er­al elec­tion. What’s more, the Re­pub­lic­an Party, for ex­ample, wor­ries that Demo­crat­ic voters will cast bal­lots in their primary elec­tion in fa­vor of the can­did­ate who doesn’t stand a chance against the lead­ing Demo­crat. And vice versa.

This happened mem­or­ably in Michigan in 2012, when about 10 per­cent of Re­pub­lic­an primary voters were ac­tu­ally re­gistered as Demo­crats. Former Sen. Rick San­tor­um even paid for robo-calls in the state that urged Demo­crats to vote for him in the Re­pub­lic­an primary in or­der to take a stand against Mitt Rom­ney, who was well on his way to nab­bing the party’s pres­id­en­tial nom­in­a­tion.

Clearly, that’s less of an is­sue in the Dis­trict of Columbia where the vast ma­jor­ity of re­gistered voters are Demo­crats. Wash­ing­ton’s few re­gistered Re­pub­lic­ans, eas­ily re­cog­nized by their Stand With Rand stick­ers and their Ted Cruz tat­toos (here’s look­ing at you, Scott Green­berg), could hardly sway an elec­tion. About 6 per­cent of re­gistered voters in the city (roughly 27,000 people) identi­fy them­selves as Re­pub­lic­ans.

Giv­en that this is Wash­ing­ton (or should we say, “This Town”), hun­dreds, if not thou­sands, of those in­de­pend­ent voters are likely journ­al­ists, like my­self, who of­ten re­gister sans party in or­der to avoid con­cerns about par­tis­an­ship in their work. Some, par­tic­u­larly of the old school, don’t vote at all.

In truth, my in­de­pend­ent status has noth­ing to do with my ca­reer. As a seni­or in high school fas­cin­ated by elect­or­al polit­ics, I chose to re­gister un­af­fili­ated (through MTV’s Rock the Vote web­site, nat­ur­ally) as a small protest of my home state of Wash­ing­ton’s closed primary sys­tem. The state has since done away with closed primar­ies in fa­vor of a top-two sys­tem. As I like to tell my friends and cowork­ers, I showed them.

But many in­de­pend­ents are just av­er­age voters, frus­trated with the party sys­tem. There are even some true in­de­pend­ents, who find them­selves some­where in the gray area between the Re­pub­lic­an and Demo­crat­ic parties. Should they not be able to vote for a Re­pub­lic­an when they feel the party is best aligned with their feel­ings or a Demo­crat when a can­did­ate truly speaks to them?

When I ex­plained to my room­mate, who moved from Lon­don to Wash­ing­ton last year, why I wouldn’t be able to vote in the elec­tion we’ve been dis­cuss­ing all week, she called it “un­demo­crat­ic.” Yes, a Brit­ish per­son called an Amer­ic­an vot­ing sys­tem un­demo­crat­ic. And she has a point. Walk­ing down to the Tid­al Basin this af­ter­noon, I wouldn’t be sur­prised to see that the statue of Thomas Jef­fer­son had fallen over on its back.

What We're Following See More »
WHITE HOUSE URGING QUICK SENATE ACTION
John King Gets Nod for Education Secretary
1 hours ago
THE DETAILS

President Obama has said he’ll nominate John King to fill out the last few months of Obama’s presidency as Secretary of Education. King has been in an acting secretary role since Arne Duncan stepped down in December. The White House is pressuring the Senate to act quickly on the nomination.

Source:
162,000 SIGNATURES SO FAR
Sanders Supporters Begin to Petition Superdelegates
1 hours ago
WHY WE CARE

Bernie Sanders supporters aren’t taking this whole superdelegate thing lying down. Despite a tie a blowout win against Hillary Clinton, Sanders trails her by some 350 delegates in the overall count, thanks mostly to superdelegates pledging to support her. His backers have taken to creating a MoveOn.org petition to pressure the superdelegates to be flexible. It reads: “Commit to honoring the voters—let everyone know that you won’t allow your vote to defeat our votes. Announce that in the event of a close race, you’ll align yourself with regular voters—not party elites.” So far it’s attracted 162,000 signatures.

Source:
REGULAR ORDER
Ryan Pitching the Importance of Passing a Budget Today
1 hours ago
THE LATEST

House Speaker Paul Ryan today is trying to convince his large but divided conference that they need to pass a budget under regular order. “Conservatives are revolting against higher top-line spending levels negotiated last fall by President Obama and Ryan’s predecessor, then-Speaker John Boehner (R-OH). GOP centrists are digging in on the other side, pledging to kill any budget that deviates from the two-year, bipartisan budget deal.” Ryan’s three options are to lower the budget numbers to appease the Freedom Caucus, “deem” a budget and move on to the appropriations process, or “preserve Obama-Boehner levels, but seek savings elsewhere.”

Source:
HEADED TO PRESIDENT’S DESK
Trade Bill Would Ban Imports Made with Slave Labor
2 hours ago
THE DETAILS

“A bill headed for President Barack Obama this week includes a provision that would ban U.S. imports of fish caught by slaves in Southeast Asia, gold mined by children in Africa and garments sewn by abused women in Bangladesh, closing a loophole in an 85-year-old tariff law.” The Senate approved the bill, which would also ban Internet taxes and overhaul trade laws, by a vote of 75-20. It now goes to President Obama.

Source:
TRUMP UP TO 44%
Sanders Closes to Within Seven Nationally in New Poll
2 hours ago
THE LATEST

Bernie Sanders has closed to within seven points of Hillary Clinton in a new Morning Consult survey. Clinton leads 46%-39%. Consistent with the New Hampshire voting results, Clinton does best with retirees, while Sanders leads by 20 percentage points among those under 30. On the Republican side, Donald Trump is far ahead with 44% support. Trailing by a huge margin are Ted Cruz (17%), Ben Carson (10%) and Marco Rubio (10%).

Source:
×