Documentary on Obesity Lacks Policy Muscle

“Fed Up” focuses on the food industry’s failure to dish up nutritious options.

National Journal
Jerry Hagstrom
May 11, 2014, 6:28 a.m.

This week­end, Fed Up, a doc­u­ment­ary that hopes to en­cour­age a fight against obesity, opens in New York, Wash­ing­ton, and oth­er cit­ies. It’s be­ing heav­ily pro­moted by its pro­du­cers, TV journ­al­ist Katie Cour­ic and Laurie Dav­id, the pro­du­cer of An In­con­veni­ent Truth, the doc­u­ment­ary about former Vice Pres­id­ent Al Gore’s cam­paign about cli­mate change.

Fed Up has good in­ten­tions and raises val­id is­sues, but it is al­most two hours long and is so broad in its con­dem­na­tion of the food in­dustry that it’s ques­tion­able wheth­er it will find a view­er­ship bey­ond the people who already agree with the pro­du­cers’ view­point, or wheth­er it will have any im­pact on pub­lic policy.

The film, which was pre­viewed last week in a theat­er in the Cap­it­ol Vis­it­or’s Cen­ter, starts out by blam­ing the food in­dustry for the obesity epi­dem­ic. When nu­tri­tion­ists dis­cour­aged people from eat­ing fat, the food in­dustry re­spon­ded by put­ting more sweeten­ers in food to make it tasti­er, the film says. When people took up the re­com­mend­a­tion to drink skim milk, the dairy in­dustry re­spon­ded by mak­ing and mar­ket­ing more cheese, the film con­tin­ues. The idea that people can bal­ance what they eat with ex­er­cise is wrong, the film­makers say, be­cause it is im­possible to ex­er­cise enough to work off the cal­or­ies.

People who are over­weight from eat­ing these foods should not blame them­selves but the in­dustry for their con­stant ad­vert­ising, par­tic­u­larly to chil­dren, a series of aca­dem­ic ex­perts and food journ­al­ists say in the film.

But Fed Up then di­min­ishes these points through a series of in­ter­views with obese work­ing-class chil­dren about their struggles and fail­ures to lose weight. While the film makes the point that the chil­dren are ex­posed to ad­vert­ising, the scenes of these fam­il­ies seem to say that work­ing-class people just can’t make good food choices or get ex­er­cise.

Fed Up con­tains some fant­ast­ic graph­ics about how the body ab­sorbs food, but its worst as­pect is the ap­par­ent lack of un­der­stand­ing about how pub­lic policy is made. The film ac­know­ledges that first lady Michelle Obama raised the is­sue of child­hood obesity, but it pretty much de­clares her “Let’s Move” cam­paign a fail­ure be­cause it fo­cuses on ex­er­cise and be­cause she has worked with food com­pan­ies rather than op­pos­ing them.

Left­ist crit­ics have of­ten said that it was a mis­take for the first lady to try to con­vince the food com­pan­ies to re­for­mu­late their products. But as Sam Kass, the as­sist­ant White House chef who also heads the Let’s Move cam­paign and ad­vises the ad­min­is­tra­tion on nu­tri­tion, said at a re­cent Con­sumer Fed­er­a­tion of Amer­ica con­fer­ence that the idea “that we could change the food without work­ing with the people who are feed­ing every­body just doesn’t make any sense to me.”

The film ac­know­ledges that the 2010 Healthy Hun­ger-Free Kids Act — which re­quires schools to re­duce sug­ar and so­di­um and serve lower-fat meat and dairy products, whole-grain breads, and lots of fruits and ve­get­ables — man­dates health­i­er school meals. But it fo­cuses on the two is­sues on which nu­tri­tion­ists failed to pre­vail in that bill: the des­ig­na­tion of to­mato paste on pizza as a ve­get­able and the un­lim­ited use of pota­toes as a ve­get­able. Fed Up does not ac­know­ledge that the Healthy Hun­ger-Free Kids Act is one hard-fought battle that nu­tri­tion­ists won with the help of the White House. It also doesn’t men­tion that the new school-meal rules are strong enough that the School Nu­tri­tion As­so­ci­ation, which rep­res­ents school-meal pre­parers, and some stu­dents are ur­ging Con­gress to roll back the new rules when child-nu­tri­tion pro­grams come up for reau­thor­iz­a­tion in 2015.

Per­haps the most frus­trat­ing as­pect of Fed Up is that, while it blames big food con­glom­er­ates for the obesity prob­lem, it doesn’t give cred­it to people who have con­fron­ted the food in­dustry and doesn’t of­fer any new ideas on how to ad­dress obesity in pub­lic policy oth­er than big­ger la­beling on soda cans for sug­ar con­tent. Dav­id said at the Cap­it­ol Hill screen­ing, “Whatever is­sue you’re work­ing on, [Fed Up] will help move that agenda.”

Cour­ic is chal­len­ging people to give up all sug­ar for 10 days, though the prop­er term would be sweeten­ers, be­cause she has said she means high-fructose corn syr­up, honey, and juice or ar­ti­fi­cial sweeten­ers. Cour­ic is start­ing the chal­lenge her­self on Monday. That may be a good way to get people to talk about the film, but what hap­pens after 10 days? Are people sup­posed to give up all sweeten­er-con­tain­ing products forever?

As people who are well-con­nec­ted in the en­ter­tain­ment in­dustry, Cour­ic, Dav­id and Fed Up dir­ect­or Stephanie Soechtig have big plans for their film. Soechtig said at the brief­ing that a Span­ish-lan­guage ver­sion will be re­leased this Fri­day, and she has plans for a short­er ver­sion that can be shown in schools.

If the movie is shown in schools, the food in­dustry will un­doubtedly de­mand equal time or pro­duce a com­pet­ing film. It looks like it will be left up to the tech­ers to point out that the feel­ings of rage that Fed Up seems in­clined to cre­ate are use­less un­less they lead to the step-by-step ac­tions that might ac­tu­ally re­duce obesity.

What We're Following See More »
11 HOUSE MEMBERS NOW BEHIND HIM
Two Committee Chairs Endorse Trump
7 hours ago
WHY WE CARE

Two powerful House members—Transportation and Infrastructure Committee Chairman Bill Shuster (R-PA) and Veterans Affairs Committee Chair Jeff Miller (R-FL)—are throwing their support behind Donald Trump.

Source:
BUT WOULD HE THROW THE CHAIR?
Bobby Knight: Trump Would Drop the Bomb Just Like Truman
7 hours ago
THE LATEST
LAST PLACE
Trump Still Struggling for Endorsements
10 hours ago
WHY WE CARE
AT ISSUE: VENEZUELA SANCTIONS
Deal Struck to Confirm Ambassador to Mexico
11 hours ago
WHY WE CARE

"The United States is finally about to get an ambassador to Mexico. Senate Republicans who have been negotiating a way to confirm Roberta Jacobson as the nation’s top diplomat to Mexico have reached the contours of an agreement that would allow Sen. Marco Rubio (R-FL)—Jacobson’s chief obstacle—to secure renewed sanctions against Venezuela in exchange for lifting his objections."

Source:
MORE INDEPENDENTS, FEWER SUPERDELEGATES
Sanders Could Force Changes to Nominating Process
12 hours ago
THE LATEST

There are not "ongoing, direct conversations between" the Bernie Sanders camp and the Hillary Clinton camp regarding "the platform or rules changes," but Sanders "is already making his opening arguments" about those issues on the stump. Sanders is putting "complaints about closed primaries" atop his stump speeches lately, and figures to start a "conversation about the role of superdelegates in the nominating process." He said, “Our goal, whether we win or we do not win, is to transform the Democratic Party."

Source:
×