Skip Navigation

Close and don't show again.

Your browser is out of date.

You may not get the full experience here on National Journal.

Please upgrade your browser to any of the following supported browsers:

Reveal Navigation

If You Don't Allow Government Cameras in Your Home, Will Terrorists Win? If You Don't Allow Government Cameras in Your Home, Will Terroris... If You Don't Allow Government Cameras in Your Home, Will Terrorists Wi... If You Don't Allow Govern...

share
This ad will end in seconds
 
Close X

Not a member? Learn More »

Forget Your Password?

Don't have an account? Register »

Reveal Navigation
 

 

Politics

If You Don't Allow Government Cameras in Your Home, Will Terrorists Win?

Reader's analogy raises question of how far we can bend Constitution before it breaks.

Would you trade your own privacy for a promise of security?(Chet Susslin)

Would you let the government install a camera in your home?

The question was posed to me by Mike Cregan, a reader from Santa Barbara, Calif., who owns a foreign trade business. He writes: "When people say, `Well, they don't get into the calls, etc. unless they have a court order,' they miss the larger point."

Cregan then offers an analogy that cuts through public ambivalence about the National Security Agency's massive spying dragnet.

 

"It is like the government saying, `We are going to put a camera in everyone's home.  But, don't worry, we aren't going to turn it on unless a court gives us the OK.'"

Don't worry. That is the central defense of President Obama and the NSA: We will blanket your telephone and Internet activity with an electronic net, but we won't listen or otherwise pry without court permission. A secret court, issuing secret rulings. Trust us.

Cregan continues:

"No, I don't want a camera in my house in the first place.  And, I don't want my Internet or phone records in the government's possession in the first place.  The potential for abuse FAR outweighs the benefit.  The abuse that could be done, in the wrong hands, is absolutely huge."

Americans should consider such logic before agreeing to further abuses of their civil liberties.  The United States must exploit the flexibility of its Constitution to adapt to 21st century threats, but Cregan's email is a fresh reminder of the threshold question: How far do we stretch the Constitution before it breaks?

The public's ambivalence is summed up nicely in the final paragraph of a New York Times story today, "N.S.A. Chief Says Phone Record Logs Halted Terror Threats." The paragraph reads:

"Public opinion, judging by two polls with differently worded questions that yielded different results, is divided over the government's tracking of the communications of Americans. In a Pew Research Center/Washington Post poll conducted June 6-9, 56 percent of Americans said the N.S.A's program tracking the phone records of "millions of Americans" was an acceptable way to investigate terrorism, while 41 percent said it was unacceptable. But a CBS News poll conducted June 9-10, which instead asked about collecting phone records of "ordinary Americans," found that just 38 percent supported it and 58 percent opposed it."

And there you have it. Americans are fine with invading the privacy of people in the abstract – "millions of Americans" vaguely targets all the evil doers.

But when the question is asked in a way that personalizes NSA's targets ("ordinary Americans") it hits, well, closer to home.

You May Find These of Interest
Get us in your feed.
Job Board
Search Jobs
Project Manager II
American Society of Civil Engineers | Memphis, TN
Structural Engineer
American Society of Civil Engineers | Chicago, IL
Engineering Manager
American Society of Civil Engineers | Springfield, VA
Mechanical Engineer - Dallas, TX
American Society of Civil Engineers | Dallas, TX
Concrete Testing Technician & Special Inspectors
American Society of Civil Engineers | New York, NY
Manager of Engineering
American Society of Civil Engineers | Berkeley, CA
Structural Engineer
American Society of Civil Engineers | Orlando, FL
Engineer
American Society of Civil Engineers | Lake Charles, LA
Watershed Resources Specialist
American Society of Civil Engineers | San Francisco, CA
Outside sales.
American Society of Civil Engineers | San Francisco, CA
Mgr, Corp Qual Technology
American Society of Civil Engineers | Fort Worth, TX
Administrative Assistant
American Society of Civil Engineers | Cleveland, OH
Project Engineer
American Society of Civil Engineers | Atlanta, GA
Instrumentation and Controls Engineer â?? Gainesville, FL US
American Society of Civil Engineers | Gainesville, FL
VP, Engineering & Construction
American Society of Civil Engineers | Boston, MA
 
Comments
comments powered by Disqus