COMMENTARY

A Textbook Example of the Right's Epistemic Closure

After populating his Twitter feed with hundreds of conservatives, John Hinderaker concludes that conservatives dominate the medium.

May 16, 2012 | 11:42 a.m.

On Twitter, I follow 308 feeds, and from what I see, it's exactly the sorts of people I follow who dominate the Twittersphere. Day after day, theirs are the most clever tweets I run across; when they draw attention to exchanges with outsiders they always seem to get the better of them. From my vantage, it even seems like folks frustrated with both partisan teams are especially suited to the medium.  

John Hinderaker is on Twitter too. He follows 458 people. The vast majority are conservatives whose work he likes. And guess what? "The Right is clobbering the Left on Twitter," he writes. "Maybe it's because Twitter puts a premium on brevity and cleverness. I don't know. But for some reason, it seems to be a natural medium for conservatives." It would seem that way if the feed you curated included thousands of daily tweets from your favorite conservatives and only a handful from liberals, some of whom -- Snoop Dogg, for example -- you're probably following on a lark.



Latest Politics Posts:
Loading feed...


Says Hinderaker, "Currently, the White House is promoting #AskMichelle, where loyal Democrats can go to ask the first lady a question. Only, nearly all of the questions have come from conservatives." From this he concludes, "You almost feel sorry for the White House. They're going to have to either do a better job of mobilizing their supporters on Twitter or abandon the medium altogether." 
As of this writing, President Obama's official campaign Twitter account has 15,451,740 followers. Michelle Obama has 891,729 followers. I'm thinking they won't have to abandon the medium. 

Musing on the supposed conservative Twitter advantage, Hinderaker adds: "We saw it when the Hilary Rosen interview ('Ann Romney never worked a day in her life') prompted a Twitterstorm. We saw it again when #ObamaEatsDogs exploded, and when #Julia blew up in the White House's face like an exploding cigar." Of course, Hinderaker only sees the successful conservative Twitter memes because they're the ones that circulate among the conservatives he follows. Meanwhile, Mitt Romney has 499,989 Twitter followers, or roughly 15 million fewer than his opponent, and almost 400,000 fewer than his opponent's wife. Is it really so clear that "the Left is getting clobbered on Twitter"? 

Doug Mataconis points out that dominating Twitter and its memes is probably meaningless, even when it happens. He's probably right. But I still think Hinderaker's post is worth noting because it's such a perfect example of someone self-consciously curating an ideologically skewed information stream and then reflexively presuming that what they see there obviously reflects reality.

Whereas the actual reality of who dominates Twitter is as follows:

  • Lady Gaga (24.1 million followers)
  • Justin Bieber (21.7 million)
  • Katy Perry (19.5 million)
  • Rihanna (18.8 million)

Get the latest news and analysis delivered to your inbox. Sign up for National Journal's morning alert, Wake-Up Call, and afternoon newsletter, The Edge. Subscribe here.


Leave A Comment
The National Journal Group has the right (but not the obligation) to monitor the comments and to remove any materials it deems inappropriate.
Comments powered by Disqus
Follow National Journal
Related Content
Expert Opinions
Transportation Experts

Do We Suddenly Hate Driving?

5:16 p.m.

Latest Response by Phineas Baxandall: It's About Waste, Not Hate

Transportation Experts

Do We Suddenly Hate Driving?

3:19 p.m.

Latest Response by James Corless: Time to adapt to the new reality

Energy Experts

What's at Stake with Natural-Gas Exports?

11:51 a.m.

Latest Response by Bill Cooper: U.S. Should Quickly Approve Other Apps

More Expert Opinions »
Columns
Reid Wilson: On the Trail

Parties Push For House Retirements

6:00 a.m.
Campaign committees utilize scare tactics to pressure members to step aside.
Norm Ornstein: Washington Inside Out

GOP’s Switch on Financial Disclosure Wins Gold Medal in Hypocrisy Olympics

9:30 p.m.
The IRS scandal evolved from the broader reality that the GOP has changed its financing mantra from “disclosure” to “secrecy.”
Major Garrett: All Powers

Obama Pushes to Accommodate, Not Protect, Freedom of the Press

May 21, 2013
The Justice Department’s secret subpoena of AP phone logs begs questions about Obama’s attitude toward the First Amendment and government scrutiny.
More Columns »