Skip Navigation

Close and don't show again.

Your browser is out of date.

You may not get the full experience here on National Journal.

Please upgrade your browser to any of the following supported browsers:

Should Consumers Bear the Cost to Upgrade the Grid? Should Consumers Bear the Cost to Upgrade the Grid?

This ad will end in seconds
Close X

Want access to this content? Learn More »

Forget Your Password?

Don't have an account? Register »

Reveal Navigation


Should Consumers Bear the Cost to Upgrade the Grid?


The electric grid is in need of an update. But who should pay for improvements?(Justin Sullivan/Getty Images)

Given that it will cost upward of $4 trillion over the next 20 years to modernize electricity, gas, and water lines, is it OK to allow utilities to tack on extra charges to customers' bills to pay for those upgrades? How can customers voice their opinions? The first question is one that utility regulators deal with on a daily basis. The second question is only just beginning to surface.

Every time a utility wants to add extra charges to utility bills for a system upgrade, a state public utility commission has to weigh whether the proposed upgrade is necessary and whether the company has done its due diligence in maintaining its current infrastructure. Then the commission has to consider whether the utility can or should pay for the upgrade without a surcharge. And, finally, it has to determine whether the amount of the proposed surcharge is too high. It's a long, detailed legal process that can take months (or years) to finish.


"There is no easy booklet that I can refer to as a regulator, like a flow chart that says, 'If this occurs, you give them their money. If this occurs, you do not give them their money,' " said Colette Honorable, the president of the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners in a feature story on utility surcharges that recently ran in National Journal magazine.

Regulators are well aware that granting a utility's request for a surcharge can be a double-edged sword. It gives the utilities access to capital and cheaper financing, but it also puts an extra burden on consumers who are not responsible for maintaining reliable service. Still, pipelines and power lines don't last forever, and replacing them requires a massive investment that can't be recouped with basic charges for the use of a utility. Moreover, the United States is experiencing frequent severe-weather events that cause prolonged power outages at a time when people are more attached than ever to their devices.

The public, for the most part, isn't involved in the details of utility-rate setting. The entire system is out of sight and out of mind as long as the lights come on. Power outages are often the first time that customers turn their attention to a utility and its regulators. The lack of public attention at other times insulates the utilities, the regulators, and the consumer advocates who are supposed to be watching over them. That's not good for anyone.


Customers can get involved in utility-rate issues, but it requires a little more commitment than complaining to a consumer affairs department once or twice a year. All commission deliberations are available online for anyone to peruse. Local elected officials generally are in contact with regulators and utilities, and their involvement can spur public hearings and forums. The commissions often have their own hearings, and they are willing to accept testimony from the guy on the street as part of their case-setting record. (That's not a regular request, however.)

Should utilities be allowed to seek extra charges for upgrades to the power grid? Should those charges be spelled out in separate line items? What kinds of upgrades should a utility make on its own, without asking the public to pitch in? When is it appropriate to seek a surcharge? How can regulators and customers communicate? What should customers know if they want to get involved?

Don't Miss Today's Top Stories

Exactly what I need as a busy college student."

Samantha, Student

Sign up form for the newsletter

From the Energy Insiders

comments powered by Disqus