• National Journal.com
  • Sign In

  • My Account | Free Trial

    Submit site feedback

nationaljournal.com > Interactive

    • Home
    • The Magazine
    • The Hotline
    • CongressDaily
    • 3121
  • Sunday, Nov. 8, 2009
INTERACTIVE REPORT

The Health Care Dividing Lines

Did Representatives Of The Nation's Most Uninsured Districts Vote For Health Care Reform?
Story By Jason Plautz, Graphic By Charlie Szymanski

Saturday, November 7, 2009

In a close vote on the House health care plan Saturday, legislators voted largely along party lines and analysis from NationalJournal.com shows that the uninsured population of a representative's district had little influence on their vote.

The plan, which would extend health care coverage to 36 million Americans and cost nearly $1.1 trillion over 10 years, passed by a narrow 220-215 vote. Only one Republican -- Anh “Joseph” Cao of Louisiana -- voted for the bill, and 39 Democrats voted against it.

The interactive table below allows readers to analyze the vote from a variety of angles, including the members' margin of victory, whether Barack Obama or John McCain carried their district last year, and whether their state's percentage of uninsured residents is above or below the national average.

Story Continues Below Graphic

Advertisement



More About This Graphic

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2008 American Community Survey.

Sort members by party, percentage of uninsured constituents, their district's choice in the 2008 presidential race or whether they supported the reform bill in committee. Hold Ctrl and click another column to sort again by that variable.

Related Story: The New Geography Of Health Care

Related Story: The Climate Dividing Lines

Related Section: Health Care Briefing


However, the population of uninsured Americans seemed to have little influence on the vote. According to data from the Census Bureau's 2008 American Community Survey, 101 congressmen from districts where the rate of the uninsured was above the national average voted against the bill. That's compared to only 96 representatives from districts with an uninsured population above the national average that voted for the bill. On the other side, 124 representatives from districts where less than the national average are uninsured voted for the bill compared to just 114 against.

Of the 193 districts that went to McCain, 175 voted against the bill, including 31 McCain districts represented by a Democrat. Fiscally conservative Democrats were also split on the bill: Among the centrist Blue Dogs, 27 voted for the bill and 24 voted against even after Speaker Nancy Pelosi, D-Calif., amended the public option portion to garner their votes.

Moderate Democrats were drawn to the bill after the passage of an amendment from Rep. Bart Stupak, D-Mich., which would bar federal funds from being used for abortions. Sixty-four Democrats joined Republicans in voting for the amendment, including Michael Michaud of Maine and John Salazar of Colorado, moderates who ended up voting for the final bill.

Cao, the lone Republican vote for the bill, helped Democrats overcome the loss of 39 party members and push the support over the 218-vote threshold. Cao's district, which went for Obama, has 21.7 percent of the population uninsured.

The historic vote marked the further progress for a health care reform bill, a staple of Obama's domestic agenda. Speaking after the vote, Pelosi said, “This legislation will mean affordability for the middle-class, security for our seniors, and honors our responsibility to our children, adding not one dime to the deficit.”


Staff Contact Employment Reprints & Back Issues Privacy Policy Advertising Terms of Service
Copyright 2009 by National Journal Group Inc. The Watergate 600 New Hampshire Ave., NW Washington, DC 20037
202-739-8400 · fax 202-833-8069 NationalJournal.com is an Atlantic Media publication.